A Call to Explicitly Name and Account for Power in Epistemic Agency Research
- 5 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Science Education
Abstract
For decades, science and engineering education researchers in the United States have sought to understand ways to realize more equitable, student‐centered learning experiences within K‐12 classrooms. One important line of research aligned to this aim has centered on opportunities for developing and supporting students’ epistemic agency, focusing on shifting epistemic agency away from residing solely in the teacher toward instead being enacted across the collaborative classroom community. Yet, despite extant research around this area of inquiry, little is known about how students negotiate epistemic agency amongst themselves. As research begins to delve into these critical student dynamics, we argue that the field must explicitly account for the varied powered relations ingrained within school spaces and how those relations impact students’ learning experiences. We then offer an illustrative example of student data to share a possible direction for critical analysis that could offer insight into such powered relations and how they play out and impact students’ epistemic agency, specifically through the concept of epistemic exclusion. Finally, we conclude with a call to action for educators and researchers.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding student use of epistemic criteria in engineering design contextsScience Education, 2023
- Acting with epistemic agency: Characterizing student critique during argumentation discussionsScience Education, 2020
- Critical science agency and power hierarchies: Restructuring power within groups to address injustice beyond themScience Education, 2020
- Opening up curricula to redistribute epistemic agency: A framework for supporting science teachingScience Education, 2019
- Fostering students’ epistemic agency through the co‐configuration of moth researchScience Education, 2018
- Addressing the epistemic elephant in the room: Epistemic agency and the next generation science standardsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2018
- Framing negotiation: Dynamics of epistemological and positional framing in small groups during scientific modelingScience Education, 2017
- Examining Classroom Science Practice Communities: How Teachers and Students Negotiate Epistemic Agency and Learn Science‐as‐PracticeScience Education, 2014
- Cultural processes in science education: Supporting the navigation of multiple epistemologiesScience Education, 2010
- Engineering Design Thinking, Teaching, and LearningJournal of Engineering Education, 2005