Classical Lottery in Action: Quantifying Risk and Evaluating Uncertainty
- 15 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
Abstract
The rarity of objectively known probabilities undermines the risk-ambiguity dichotomy, challenging the practical relevance of related theories. We return to classical lotteries—coins, dice, and similar devices—which inspired early probability theories through the idea of equiprobable outcomes and are widely considered strong candidates for objective probability. We adapt axioms of expected utility for risk to advocate average utility for classical lotteries, highlighting their conceptual affinity. Any general unknown event is conceived as a collection of possible classical-lottery frequencies, consistent with the ambiguity literature, and we suggest normative principles for their aggregation into an indifferent matching frequency. These principles identify a model in the spirit of the smooth model of ambiguity; the agent assigns subjective probabilities over the frequencies and aggregates them via a nonlinear mixture. The nonlinearity reflects the agent’s distinct attitudes toward classical-lottery frequencies versus subjective probabilities; a concave mixture, for example, captures ambiguity aversion. Our approach provides a concrete justification for the distinct attitudes and presents several advantages for model elicitation. We illustrate the theory’s applicability through examples and, especially, social policy evaluation where the veil of ignorance can be seen as a classical lottery. This paper was accepted by Manel Baucells, behavioral economics and decision analysis. Funding: J. Li was supported by the General Research Fund of the Hong Kong Research [Grant Council under research project LU13500322]. I. Tsetlin and F. Wang do not have fundings that need to be disclosed.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Why probability probably doesn’t exist (but it is useful to act like it does)Nature, 2024
- Experience and rationality under risk: re-examining the impact of sampling experienceExperimental Economics, 2020
- Probability2019
- A theory of subjective compound lotteriesJournal of Economic Theory, 2009
- On the Measurement of Inequality under UncertaintyJournal of Economic Theory, 1997
- Decisions with Multiple Objectives1993
- Additive Representations of Preferences1989
- Maxmin expected utility with non-unique priorJournal of Mathematical Economics, 1989
- Additively decomposed quasiconvex functionsMathematical Programming, 1982
- A theory of anticipated utilityJournal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 1982