The (re)production of insecurities: an ethnographic study of the gendered science classroom in upper secondary school
Open Access
- 21 May 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Cultural Studies of Science Education
- Vol. 20 (3-4) , 293-319
Abstract
The purpose of this article is to go beyond the well-established fact that many science classrooms seem to be gendered in ways that favour masculinity and explore in depth how disciplinary norms work with gender norms in specific teacher-student interactions. Through micro-investigations of how power and knowledge interact, we propose a lens to understand how normalisation/exclusion function in the everyday activities in the science classroom. The article draws on feminist, poststructuralist theory and a Foucauldian power-perspective to produce and combine two levels of analysis, a micro-level of moment-to-moment interactions and a structural level of normative hierarchies that frame and influence the daily interactions between students and the teacher. The findings are based on a 3-year ethnographic study investigating the science learning environment at three non-compulsory upper secondary schools in Denmark. The empirical material consists of extensive observations in physics, chemistry and technology classrooms, interviews with observed students, and involved teachers. The theoretically informed analysis demonstrates firstly how teacher-student interactions both can mitigate and intensify gendered practices in the science classroom and secondly how the disciplinary and gendered norms in various ways are co-constructed in the classroom by both the students and the teachers rendering young women less likely to feel that they belong in science. The article ends with a discussion of the need for a gender reflexive teaching practice. The discussion is based on a critique of the pedagogical practices that the analysis shows create unequal opportunities for the students to be recognised as legitimate participants in the science classroom despite the teachers’ good intentions.Keywords
Funding Information
- Poul Due Jensens Fond (2021 514)
- Copenhagen University
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Science Talent and Unlimited Devotion: An Investigation of the Dynamics of University Students’ Science Identities Through the Lens of Gendered Conceptualisations of Talent2022
- Killing curiosity? An analysis of celebrated identity performances among teachers and students in nine London secondary science classroomsScience Education, 2017
- The Construction of Physics as a Quintessentially Masculine Subject: Young People’s Perceptions of Gender Issues in Access to PhysicsSex Roles, 2016
- Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis2014
- INFLUENCES OF DISCIPLINARY CLASSROOM CLIMATE ON HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT SELF-EFFICACY AND MATHEMATICS ACHIEVEMENT: A LOOK AT GENDER AND RACIAL–ETHNIC DIFFERENCESInternational Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2013
- Methodological Considerations for Studying Identities in School Science2012
- “It depends on what science teacher you got”: urban science self-efficacy from teacher and student voicesCultural Studies of Science Education, 2011
- Understanding the science experiences of successful women of color: Science identity as an analytic lensJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2007
- Teaching and learning in the science classroom: The interplay between teachers' epistemological moves and students' practical epistemologyScience Education, 2005
- The cultural production of science in reform‐based physics: Girls' access, participation, and resistanceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2004