Invisible attitudes have visible effects on the behaviour of animals in scientific studies
Open Access
- 10 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Animal Cognition
- Vol. 29 (1)
Abstract
Animal behaviour research requires measures to avoid human influences on the investigated animals. While efforts to minimize experimenter biases have primarily focused on reducing explicit expectancy effects, the impact of human attitudes on animal behaviour, particularly on the unconscious level, remains largely unstudied in research contexts. Here we show that experienced animal handlers’ explicit (conscious) and implicit (unconscious) attitudes influenced the behaviour of similarly raised, human-socialized dogs and wolves during commonly used sociability tests. Explicit attitudes shaped animals’ affiliative and discomfort behaviour, while implicit attitudes affected handlers’ heart rate variability which, in turn, modulated animal affiliation. Notably, explicit and implicit attitudes were uncorrelated, highlighting that they may have had different effects. While wolves reacted more to human attitude and physiology than dogs, time series analyses revealed that the behavioural influence between both canid species and humans was strong and reciprocal. Our findings highlight the subtle yet powerful role of human conscious and unconscious attitudes in shaping animals’ behaviour in research and beyond, potentially creating artifacts and skewing reported differences between species or populations. Our results raise concerns about findings in comparative cognition and behaviour research, emphasizing the need for more appropriate control of attitude-related experimenter bias.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna
This publication has 62 references indexed in Scilit:
- On the (limited) use of touchscreen-based behavioural and cognitive research with dogs: potential causes and future directionsAnimal Cognition, 2026
- Differences in dogs’ and wolves’ human-directed greeting behaviour: facial expressions, body language, and the problem of human biasesAnimal Cognition, 2025
- Wolves and Dogs2022
- Implicit and Explicit Gender Stereotypes at the Bargaining Table: Male Counterparts’ Stereotypes Predict Women’s Lower Performance in Dyadic Face-to-Face NegotiationsSex Roles, 2020
- Sociability and gazing toward humans in dogs and wolves: Simple behaviors with broad implicationsJournal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 2016
- Observer bias in animal behaviour research: can we believe what we score, if we score what we believe?Animal Behaviour, 2014
- Measuring Nonverbal Bias Through Body Language Responses to StereotypesJournal of Nonverbal Behavior, 2014
- Handler beliefs affect scent detection dog outcomesAnimal Cognition, 2011
- Attachment to humans: a comparative study on hand-reared wolves and differently socialized dog puppiesAnimal Behaviour, 2005
- Improving the attitude and behaviour of stockpersons towards pigs and the consequences on the behaviour and reproductive performance of commercial pigsApplied Animal Behaviour Science, 1994