Leveraging the Value of Project Scope Growth through Construction Manager-at-Risk Delivery of Public University Capital Improvement Projects
- 1 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 14 (1) , 04521042
Abstract
When capital improvement project final costs exceed initial estimates, the overrun is assumed to be an indication of poor performance. However, when a project owner adds scope at any point after the initial estimate, the value of the project is enhanced, even though the numbers are interpreted in a negative light. This paper explores the idea that construction manager-at-risk (CMR) delivery provides a level of contractual flexibility that is not available in traditional design-bid-build (DBB) contracts and, consequently, lends itself to projects in which additional funding may become available after contract award and facilitates the efficient use of such funds in a manner not available in DBB-delivered projects. This study reviewed the cost performance of 166 CMR and DBB projects completed by 23 American public universities valued at over $3 billion from 2018 to 2019. The study found that cost growth in university CMR projects was greater than in similar DBB projects, contradicting the conclusions of most of the literature on CMR. The analysis of a second sample of 86 projects, which individually compared DBB projects with similar CMR projects, found that CMR project design fee efficiency was double that of DBB. The first contribution of this study is the provision of an objective metric for differentiating between owner-driven scope cost growth and cost growth due to other reasons; the second contribution is the finding that the contractual flexibility inherent to CMR project delivery adds value for money by allowing a university to expeditiously obligate new sources of funding, such as donations.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effective Tools for Projects Delivered by Construction Manager–General Contractor MethodTransportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2012
- Selection of Project Delivery Method in Transit: Drivers and ObjectivesJournal of Management in Engineering, 2011
- Construction Delivery Systems: A Comparative Analysis of Their Performance within School DistrictsJournal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2006
- Design Fees, the State of the Profession, and a Time for Corrective ActionJournal of Management in Engineering, 2005
- Class Noise vs. Attribute Noise: A Quantitative StudyArtificial Intelligence Review, 2004
- Quantifying the causes and costs of rework in constructionConstruction Management and Economics, 2000
- Quality practices in design organizationsConstruction Management and Economics, 1999
- Scope Management Using Project Definition Rating IndexJournal of Management in Engineering, 1997
- Relationship between Project Interaction and Performance IndicatorsJournal of Construction Engineering and Management, 1996
- The Concept of Value for MoneyInternational Journal of Public Sector Management, 1988