Compliance promotion in the vertical arena
- 6 October 2026
- book chapter
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 94-130
Abstract
This chapter maps the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in the vertical arena, which encompasses the direct interplay between supranational institutions and the member states. It consists of actions taken by the Commission in its role as guardian of the treaties to prevent or redress non-compliance vis-à-vis member state authorities, as well as tools to be employed by other supranational actors—notably EU agencies. The chapter first describes the tools in the ‘vertical toolbox’ as they have been employed. This description is organized along the regulatory cycle, going from ex-ante instruments, which aim to prevent non-compliance, to ex-post instruments, which aim to redress it. Among the ex-ante instruments, it discusses the better regulation agenda, as well as the Commission’s efforts to structure implementation through strategic legislative design. Among the ex-post instruments, it features tools to collect information on member states’ implementation behaviour (monitoring), measures to communicate with domestic implementers about (potential) breaches of EU law (dialogue), and the role of EU agencies in improving implementation. It also discusses the EU’s key instrument to pursue and sanction cases of non-compliance, the infringement procedure. After the discussion of the instruments’ rationale and their linkages to the three theoretical paradigms of managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism, the chapter continues to discuss insights from the literature about the effectiveness of each instrument and the factors influencing this. The chapter concludes by discussing the lessons for improving compliance promotion in the vertical arena.Keywords
This publication has 510 references indexed in Scilit:
- Legislation or Economic Instruments for a Successful Environmental Policy?2020
- Information Disclosure by the European Union as a Tool to Improve Implementation? A Comparative Analysis of the Perception of Domestic RegulatorsEuropean Policy Analysis, 2019
- The Differentiated Implementation of European Participation Rules in Energy Infrastructure Planning. Why Does the German Participation Regime Exceed European Requirements?European Policy Analysis, 2017
- Reconsidering EU Compliance: Implementation performance in the field of environmental policyEnvironmental Policy and Governance, 2017
- What Role for Public Participation in Implementing the EU Floods Directive? A Comparison With the Water Framework Directive, Early Evidence from Germany and a Research AgendaEnvironmental Policy and Governance, 2014
- Environmental governance: participatory, multi‐level – and effective?Environmental Policy and Governance, 2009
- Interplay of actors, scales, frameworks and regimes in the governance of biodiversityEnvironmental Policy and Governance, 2009
- Implementation and integration of EU environmental directives. Experiences from The NetherlandsEnvironmental Policy and Governance, 2009
- The EU Water Framework Directive: part 2. Policy innovation and the shifting choreography of governanceEuropean Environment, 2003
- Explaining Legal Implementation in the European UnionInternational Journal of the Sociology of Law, 1997