Oliver Treib
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Oliver Treib has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ellen Mastenbroek
Radboud University
12 shared publications - Esther Versluis
Maastricht University
12 shared publications - Bernd Schlipphak
University of Münster, Münster, Germany
7 shared publications Gerda Falkner
7 shared publications- Constantin Schäfer
Institute of Political Science, University of Münster, Münster, Germany
3 shared publications Holger Bähr
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 215-235
Conclusion and recommendations
Over time, the European Commission—and the EU legislator more broadly—have developed a comprehensive compliance promotion architecture. In an attempt to better grasp this architecture, this book has had a dual purpose. First it has sought to provide an empirical diagnosis and explanation of EU implementation and compliance. Analysing and synthesizing the vast body of theoretical and empirical research on EU implementation and compliance, it has aimed to develop an overview of the extent to which member states truthfully fulfil their role of loyal and sincere implementers of EU law. Second, it has sought to map and assess the EU’s compliance promotion architecture. Grounded in theories on compliance and enforcement from IR, comparative politics, and policy studies, the book has provided an analysis of the main managerialist, rationalist, and constructivist drivers of, and solutions for, compliance problems. This way, the book has sought to add to the flourishing but scattered academic literature on these topics. In addition, the goal has been to provide a basis for reflection and improvement of the EU’s system of compliance promotion. This chapter presents the key conclusions to be drawn from this exercise, organized around the following two questions: what have we learnt about member states’ compliance with EU rules and what have we learnt about the EU’s architecture for compliance promotion and its effectiveness? The chapter concludes with a set of policy recommendations and an agenda for further research.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 215-235
Conclusion and recommendations
Over time, the European Commission—and the EU legislator more broadly—have developed a comprehensive compliance promotion architecture. In an attempt to better grasp this architecture, this book has had a dual purpose. First it has sought to provide an empirical diagnosis and explanation of EU implementation and compliance. Analysing and synthesizing the vast body of theoretical and empirical research on EU implementation and compliance, it has aimed to develop an overview of the extent to which member states truthfully fulfil their role of loyal and sincere implementers of EU law. Second, it has sought to map and assess the EU’s compliance promotion architecture. Grounded in theories on compliance and enforcement from IR, comparative politics, and policy studies, the book has provided an analysis of the main managerialist, rationalist, and constructivist drivers of, and solutions for, compliance problems. This way, the book has sought to add to the flourishing but scattered academic literature on these topics. In addition, the goal has been to provide a basis for reflection and improvement of the EU’s system of compliance promotion. This chapter presents the key conclusions to be drawn from this exercise, organized around the following two questions: what have we learnt about member states’ compliance with EU rules and what have we learnt about the EU’s architecture for compliance promotion and its effectiveness? The chapter concludes with a set of policy recommendations and an agenda for further research.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 191-214
European Union compliance promotion
The EU has developed a comprehensive compliance promotion architecture in the vertical, horizontal, and domestic arenas. Reflecting on the effectiveness of all these compliance promotion tools, this chapter provides an integral overview of the EU’s compliance promotion architecture as it has been pieced together over time. It does so by reporting common themes as well as key differences across the three arenas. The first section provides a description of the EU’s compliance promotion architecture as it has developed since the early 1990s. It sketches how the toolbox has developed in practice over time. Based on this analysis, it highlights two core themes in the Commission’s approach to compliance promotion: (1) its multi-arena, multi-paradigmatic focus and (2) the development of strongly sector-specific accents in compliance promotion. The remainder of this section provides an analysis of the emphases and gaps of the current compliance promotion architecture. The chapter continues, then, by providing an assessment of the impact of the EU’s compliance promotion architecture. What are the commonalities and differences in effectiveness and preconditions in the three arenas? Hereafter, the chapter focuses on the escalation model in practice, assessing and comparing the working of the escalation model. It reflects on the prevalence of escalation in the three arenas and discusses the preconditions for operating the various instruments, before moving on to discuss some key escalation routes between the arenas. The chapter concludes, finally, by providing an overarching conclusion on the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in light of the theoretical model presented in this book.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 191-214
European Union compliance promotion
The EU has developed a comprehensive compliance promotion architecture in the vertical, horizontal, and domestic arenas. Reflecting on the effectiveness of all these compliance promotion tools, this chapter provides an integral overview of the EU’s compliance promotion architecture as it has been pieced together over time. It does so by reporting common themes as well as key differences across the three arenas. The first section provides a description of the EU’s compliance promotion architecture as it has developed since the early 1990s. It sketches how the toolbox has developed in practice over time. Based on this analysis, it highlights two core themes in the Commission’s approach to compliance promotion: (1) its multi-arena, multi-paradigmatic focus and (2) the development of strongly sector-specific accents in compliance promotion. The remainder of this section provides an analysis of the emphases and gaps of the current compliance promotion architecture. The chapter continues, then, by providing an assessment of the impact of the EU’s compliance promotion architecture. What are the commonalities and differences in effectiveness and preconditions in the three arenas? Hereafter, the chapter focuses on the escalation model in practice, assessing and comparing the working of the escalation model. It reflects on the prevalence of escalation in the three arenas and discusses the preconditions for operating the various instruments, before moving on to discuss some key escalation routes between the arenas. The chapter concludes, finally, by providing an overarching conclusion on the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in light of the theoretical model presented in this book.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 159-190
Compliance promotion in the domestic arena
This chapter maps the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in the domestic arena. This arena focuses on domestic checks and balances upon member state authorities responsible for EU implementation. These checks and balances can either be exerted by other public actors such as national regulatory agencies or national courts, or by societal actors such as NGOs, business, individual citizens, or the general public. The chapter first describes the tools in the ‘domestic toolbox’ as they have been employed, outlining four categories of domestic instruments. First, the EU legislator may prescribe information provision by member state authorities to relevant domestic stakeholders such as NGOs, business interests, other levels of government, or individual citizens. Secondly, EU legal acts may prescribe the participation of either public or private domestic stakeholders in EU policy implementation. Thirdly, the EU legislator has sought to enable and stimulate decentralized enforcement by national courts, for instance by laying down detailed and precise individual rights in secondary law and enhancing the scope for litigation by NGOs. The fourth instrument involves the prescribed establishment of independent national executive or regulatory agencies. After the discussion of the instruments’ rationale and their linkages to the three theoretical paradigms of managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism, the chapter continues to discuss insights from the literature about the effectiveness of each instrument and the factors influencing this. The chapter concludes by discussing the lessons for improving compliance promotion in the domestic arena.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 159-190
Compliance promotion in the domestic arena
This chapter maps the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in the domestic arena. This arena focuses on domestic checks and balances upon member state authorities responsible for EU implementation. These checks and balances can either be exerted by other public actors such as national regulatory agencies or national courts, or by societal actors such as NGOs, business, individual citizens, or the general public. The chapter first describes the tools in the ‘domestic toolbox’ as they have been employed, outlining four categories of domestic instruments. First, the EU legislator may prescribe information provision by member state authorities to relevant domestic stakeholders such as NGOs, business interests, other levels of government, or individual citizens. Secondly, EU legal acts may prescribe the participation of either public or private domestic stakeholders in EU policy implementation. Thirdly, the EU legislator has sought to enable and stimulate decentralized enforcement by national courts, for instance by laying down detailed and precise individual rights in secondary law and enhancing the scope for litigation by NGOs. The fourth instrument involves the prescribed establishment of independent national executive or regulatory agencies. After the discussion of the instruments’ rationale and their linkages to the three theoretical paradigms of managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism, the chapter continues to discuss insights from the literature about the effectiveness of each instrument and the factors influencing this. The chapter concludes by discussing the lessons for improving compliance promotion in the domestic arena.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 131-158
Compliance promotion in the horizontal arena
This chapter maps the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in the horizontal arena. This arena comprises the relations among member states. In their capacity as peers, they can employ instruments that aim to prevent or redress non-compliance in a peer-to-peer manner. The chapter first describes the key four tools in the ‘horizontal toolbox’. First, member states may engage in administrative cooperation. This includes case-based mutual administrative assistance and more systematic information and capacity exchange, often underpinned by procedures for cooperation. A second type of instrument consists of European administrative networks: networks of national administrative authorities intended to harmonize or improve national implementation or enforcement. Third, peer review instruments aim at the establishment of normative frames of reference, preceded or followed by voluntary processes of learning or socialization. A fourth set of instruments is labelled coercive coordination. Through these instruments member states can exert pressure on each other with the aim of forcing each other into compliance. Key examples are institutionalized peer pressure, dispute settlement, and the Article 259 procedure. After the discussion of the instruments’ rationale and their linkages to the three theoretical paradigms of managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism, the chapter continues to discuss insights from the literature about the effectiveness of each instrument and the factors influencing this. The chapter concludes by discussing the lessons for improving compliance promotion in the horizontal arena.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 131-158
Compliance promotion in the horizontal arena
This chapter maps the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in the horizontal arena. This arena comprises the relations among member states. In their capacity as peers, they can employ instruments that aim to prevent or redress non-compliance in a peer-to-peer manner. The chapter first describes the key four tools in the ‘horizontal toolbox’. First, member states may engage in administrative cooperation. This includes case-based mutual administrative assistance and more systematic information and capacity exchange, often underpinned by procedures for cooperation. A second type of instrument consists of European administrative networks: networks of national administrative authorities intended to harmonize or improve national implementation or enforcement. Third, peer review instruments aim at the establishment of normative frames of reference, preceded or followed by voluntary processes of learning or socialization. A fourth set of instruments is labelled coercive coordination. Through these instruments member states can exert pressure on each other with the aim of forcing each other into compliance. Key examples are institutionalized peer pressure, dispute settlement, and the Article 259 procedure. After the discussion of the instruments’ rationale and their linkages to the three theoretical paradigms of managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism, the chapter continues to discuss insights from the literature about the effectiveness of each instrument and the factors influencing this. The chapter concludes by discussing the lessons for improving compliance promotion in the horizontal arena.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 94-130
Compliance promotion in the vertical arena
This chapter maps the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in the vertical arena, which encompasses the direct interplay between supranational institutions and the member states. It consists of actions taken by the Commission in its role as guardian of the treaties to prevent or redress non-compliance vis-à-vis member state authorities, as well as tools to be employed by other supranational actors—notably EU agencies. The chapter first describes the tools in the ‘vertical toolbox’ as they have been employed. This description is organized along the regulatory cycle, going from ex-ante instruments, which aim to prevent non-compliance, to ex-post instruments, which aim to redress it. Among the ex-ante instruments, it discusses the better regulation agenda, as well as the Commission’s efforts to structure implementation through strategic legislative design. Among the ex-post instruments, it features tools to collect information on member states’ implementation behaviour (monitoring), measures to communicate with domestic implementers about (potential) breaches of EU law (dialogue), and the role of EU agencies in improving implementation. It also discusses the EU’s key instrument to pursue and sanction cases of non-compliance, the infringement procedure. After the discussion of the instruments’ rationale and their linkages to the three theoretical paradigms of managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism, the chapter continues to discuss insights from the literature about the effectiveness of each instrument and the factors influencing this. The chapter concludes by discussing the lessons for improving compliance promotion in the vertical arena.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 94-130
Compliance promotion in the vertical arena
This chapter maps the EU’s compliance promotion architecture in the vertical arena, which encompasses the direct interplay between supranational institutions and the member states. It consists of actions taken by the Commission in its role as guardian of the treaties to prevent or redress non-compliance vis-à-vis member state authorities, as well as tools to be employed by other supranational actors—notably EU agencies. The chapter first describes the tools in the ‘vertical toolbox’ as they have been employed. This description is organized along the regulatory cycle, going from ex-ante instruments, which aim to prevent non-compliance, to ex-post instruments, which aim to redress it. Among the ex-ante instruments, it discusses the better regulation agenda, as well as the Commission’s efforts to structure implementation through strategic legislative design. Among the ex-post instruments, it features tools to collect information on member states’ implementation behaviour (monitoring), measures to communicate with domestic implementers about (potential) breaches of EU law (dialogue), and the role of EU agencies in improving implementation. It also discusses the EU’s key instrument to pursue and sanction cases of non-compliance, the infringement procedure. After the discussion of the instruments’ rationale and their linkages to the three theoretical paradigms of managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism, the chapter continues to discuss insights from the literature about the effectiveness of each instrument and the factors influencing this. The chapter concludes by discussing the lessons for improving compliance promotion in the vertical arena.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 64-93
Theoretical perspectives on improving European Union policy implementation
This chapter introduces the theoretical framework needed for the mapping and assessment of the Commission’s instruments for improving EU implementation. This ‘escalation model of compliance promotion’ is based on the three key theoretical approaches to explaining EU policy implementation problems: managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism. Each of these theoretical approaches has its roots in the IR literature on compliance. In addition, this chapter outlines the multi-actor version of the three approaches. These multi-actor versions open the ‘black box’ of the state and take into account the interplay between the various European and domestic political, administrative, and societal actors involved in processes of policy implementation in the European multi-level system. Using the three theoretical paradigms, the chapter continues to present three corresponding sets of strategies for improving implementation or compliance. In line with our mixed IR and comparative politics perspective, the chapter argues that such strategies may be applied in three different settings: the vertical, horizontal, and domestic arenas. The combination of the three arenas and the three strategies results in nine different types of compliance promotion strategies. The chapter continues to develop an escalation model of compliance promotion which discusses optimal combinations of managerialist, constructivist, and rationalist strategies.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 64-93
Theoretical perspectives on improving European Union policy implementation
This chapter introduces the theoretical framework needed for the mapping and assessment of the Commission’s instruments for improving EU implementation. This ‘escalation model of compliance promotion’ is based on the three key theoretical approaches to explaining EU policy implementation problems: managerialism, constructivism, and rationalism. Each of these theoretical approaches has its roots in the IR literature on compliance. In addition, this chapter outlines the multi-actor version of the three approaches. These multi-actor versions open the ‘black box’ of the state and take into account the interplay between the various European and domestic political, administrative, and societal actors involved in processes of policy implementation in the European multi-level system. Using the three theoretical paradigms, the chapter continues to present three corresponding sets of strategies for improving implementation or compliance. In line with our mixed IR and comparative politics perspective, the chapter argues that such strategies may be applied in three different settings: the vertical, horizontal, and domestic arenas. The combination of the three arenas and the three strategies results in nine different types of compliance promotion strategies. The chapter continues to develop an escalation model of compliance promotion which discusses optimal combinations of managerialist, constructivist, and rationalist strategies.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 35-63
Implementation in the European Union
What do we know about implementation in the EU? There is a wealth of information available about how member states put EU laws into practice. This chapter aims to draw together what we can learn from the existing literature as well as the available EU documentation to assess the size of the implementation gap in the EU. The first part focuses on legal implementation. The section first describes which legal instruments member states typically use to transpose EU directives. Based on available data and the existing literature, it then provides an overview of the size of the transposition gap and sketches the main transposition patterns across member states, sectors, and over time. Hereafter the chapter turns to the phase of practical implementation. This section starts by outlining the difficulties related to analysing practical implementation. It continues by sketching what we do know and describing the trends in practical implementation research. Based on the available research and EU documentation, this section then provides an overview of the practical implementation gap. The chapter concludes with a summary of the overall diagnosis.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 35-63
Implementation in the European Union
What do we know about implementation in the EU? There is a wealth of information available about how member states put EU laws into practice. This chapter aims to draw together what we can learn from the existing literature as well as the available EU documentation to assess the size of the implementation gap in the EU. The first part focuses on legal implementation. The section first describes which legal instruments member states typically use to transpose EU directives. Based on available data and the existing literature, it then provides an overview of the size of the transposition gap and sketches the main transposition patterns across member states, sectors, and over time. Hereafter the chapter turns to the phase of practical implementation. This section starts by outlining the difficulties related to analysing practical implementation. It continues by sketching what we do know and describing the trends in practical implementation research. Based on the available research and EU documentation, this section then provides an overview of the practical implementation gap. The chapter concludes with a summary of the overall diagnosis.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 13-34
The concept of European Union policy implementation
The EU is commonly depicted as a system of indirect implementation. According to this model, the member states—or more precisely the relevant legislative, judicial, and administrative authorities within them—are responsible for the implementation of EU law within their territory. This chapter provides the legal and conceptual contours of EU policy implementation, setting the stage for the empirical diagnosis and theoretical understanding of implementation in the subsequent chapters. It describes, firstly, the notion of indirect implementation and contrasts it with the alternative models of direct, horizontal, and composite implementation. It then proceeds with an analysis of the key sources of EU law. Hereafter, it sketches the legal principles governing the relation between EU and national law. Next, the chapter provides a conceptualization of the main stages of EU implementation—legal and practical implementation—and their more refined substeps: transposition, operationalization, application, and (national) enforcement. It then provides the framework for evaluating implementation from a conformance perspective, which revolves around the criteria of timeliness and correctness. This legal approach is contrasted with a perspective focusing on implementation performance. Finally, a short conclusion is provided.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 13-34
The concept of European Union policy implementation
The EU is commonly depicted as a system of indirect implementation. According to this model, the member states—or more precisely the relevant legislative, judicial, and administrative authorities within them—are responsible for the implementation of EU law within their territory. This chapter provides the legal and conceptual contours of EU policy implementation, setting the stage for the empirical diagnosis and theoretical understanding of implementation in the subsequent chapters. It describes, firstly, the notion of indirect implementation and contrasts it with the alternative models of direct, horizontal, and composite implementation. It then proceeds with an analysis of the key sources of EU law. Hereafter, it sketches the legal principles governing the relation between EU and national law. Next, the chapter provides a conceptualization of the main stages of EU implementation—legal and practical implementation—and their more refined substeps: transposition, operationalization, application, and (national) enforcement. It then provides the framework for evaluating implementation from a conformance perspective, which revolves around the criteria of timeliness and correctness. This legal approach is contrasted with a perspective focusing on implementation performance. Finally, a short conclusion is provided.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 1-12
Introduction
The implementation of EU policies does not come without problems. To make EU law work the EU has developed a unique compliance promotion architecture. This book studies this innovative compliance promotion architecture, which over time has been established by the European Commission and the EU legislator more broadly. This chapter introduces the book’s dual analytical purpose of (1) providing an empirical diagnosis and theory-based explanation of EU implementation, and (2) mapping and assessing the EU’s compliance promotion architecture as it has been pieced together over time. The chapter develops a multi-arena, multi-paradigm theoretical framework on EU compliance promotion based on the existing literatures on EU, international, and national compliance and enforcement. To demarcate the focus on this book, this chapter introduces the core concepts and their delineation and provides an outline of the remainder of the book.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 1-12
Introduction
The implementation of EU policies does not come without problems. To make EU law work the EU has developed a unique compliance promotion architecture. This book studies this innovative compliance promotion architecture, which over time has been established by the European Commission and the EU legislator more broadly. This chapter introduces the book’s dual analytical purpose of (1) providing an empirical diagnosis and theory-based explanation of EU implementation, and (2) mapping and assessing the EU’s compliance promotion architecture as it has been pieced together over time. The chapter develops a multi-arena, multi-paradigm theoretical framework on EU compliance promotion based on the existing literatures on EU, international, and national compliance and enforcement. To demarcate the focus on this book, this chapter introduces the core concepts and their delineation and provides an outline of the remainder of the book.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
Preface