Winners’ Restraint or Affective Majoritarianism? Elections, Polarization and Political Support
Open Access
- 29 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Comparative Political Studies
- Vol. 59 (14) , 3227-3261
Abstract
Research on the impact of elections on attitudes toward democracy has focused primarily on satisfaction with democracy. Building on this, we analyze how winning and losing elections, along with affective polarization, shapes citizens’ support for norms of democratic restraint and consent. We propose that partisan animus weakens the “reservoir of goodwill” that helps citizens accept democratic norms that may go against their self interest. Using a comparative study of 35 elections and two quasi-experimental case studies, we find that while differences between winners and losers in their support for norms of restraint and consent can be statistically significant, they are substantively small compared to several benchmarks, even in highly polarized contexts. Thus, while satisfaction with democracy is notably shaped by winner-loser dynamics, especially when polarization is high, the impact of those dynamics on support for core democratic principles is limited. These findings improve our understanding of the role of citizens in democratic processes.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- European Union (101042292)
- Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (PID2022-137516NA-I00)
- Catalan Institution for Research and Advanced Studies
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- The dynamics of political and affective polarisation: Datasets for Spain, Portugal, Italy, Argentina, and Chile (2019-2022)Data in Brief, 2023
- Affective polarization and the salience of electionsElectoral Studies, 2021
- Affective polarization in multiparty systemsElectoral Studies, 2021
- Enemy Mine: Negative Partisanship and Satisfaction with DemocracyPolitical Behavior, 2020
- Changes in Mental Health Following the 2016 Presidential ElectionJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2020
- Modeling the evolution of winner and loser effects: A survey and prospectusMathematical Biosciences, 2016
- Electoral losers revisited – How citizens react to defeat at the ballot boxElectoral Studies, 2011
- Emotional dynamics of soccer fans at winning and losing gamesPersonality and Individual Differences, 2005
- Affective responses to success and failure:Personality and Individual Differences, 1999
- The Impact of Fan Attitudes on Intentions to Watch Professional Basketball Teams on TelevisionSport Management Review, 1999