Inappropriate Requesting of Glycated Hemoglobin (Hb A1c) Is Widespread: Assessment of Prevalence, Impact of National Guidance, and Practice-to-Practice Variability
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 May 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Clinical Chemistry
- Vol. 58 (5) , 906-915
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Estimates suggest that approximately 25% of requests for pathology tests are unnecessary. Even in diabetes, for which international guidance provides recommended testing frequency, considerable variability in requesting practice exists. Using the diabetes marker, Hb A1c, we examined (a) the prevalence of under- and overrequesting, (b) the impact of international guidance on prevalence, and (c) practice-to-practice variability. METHODS: We examined Hb A1c requests (519 664 requests from 115 730 patients, January 2001 to March 2011) processed by the Clinical Biochemistry Department, University Hospital of North Staffordshire, and prevalence of requesting outside guidance from intervals between requests was calculated. Requests were classified as “appropriate,” “too soon,” or “too late.” We also assessed the effect of demographic factors and publication of guidance, along with between-practice variability, on prevalence. RESULTS: Only 49% of requests conformed to guidance; 21% were too soon and 30% were too late. Underrequesting was more common in primary care, in female patients, in younger patients, and in patients with generally poorer control (all P < 0.001); the reverse generally was true for overrequesting. Publication of guidance (e.g., American Diabetes Association, UK National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence) had no significant impact on under- or overrequesting rates. Prevalence of inappropriate requests varied approximately 6-fold between general practices. CONCLUSIONS: Although overrequesting was common, underrequesting was more prevalent, potentially affecting longer-term health outcomes. National guidance appears to be an ineffective approach to changing request behavior, supporting the need for a multisystem approach to reducing variability.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute for Health Research (HCS/08/011)
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Copy/Paste Documentation of Lifestyle Counseling and Glycemic Control in Patients With Diabetes: True to Form?Archives of internal medicine (1960), 2011
- Understanding information and education gaps among people with type 1 diabetes: A qualitative investigationPatient Education and Counseling, 2011
- Managing the demand for laboratory testing: Options and opportunitiesClinica Chimica Acta, 2010
- Costly regional variations in primary health care test utilization in SwedenScandinavian Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigation, 2010
- Team Effect on Variation in Laboratory Utilization on Subspecialty ServicesAcademic Medicine, 2009
- The inappropriate use of HbA1c testing to monitor glycemia: is there evidence in laboratory data?Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 2006
- Methodology for constructing guidanceJournal of Clinical Pathology, 2005
- Population-based Study of Repeat Laboratory TestingClinical Chemistry, 2003
- Pathology tests: is the time for demand management ripe at last?Journal of Clinical Pathology, 2003
- How much variation in clinical activity is there between general practitioners? A multi-level analysis of decision-making in primary careJournal of Health Services Research & Policy, 2002