Power and Manipulation
Author:
- 25 February 2025
- book chapter
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 97-114
Abstract
This chapter examines concerns about advisors improperly exercising power through their framing and delivery of advice, and reveals how power dynamics can compromise the safety of advice relationships. Section 4.1 considers worries about the use of manipulative techniques and concludes that thinking in terms of manipulation only serves to muddy the ethical waters when it comes to advice. There is more to be gained by focusing on whether the norms of advice are adhered to. The discussion then turns to the challenge of navigating power relations. Disparities of power between advisor and advisee can threaten the prospects of advice being received as such, even when the advisor’s conduct, intentions, and attitudes are norm-compliant. I canvass a range of relationships in which status issues pose challenges for advising and consider what makes it possible to safely advise those whom we rely upon, or who rely upon us.Keywords
This publication has 151 references indexed in Scilit:
- Communicating About Vaccines in a Fact-Resistant WorldJAMA Pediatrics, 2017
- Resentment of Advice and Norms of AdviceEthical Theory and Moral Practice, 2017
- The Art and Craft of Policy Advising2017
- Internalism about reasons: sad but true?Philosophical Studies, 2013
- On Being Responsible and Holding ResponsibleThe Journal of Ethics, 2007
- Autonomy and the Asymmetry Problem for Moral ExpertisePhilosophical Studies, 2006
- Solidarity1999
- Four Models of the Physician-Patient RelationshipJAMA, 1992
- Autonomy and benevolent liesThe Journal of Value Inquiry, 1984
- Hedges: A study in meaning criteria and the logic of fuzzy conceptsJournal of Philosophical Logic, 1973