ABAndreas Berghänel

Andreas Berghänel

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Andreas Berghänel has a total of 154 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Invisible attitudes have visible effects on the behaviour of animals in scientific studies

    by Svenja Capitain, Gwendolyn Wirobski, Catherine-Noémie Alexandrina Guran, Andreas Berghänel, Claus Lamm, Sarah Marshall-Pescini, Friederike Range

    Animal behaviour research requires measures to avoid human influences on the investigated animals. While efforts to minimize experimenter biases have primarily focused on reducing explicit expectancy effects, the impact of human attitudes on animal behaviour, particularly on the unconscious level, remains largely unstudied in research contexts. Here we show that experienced animal handlers’ explicit (conscious) and implicit (unconscious) attitudes influenced the behaviour of similarly raised, human-socialized dogs and wolves during commonly used sociability tests. Explicit attitudes shaped animals’ affiliative and discomfort behaviour, while implicit attitudes affected handlers’ heart rate variability which, in turn, modulated animal affiliation. Notably, explicit and implicit attitudes were uncorrelated, highlighting that they may have had different effects. While wolves reacted more to human attitude and physiology than dogs, time series analyses revealed that the behavioural influence between both canid species and humans was strong and reciprocal. Our findings highlight the subtle yet powerful role of human conscious and unconscious attitudes in shaping animals’ behaviour in research and beyond, potentially creating artifacts and skewing reported differences between species or populations. Our results raise concerns about findings in comparative cognition and behaviour research, emphasizing the need for more appropriate control of attitude-related experimenter bias.

  • Open Access

    A Direct Observation of Infanticide by a Female Free‐Ranging Dog ( Canis familiaris ) Supports the Resource Competition Hypothesis

    by Melissa Vanderheyden, Brenda Chaignon, Clément Car, Małgorzata Pilot, Ikhlass el Berbri, Sarah Marshall‐Pescini, Friederike Range, Andreas Berghänel

    Infanticide by females occurs in many mammalian species but is rarely observed directly, making its social and ecological determinants difficult to identify. Here, we report the first direct observation of within‐pack infanticide by a female free‐ranging domestic dog. To assess whether this case can be better explained by resource competition or nutritional gain, we examined the social context in which it occurred. In our long‐term study population, we identified 26 cases characterised by a similar pattern of overlapping pregnancies within social groups. By comparing dominance rank and birth order across cases, we found that subordinate females time their births after or in synchrony with the alpha female, which may be a strategy to reduce infanticide risk. By giving birth later, the subordinate potentially allows the alpha a competitive advantage, thereby reducing the incentive for infanticide. Furthermore, subordinate free‐ranging dogs may use communal denning as a protective measure, as it hinders the identification of individual litters. In our study, the infanticide followed a period of rank instability. Social rank instability could elevate infanticide risk, since the absence of dominance signals might complicate the subordinate's assessment of the potential threat to its offspring, or because infanticide is used to consolidate dominance. On the other hand, we did not find support for the hypothesis that insufficient nutrition motivated the infanticide, based on an evaluation of the body condition scores within the pack and on the observation that not all killed pups were eaten. Taken together, our preliminary findings suggest that resource competition rather than nutritional gain may better explain infanticide by female free‐ranging dogs.


  • Open Access

    Great Ape Childhoods: Social and Spatial Pathways to Independence in Bonobo and Chimpanzee Infants

    by Jolinde M. R. Vlaeyen, Bas van Boekholt, Franziska Wegdell, Raymond Katumba, Andreas Berghänel, Martin Surbeck, Simone Pika

    Human development is marked by extended immaturity, necessitating extended care throughout infancy and childhood, facilitating advanced cognitive, social, and cultural skill acquisition. Parallels of extended development are also present in our closest living relatives, bonobos ( Pan paniscus ) and chimpanzees ( Pan troglodytes ), which differ markedly in their social systems. Bonobos live in more tolerant, female‐bonded societies, while societies of chimpanzees are more hierarchical, and male‐dominated. These differences in social ecology may thus also shape the pace and nature of early behavioural development. However, systematic, quantitative comparisons of developmental patterns of bonobos and chimpanzees are very limited, and results are conflicting. Hence, this study addressed this crucial gap by systematically examining behavioural development in bonobo and chimpanzee infants living in two populations (Kokolopori community, Kokolopori Bonobo Reserve, DRC, N = 21; Ngogo community, Kibale National Park, Uganda, N = 22) in their natural environments. We specifically focused on infants aged 0–5.5 years and investigated behavioural markers of independence (travel, feeding, grooming) and spatial independence. Our results showed similar developmental trajectories but marked species differences concerning specific social and spatial patterns. While chimpanzee infants exhibited prolonged dorsal riding, bonobo infants travelled independently more often and maintained greater distances from their mothers. In addition, age, sibling presence and maternal parity, but not sex, influenced behavioural patterns. These findings highlight the importance of systematic comparative developmental research across great ape populations for understanding both species‐specific adaptations and the broader evolutionary foundations of extended development in the human lineage.

  • Open Access

    Mating system of free-ranging domestic dogs and its consequences for dog evolution

    by Clément Car, Roya Adavoudi, Andreas Berghänel, Melissa Vanderheyden, Andre E. Moura, Friederike Range, Giulia Cimarelli, Martina Lazzaroni, Rachel Dale, Ikhlass El Berbri, et al.

    The polygamous mating system of free-ranging domestic dogs (FRDs) contrasts with the social monogamy typical of gray wolves and all other wild canids. The transition to polygamy in dogs could have been initiated by a shift from apex predator to human commensal during the early domestication stages. Here, we test this hypothesis by investigating the characteristics of the FRD mating system that could have been important for domestication. This inference is based on genome-wide Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) data from three geographically distinct populations, including behavioral data for one of them. The reconstructed genealogies form a wide network of kinship relationships resulting from the frequent occurrence of maternal and paternal half-siblings, reflecting male and female polygamy. Reproductive success is positively correlated with the strength of social interactions and the number of connections with opposite-sex individuals, implying a preference toward familiar mates and the importance of social relationships in determining mating patterns. This is supported by a nonrandom distribution of reproductive partners and a reproductive skew in males and females. Multiple paternity within litters points to female polygamy within a single estrus, and sexual size dimorphism implies sexual selection favoring larger males. Physiological changes resulting from polygamy, including increased male fertility and reduced breeding seasonality, could have facilitated the natural spread of novel adaptive traits and limited the introgression from wolves. The change in reproductive patterns, typically considered a consequence of selective breeding, could instead have occurred naturally in response to the dietary niche change, triggering further changes that facilitated the domestication process.


  • Open Access

    A direct observation of infanticide by a female free-ranging dog (Canis familiaris) supports the resource competition hypothesis

    by Melissa Vanderheyden, Brenda Chaignon, Clément Car, Małgorzata Pilot, Ikhlass El Berbri, Sarah Marshall-Pescini, Friederike Range, Andreas Berghänel

    Infanticide by females occurs in many mammalian species but is rarely observed directly, making its social and ecological determinants difficult to identify. Here, we report the first direct observation of within-pack infanticide by a female free-ranging domestic dog. To assess whether this case can be better explained by resource competition or nutritional gain, we examined the social context in which it occurred. In our long-term study population, we identified 26 cases characterised by a similar pattern of overlapping pregnancies within social groups. By comparing dominance rank and birth order across cases, we found that subordinate females time their births after or in synchrony with the alpha female, which may be a strategy to reduce infanticide risk. By giving birth later, the subordinate potentially allows the alpha a competitive advantage, thereby reducing the incentive for infanticide. Furthermore, subordinate free-ranging dogs may use communal denning as a protective measure, as it hinders the identification of individual litters. In our study, the infanticide followed a period of rank instability. Social rank instability could elevate infanticide risk, since the absence of dominance signals might complicate the subordinate's assessment of the potential threat to its offspring, or because infanticide is used to consolidate dominance. On the other hand, we did not find support for the hypothesis that insufficient nutrition motivated the infanticide, based on an evaluation of the body condition scores within the pack and on the observation that not all killed pups were eaten. Taken together, our findings suggest that resource competition rather than nutritional gain may better explain infanticide by female free-ranging dogs.

  • Open Access

    Cofeeding at rich clumped food patches in free-ranging dogs: social tolerance or scramble competition?

    by Andreas Berghänel, Martina Lazzaroni, Malgorzata Ferenc, Malgorzata Pilot, Ikhlass el Berbri, Sarah Marshall-Pescini, Friederike Range

    Animals are generally expected to monopolize food patches whenever possible. However, cofeeding within a defendable range occurs in many species, particularly at larger food patches, but the mechanism behind that remains underexplored. In theory, it could be due to multiple, mutually non-exclusive processes. First, larger food patches may saturate multiple top-ranking individuals, enabling cofeeding even under pure contest competition. Second, cofeeding may result from social tolerance where dominant individuals provide cofeeding concessions to certain subordinates. Third, cofeeding may result from prevailing scramble competition (i.e., indirect competition through patch exploitation) caused by large numbers of individuals that prevent monopolization ("swamping"). To investigate and differentiate between these mechanisms, we applied feeding tests to free-ranging dogs in Morocco. We provided them with a large food patch plus a varying number of small food patches. Although the small food patches were virtually always monopolized by single individuals, the dogs typically cofed in large and very dense feeding groups at the large food patches. Controlling for alternative explanations using multivariate statistics, we found that access to feeding groups was independently predicted by rank and social relationship strength, suggesting that contest competition and social tolerance play a role. However, aggression rates by top-rankers decreased with increasing feeding group size, suggesting decreasing monopolizability and increasing scramble competition. Our results underscore that social tolerance may not reduce competition but shifts it from contest to scramble competition. This can be due to active levelling, licensing more individuals access to the resource, but also to loss of control caused by swamping. Significance statement: Although animals are generally expected to fight for resources, they are sometimes observed to cofeed peacefully in large groups. Such peaceful cofeeding is typically ascribed to and taken as a measure of social tolerance, assuming that dominants overcome their impulse to monopolize and make concessions to lower-ranking group members. Alternatively, such large peaceful cofeeding groups may result from swamping where lower-ranking group members overrun dominants as a mob. In this scenario, the dominant individuals simply lose control. Fighting would be pointless and only make them lose feeding time and reduce their share while others are feeding. Studying feedings of free-ranging dogs, we show that aggression by dominants decreases with increasing feeding group size, which supports this alternative explanation and sheds new light on the emergence of cofeeding and social tolerance.


  • Open Access

    Great Ape Childhoods: Development of infant bonobos ( Pan paniscus ) and chimpanzees ( Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii ) in the wild

    by Jolinde M.R. Vlaeyen, Bas van Boekholt, Franziska Wegdell, Raymond Katumba, Andreas Berghänel, Martin Surbeck, Simone Pika

    Human development is marked by extended immaturity, necessitating extended care throughout infancy and childhood, facilitating advanced cognitive, social, and cultural skill acquisition. Parallels of extended development are also present in our closest living relatives, bonobos ( Pan paniscus ) and chimpanzees ( Pan troglodytes ). The Self-Domestication Hypothesis (SDH) suggests that human uniqueness stems from selection against aggression. Bonobos are also considered self-domesticated, exhibiting lower aggression and greater social tolerance, which are linked to delayed development and prolonged maternal dependence compared to chimpanzees. However, systematic, quantitative comparisons of the two species’ developmental patterns are limited and conflicting. This study addressed this gap by examining behavioural development in bonobo and chimpanzee infants aged 0-5.5 years living in two populations (Kokolopori community, Kokolopori Bonobo Reserve, DRC, N=21; Ngogo community, Kibale National Park, Uganda, N=22) in their natural environments. We specifically focused on (i) general behaviours (travel, feeding, grooming), and (ii) spatial independence. By systematically comparing developmental data and using consistent methods, we tested whether bonobo development aligns with SDH predictions. Our results showed similar developmental trajectories, with no species differences concerning ventral riding, nipple contact, or grooming. However, we found species differences regarding travel and proximity patterns, with chimpanzees exhibiting prolonged dorsal riding, bonobos travelling independently more often and maintaining greater distances from their mothers. Age, sibling presence, and maternal parity influenced behavioural patterns, but no sex differences were observed. These findings challenge assumptions of slower bonobo maturation, and highlight the importance of systematic, collaborative research on primate behavioural diversity in natural environments.

  • Open Access

    Socioecology and the role of scramble competition

    by Andreas Berghänel, Sarah Marshall, Friederike Range

    Ecological explanations for social organization and behavior are central to behavioral ecology. Unfortunately, the continuing mismatch between theoretical predictions and some empirical data led to increasingly complex hypotheses with numerous factors, raising doubts about their predictive value or even falsifiability. Moreover, several taxon-specific socioecological hypotheses have been developed that are seemingly detached from one another. We discuss how an integration of different hypotheses may help to clarify theoretical arguments and empirical discrepancies. We will first integrate two major socioecological hypotheses developed for carnivores and primates respectively, namely the Resource Dispersion Hypothesis (RDH) and the Socioecological Model (SEM). We then discuss how both hypotheses can benefit each other, particularly by implementing new perspectives about the role of scramble competition. First, the RDH proposes that under certain widespread conditions, territories provide surplus resources that can maintain stable groups without any costs and thus also without any need for direct benefits to the territory owners. We argue that such cost-free group formation requires strong within-group contest competition that assures priority of access to the territory owners, but would not withstand within-group scramble competition, which inevitably causes costs for all group members. Second, the SEM proposes that under pure within-group scramble competition, resources cannot be monopolized and thus dominance rank and social tolerance are pointless. We argue that rank-dependent eviction and group fission into territory holders and leavers as proposed by the RDH provides rank-dependent benefits and allows for social tolerance in terms of granted group membership even under pure within-group scramble competition.


  • Open Access

    MacaqueNet: Advancing comparative behavioural research through large‐scale collaboration

    by Delphine De Moor, Macaela Skelton, Macaque Net, Federica Amici, Malgorzata E. Arlet, Krishna N. Balasubramaniam, Sébastien Ballesta, Andreas Berghänel, Carol M. Berman, Sofia K. Bernstein, et al.

    There is a vast and ever‐accumulating amount of behavioural data on individually recognised animals, an incredible resource to shed light on the ecological and evolutionary drivers of variation in animal behaviour. Yet, the full potential of such data lies in comparative research across taxa with distinct life histories and ecologies. Substantial challenges impede systematic comparisons, one of which is the lack of persistent, accessible and standardised databases. Big‐team approaches to building standardised databases offer a solution to facilitating reliable cross‐species comparisons. By sharing both data and expertise among researchers, these approaches ensure that valuable data, which might otherwise go unused, become easier to discover, repurpose and synthesise. Additionally, such large‐scale collaborations promote a culture of sharing within the research community, incentivising researchers to contribute their data by ensuring their interests are considered through clear sharing guidelines. Active communication with the data contributors during the standardisation process also helps avoid misinterpretation of the data, ultimately improving the reliability of comparative databases. Here, we introduce MacaqueNet, a global collaboration of over 100 researchers (https://macaquenet.github.io/) aimed at unlocking the wealth of cross‐species data for research on macaque social behaviour. The MacaqueNet database encompasses data from 1981 to the present on 61 populations across 14 species and is the first publicly searchable and standardised database on affiliative and agonistic animal social behaviour. We describe the establishment of MacaqueNet, from the steps we took to start a large‐scale collective, to the creation of a cross‐species collaborative database and the implementation of data entry and retrieval protocols. We share MacaqueNet's component resources: an R package for data standardisation, website code, the relational database structure, a glossary and data sharing terms of use. With all these components openly accessible, MacaqueNet can act as a fully replicable template for future endeavours establishing large‐scale collaborative comparative databases.


  • Open Access

    Evidence for adolescent length growth spurts in bonobos and other primates highlights the importance of scaling laws

    by Andreas Berghaenel, Jeroen Mg Stevens, Gottfried Hohmann, Tobias Deschner, Verena Behringer

    Adolescent growth spurts (GSs) in body length seem to be absent in non-human primates and are considered a distinct human trait. However, this distinction between present and absent length-GSs may reflect a mathematical artefact that makes it arbitrary. We first outline how scaling issues and inappropriate comparisons between length (linear) and weight (volume) growth rates result in misleading interpretations like the absence of length-GSs in non-human primates despite pronounced weight-GSs, or temporal delays between length- and weight-GSs. We then apply a scale-corrected approach to a comprehensive dataset on 258 zoo-housed bonobos that includes weight and length growth as well as several physiological markers related to growth and adolescence. We found pronounced GSs in body weight and length in both sexes. Weight and length growth trajectories corresponded with each other and with patterns of testosterone and insulin-like growth factor-binding protein 3 levels, resembling adolescent GSs in humans. We further re-interpreted published data of non-human primates, which showed that aligned GSs in weight and length exist not only in bonobos. Altogether, our results emphasize the importance of considering scaling laws when interpreting growth curves in general, and further show that pronounced, human-like adolescent length-GSs exist in bonobos and probably also many other non-human primates.