HHHenriette Tolstrup Holmegaard

Henriette Tolstrup Holmegaard

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Henriette Tolstrup Holmegaard has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Young women’s longitudinal identity negotiations in physics and mathematics throughout upper secondary education

    by Emilie Gertz, Lene Møller Madsen, Henriette Tolstrup Holmegaard

    Upper-secondary education has been identified as a critical period for understanding young people’s (non)continuation in physics, as well as their broader trajectories into science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). This paper illuminates the longitudinal identity negotiations within upper secondary school physics and mathematics by focusing on two students, Kristi and Svea, who embody a paradox: Despite entering upper secondary school with strong science and mathematics identities and pursuing advanced coursework in both disciplines, they consistently refrained from considering futures in STEM. Central to our analysis is the concept of disciplinary and celebrated identities, which we integrate with perspectives from narrative psychology. This study draws on three rounds of semistructured narrative interviews with each student ( n = 6 ). The analysis was carried out by applying an in-depth reflexive thematic approach, focusing on how gendered identities and power dynamics shaped the young women’s negotiations within these masculine fields. The analysis showed how the two young women were presented with challenges in (i) aligning their interests and identity work with the disciplines’ norms and practices, and that facing such narrative disturbances was a gendered experience; (ii) bonding with the teachers enabled recognition, even though it involved applying narrow masculine strategies; and (iii) having to submit themselves to a “sink or swim” culture amplified their sense of inadequacy and unfitness for evolving strong disciplinary identities. Our findings show that these factors together discouraged the young women from maintaining sustainable narratives and negotiating positive choice considerations for a future in STEM. From a diversity perspective, our findings illustrate that inclusion is not only about access to participation but also about whose interests and ways of meaning-making are valued and legitimized within disciplinary practices. In doing so, this study advances research on diversity and inclusion in STEM by showing how disciplinary identities are shaped through sedimented practices of recognition over time. The implications call for rethinking participation to embrace and foster gender-inclusive teaching and learning environments, for example, through reforms in teacher training. Finally, we argue for moving away from deficit framings that describe young women as lacking confidence in physics and mathematics. Instead, feelings of not being “clever enough” should be understood as a product of the field itself, shaped by disciplinary practices in school physics and mathematics.

  • Open Access

    The (re)production of insecurities: an ethnographic study of the gendered science classroom in upper secondary school

    by Gry E. Thorsen, Lene Møller Madsen, Henriette T. Holmegaard

    The purpose of this article is to go beyond the well-established fact that many science classrooms seem to be gendered in ways that favour masculinity and explore in depth how disciplinary norms work with gender norms in specific teacher-student interactions. Through micro-investigations of how power and knowledge interact, we propose a lens to understand how normalisation/exclusion function in the everyday activities in the science classroom. The article draws on feminist, poststructuralist theory and a Foucauldian power-perspective to produce and combine two levels of analysis, a micro-level of moment-to-moment interactions and a structural level of normative hierarchies that frame and influence the daily interactions between students and the teacher. The findings are based on a 3-year ethnographic study investigating the science learning environment at three non-compulsory upper secondary schools in Denmark. The empirical material consists of extensive observations in physics, chemistry and technology classrooms, interviews with observed students, and involved teachers. The theoretically informed analysis demonstrates firstly how teacher-student interactions both can mitigate and intensify gendered practices in the science classroom and secondly how the disciplinary and gendered norms in various ways are co-constructed in the classroom by both the students and the teachers rendering young women less likely to feel that they belong in science. The article ends with a discussion of the need for a gender reflexive teaching practice. The discussion is based on a critique of the pedagogical practices that the analysis shows create unequal opportunities for the students to be recognised as legitimate participants in the science classroom despite the teachers’ good intentions.


  • How upper secondary students figure chemistry

    by Jonas Niemann, Henriette Holmegaard, Lene Møller Madsen

    The formation of chemistry identities among students is closely linked to the norms and practices prevalent in their chemistry learning environments. However, these norms may not be equally accessible or aligned with formal assessment criteria, leading to disparities for students in cultivating a positive chemistry identity. This study investigates how students conceptualise chemistry and the opportunities it affords for identity formation. Drawing upon the theoretical frameworks of figured worlds and science identity, data were collected from 45 upper secondary school students across three Danish schools through classroom observations and focus groups. The findings reveal that students perceive the laboratory and classroom settings as distinct in purpose, nature, and relevance, with varying degrees of celebration for enacted performance in each. While work in and related to the laboratory is highly valued by both students and teachers, individual enacted performance in the classroom is often equated with proficiency in chemistry. However, implicit norms for example governing the division of labour in laboratories indicate an inequitable distribution of tasks and underscore the need for a more equitable approach to identity formation in chemistry education.


  • Open Access

    “It’s Not Like I Go Oh That’s Really Exciting” – A Qualitative Study of Upper Secondary School Students’ Identity Negotiations in Physics

    by Emilie Gertz, Lene Møller Madsen, Henriette Tolstrup Holmegaard

    Transitions between educational levels have been identified as posing potential barriers for students’ sense of belonging in science. In this paper, we focus on the transition from lower secondary to upper secondary school while foregrounding physics as a subject. We approach transitions as an ongoing negotiation-process of identities embedded within the norms, practices, and expectations of physics. Methodologically, we narrow the focus to students who self-identify as female, as these are underrepresented in physics worldwide. We apply the analytical lens of physics identity constructed through competence, performance, interest, and recognition while drawing on the concept of the ideal student to understand what identities are idealized and marginalized, and how these are negotiated by the students. We found that a large group of the students were marginalized in relation to their interests in physics and experienced learning physics to be instrumental and meaningless. Only a small group were able to form a sense of identity mainly due to the resemblances of physics to mathematics. In conclusion we call for attention on who counts as knowledgeable and what counts as knowledge in the physics classroom. Second, we wish to question interests as imperative for being in physics. Lastly, we urge reflection on mathematics’ role in physics and what physics is without mathematics to disrupt the elite status of the subject.


  • Open Access

    Feeling the weight of the water: a longitudinal study of how capital and identity shape young people’s computer science trajectories over time, age 10–21

    by Henriette Holmegaard, Louise Archer, Spela Godec, Emma Watson, Emily MacLeod, Jennifer Dewitt, Julie Moote


  • Why science education and for whom? The contributions of science capital and Bildung

    by Line Bruun Nicolaisen, Lars Ulriksen, Henriette T. Holmegaard

    Science capital has proved a valuable concept for understanding a person's science-related resources and the inequities linked to participation in science education. The concept was developed in the UK and has since been applied worldwide. In this paper, we investigate the potential of the concept in Denmark. Here science capital meets a concept that is pivotal to the educational tradition: Bildung. We explore these two concepts, illuminate their blind spots, and point to potentials of how they may improve on each other. Our key argument is, that while science capital reveals inequities within participation in science education, the argument for why participation is important is often linked to aspirations, or ‘to become part of science'. Bildung, however enables a focus on the ‘why’ of science participation by adding how engagement with science affects the understanding of who we are and of our relationship with the world. Bildung further helps us reflect on how we may address key problems facing our societies. Based on the concept of science capital we critically reflect on issues of inequities in Bildung, and of who has access to Bildung. In conclusion, we argue for a convergence of these two concepts when understanding science participation.


  • Open Access

    Art-based methods in science education research

    by Ene Ernst Hoppe, Henriette Tolstrup Holmegaard

    In this paper, we explore the potentials of applying art-based research methods in science education research. Art-based methods are a range of qualitative methods that draw on performative, creative, and visual elements and thus propose innovative ways to produce knowledge in research. The paper is based on a systematic review of the literature on applying art as research methods in science education research. The review shows that only a few studies within science education use art-based methods as a methodological approach. Additionally, the literature identified through a snowball approach was thematically analysed. Four themes were identified: knowledge made available through artefacts, non-verbal language, more balanced power and positions, and time to reflect. The analysis outlines the strengths embedded within applying art-based methods and the potentials that they present to science education research. The implications for research and limitations of art-based methods are discussed.


  • Science students’ post-bachelor’s choice narratives in different disciplinary settings

    by Lene Møller Madsen, Henriette Tolstrup Holmegaard

    In this paper, we aim to understand the implications of the structural changes of the Bologna process from a student perspective. We investigate how bachelor’s degree students’ in a post-Bologna era with three-year bachelor’s degree and two-year master’s degree units construct their post-bachelor’s choice narratives in two different science degree programmes (chemistry and natural resources) at a Danish research-intensive university. We pay special attention to how science students’ narrative repertoires and imagined futures interact with and set the scene for their choice narratives in specific disciplinary settings. We draw on theoretical ideas of science identities including ‘narrative repertories’ and ‘imagined futures’, combined with disciplinary cultures and institutional capital. The analysis draws on small-scale rich qualitative material including 12 narrative interviews and focus groups with 44 students, including reflective essays, drawings and word-cloud brainstorms. Results show that the post-bachelor’s trajectory is a choice that students must relate themselves to in their identity negotiations. We document how students within the same faculty are presented with different narrative repertoires to construct and negotiate their choices from and as a result experience different choice processes and negotiations due to the different disciplinary settings they encounter. The implications for higher education institutions are given.