Abstract
Thermal comfort, overheating, underheating, and indoor humidity are critical determinants of health and wellbeing in residential buildings, particularly for older adults who exhibit heightened vulnerability to thermal extremes. This study develops and applies an integrated post-occupancy evaluation framework combining adaptive comfort modelling (EN 16798-1 [5]), overheating assessment (CIBSE TM59 [6] and Passivhaus criteria), health-based temperature thresholds, and humidity risk screening in a 40-unit apartment building for residents aged 65 and older in Auckland, New Zealand. Indoor environmental monitoring and comfort surveys were analysed across two consecutive summers and a winter period. The analysis identified widespread summertime overheating, particularly at night; extensive winter cold exposure below health thresholds; persistent high indoor humidity; and a systematic divergence between modelled compliance and subjective thermal perception. Across 2,083 matched survey–environment records, 52.4% of occupants reported hot thermal sensation while the EN 16798-1 [5] Category I adaptive model classified only 0.8% of the same hours as exceeding the upper comfort limit. The divergence persisted across seasons: in two summers, reported overheating exceeded modelled overheating by 72.2 and 63.5 percentage points respectively; in winter, 26.5% of occupants reported hot sensation against 0.2% of matched hours classified as hot. Running mean outdoor temperature was the dominant predictor of overheating risk. Current assessment frameworks inadequately capture the combined thermal exposure and health risks of older occupants; adaptive comfort models systematically underestimate heat-related discomfort in populations with limited thermoregulatory capacity, highlighting the need for population-specific thresholds in later-life housing.