Combustion Management of Neat Dimethyl Ether Combustion for Enabling High Efficiency and Low NOx Production
Open Access
- 23 October 2024
- journal article
- Published by Scilight Press Pty Ltd in International Journal of Automotive Manufacturing and Materials
- Vol. 3 (4) , 2
Abstract
Article Simon LeBlanc, Binghao Cong, Navjot Sandhu, Long Jin, Xiao Yu and Ming Zheng * Department of Mechanical, Automotive and Materials Engineering, University of Windsor, 401 Sunset Avenue, Windsor, ON N9B 3P4, Canada * Correspondence: mzheng@uwindsor.ca Received: 30 June 2024; Revised: 30 September 2024; Accepted: 10 October 2024; Published: 23 October 2024 Abstract: Modern compression ignition engines heavily rely on exhaust gas recirculation to reduce NOx emissions. Despite this, complex and expensive after-treatment systems are still necessary to comply with stringent emission regulations. Conventional diesel combustion operates on a robust and readily controllable mode through which the high-pressure fuel injection and combustion processes are intimately coupled. The heterogeneous nature of direct injection systems is liable to the NOx-soot trade-off inherent to diesel-fueled engines. Dimethyl ether (DME) presents a unique fuel that is reactive, volatile, and oxygenated, offering significant potential to address emission challenges with reduced reliance on aftertreatment systems. In this research, the combustion management of neat DME fuel was investigated using a high-pressure direct injection system. Principally, the suitability of single-shot fuel scheduling as a combustion management technique for DME under low NOx production was explored. The transient high-pressure injection behaviour of DME was characterized with an offline test bench. A single-cylinder research engine platform was employed to study DME combustion characteristics. A wide range of engine conditions was investigated, including injection pressures from 200 bar up to 880 bar and engine loads from 1 bar up to 17 bar indicated mean effective pressure (IMEP). The combustion management of DME as it relates to fuel injection and operating boundary conditions was emphasized throughout the work. To accomplish this, tests were conducted at direct comparison conditions to diesel operation. Most notably, the DME combustion process finished in a shorter period than diesel, albeit with a significantly longer injection duration. At most operating conditions, the soot emissions were below that of upcoming emission regulations without particulate filter exhaust treatment. Even under high engine load operation—17 bar IMEP—of neat DME, the NOx emissions could be readily contained via EGR management to 51 ppm engine-out NOx during which soot reached a maximum of 1.0 FSN. Such operating circumstances of high engine load and low oxygen availability (overall lambda of 1.2) exhibited a deterministic combustion timing control via injection timing while performing with low combustion noise (4.8 bar/°CA) and high burning efficiency (98.5%). The heavy-duty transportation sector is largely powered by internal combustion engines (ICEs) owing to their range of power density capabilities, reliability, and convenient handling of liquid fuel as the sole energy source. Compression ignition engines are valuable for such applications because of their inherent high thermal efficiency compared to their spark ignition counterparts. Through the advancements in technologies such as lightweighting, engine downsizing, aftertreatment materials, and combustion management, modern engines have reduced their tailpipe emissions footprint significantly concerning greenhouse gases, e.g., carbon dioxide (CO2), and harmful combustion byproducts, e.g., nitrogen oxides (NOx) and soot [1]. Still, it is predicted that the theoretical maximums of efficiency improvement and emission reduction are yet to be achieved, by way of further development in the fueling and combustion management area [2–4]. To ensure standardized progress toward reducing combustion byproducts, a set of tailpipe restrictions have been enacted in different regions throughout the globe, as noted in Table 1. A significant amount of effort has been focused on engine management strategies to meet emission regulation standards. Such regulations set limits on the maximum output of specified species at the tailpipe of on-road vehicles, including CO2, unburned hydrocarbon (UHC), carbon monoxide (CO), NOx, and soot. While the CO2 is predicated by the carbon content of the fuel and thermal efficiency, wherein a higher thermal efficiency will contribute to lowering the CO2 output, the remaining species are undesired combustion byproducts. The presence of UHC and CO in the exhaust indicates worsened combustion efficiency, whereas NOx and soot in due course harm the environment and human health. Emission regulations have become stricter over time, with current emission regulations over 90% lower than those introduced 20 years prior [5]. To this end, many improvements have been made successfully by the aftertreatment technology and combustion management, i.e., electronic engine control, electronic sensors, and active fuel and air handling systems [6]. 270 (2007) 47 (2027) 400 (2013) 200 (2027) 400 (2021) Present emission limits for NOx and soot are expected to experience a further reduction up to 83% and 38% in upcoming planned regulations, respectively. The European Union (EU, EURO standards) and the United States of America (USA, EPA standards) advocate distinctive regulation standards, ultimately aimed at similar range of reductions in exhaust emissions. Generally, most countries enact tailpipe emission limits similar to the EU standards in later years for heavy-duty vehicles, albeit with differing testing procedures [7,8]. Modern aftertreatment systems may exceed 90% conversion efficiency with proper operation and maintenance, allowing vehicles to conform to these tight emission regulations [9,10]. For illustrative purposes, an effective emissions target for engine research remains in the range of 10 to 20 times higher than the regulated tailpipe regulations, as shown in Table 2. In example, at a presumed 90% NOx conversion efficiency, the tailpipe regulations in the USA of 270 mg/kWh, and planned to become 47 mg/kWh, correspond to engine-out emission limits of 2700 mg/kWh and 470 mg/kWh, respectively. While further improvements in aftertreatment technology are plausible [11], additional emission reductions are expected to be realized through in-cylinder combustion management. Nonetheless, all regulations require a simultaneous reduction of NOx and soot emissions. This in practice, is an increasingly challenging task for compression ignition combustion systems. Conventional diesel combustion is a robust and readily controlled combustion mode through which the high-pressure fuel injection and combustion processes are intimately coupled near the top dead centre, as shown in Figure 1. This period of interest is comprised of an extremely rapid sequence of events that is often completed within a few milliseconds. Within this brief time frame, high-pressure fuel is injected, chemical reactions occur, fuel energy is released and emission products are formed, leading to a spatially and temporally complex system [12]. As the fuel injection and combustion are distinct, yet inherently connected processes, it is often the case that the fuel spray duration continues through the combustion event leading to a diffusion flame [13]. Figure 1. Overview of conventional diesel control and combustion behaviour. High-temperature diesel combustion as shown here is known for high efficiency but is prone to generate high levels of NOx emissions and, under high load conditions, soot. Substantial reductions in engine-out NOx emissions for compression ignition engines can be readily achieved through exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) [14]. However, a simultaneous increase in soot because of lower oxygen availability and lower combustion temperatures is often an unintended consequence of NOx mitigation efforts through EGR [15]. In general, lower oxygen availability at the start of combustion predictably lowers NOx emissions, whereas higher oxygen availability towards the end of combustion lowers soot emissions. Many operating boundary conditions act as suitable means of manipulating the physical and chemical influences to manage combustion, such as injection pressure, fuel scheduling, intake boost pressure, combustion phasing, and more. Nonetheless, the simultaneous balance of NOx and soot continues to prove challenging as the inevitable NOx-soot trade-off inherent to diesel-fueled engines persists [16,17]. The diffusion flame is a prominent phenomenon in compression ignition combustion as it facilitates a large portion of heat release under elevated engine loads [13]. It is often characterized by its mixing-controlled combustion features [18]. The close coupling of fuel injection and combustion amplifies the influence of the fuel properties on the subsequent combustion behaviour. A diffusion flame is generally undesired for enabling high NOx and soot emissions. In stark contrast, the diffusion flame provides a high-efficiency burning mode that is readily controlled in timing and intensity. As it is the undesired rise in soot emissions that limits the amount of EGR, the elimination of soot formation via fuel properties allocates a direct in-cylinder NOx management via EGR, reducing fuel scheduling and combustion management complexities. Fuel properties such as reactivity, fuel-borne oxygen content, and volatility have been proven advantageous for direct injection combustion applications for high efficiency and low engine-out soot emissions. A list of conventional and alternative fuels has been organized into three characteristics in Figure 2. A chemically reactive fuel, i.e., recognized by its adequate cetane number, enables high controllability and combustion completeness, tending to produce lower combustion noise [19]. On the other hand, fuels with high cetane numbers promote a greater degree of diffusion combustion and, in turn, may augment soot emissions [20]. An oxygenated fuel alleviates the dependency on oxygen availability from the cylinder charge during fuel spray and improves combustion completeness. Kitamura et al. [21] found that soot formation within the high-pressure fuel spray flame could be significantly reduced at >30% oxygen content. Lastly, volatility primarily enhances the atomization rate of fuel and air. Even though a volatile fuel may be subject to difficulties in liquid-phase high-pressure fuel injection, its application significantly influences the fuel spray and subsequent combustion event [22]. The period from fuel spray to autoignition involves both physical and chemical delays, wherein the physical delay dominates [23]. In high-pressure fuel sprays, Konno et al. [24] showed that the mixing quality of dimethyl ether (DME) at 600 bar injection pressure was equivalent to that of diesel at 2000 bar at half the nozzle orifice diameter. Teng and McCandless [25] explained that the rapid fuel evaporation was most notable around the perimeter of spray plume, effectively showing a turbulent-jet-like nature. Such behaviour may be most valuable during the diffusion flame when the rate of reaction is governed by the mixing rate. A faster diffusion combustion rate correspondingly improves controllability and enables a high efficiency, ultra-low emissions mode of combustion [26]. Through this comparison, the unique value of DME is apparent; a fuel possesses unique qualities of reactivity, volatility, and oxygen content. Figure 2. Qualities of conventional and alternative fuel. The potential of DME as a fuel for compression ignition engines has been widely investigated in academia and industry. The advantageous near-zero soot tendency of DME is clear, alongside the availability to be produced from a multitude of renewable feedstocks, presenting DME as an ideal fuel and sustainable energy source for future heavy-duty powertrains [27,28]. Apart from the engineering challenges associated with handling onboard high-pressure liquified DME, the engine performance is largely similar to that of diesel but with little inheritance NOx-soot trade-off [29–32]. In this respect, it is valuable to understand the combustion behaviour, akin to the research and development of diesel engines [33]. While engine performance appears similar, the unique fuel properties of DME necessitate adjustments in combustion management strategies. The fuel scheduling necessitates adjustments as the lower energy density raises the injection quantity ~55% by mass. With conventional single-shot fueling strategies, the injection duration will be extended significantly, especially as the physical properties of DME permit lower injection pressures. On the other hand, the extreme mitigation of soot emissions with DME can be leveraged for better control through prioritizing the diffusion combustion mode. In this work, the injection and combustion characteristics of neat DME fuel are investigated in a high-pressure direct injection combustion application. This research aims to compile and extend the understanding of DME combustion in a conventional direct injection combustion application The transient fuel injection and combustion processes are investigated with an offline test bench and online research engine platform, covering injection pressures from 200 bar up to 880 bar and engine loads from 1 bar up to 17 bar indicated mean effective pressure (IMEP). The combustion management of DME as it relates to fuel injection and operating boundary conditions is emphasized throughout the work. To accomplish this, tests were conducted at direct comparison conditions to diesel operation. For diesel engine tests, a higher fuel pressure of up to 1500 bar was applied to constructively match the lower volatility of diesel. The discussion primarily emphasizes comparative results to diesel fuel which acts as a reference for modern-day combustion management strategies. This comparison provides insight into the suitability of single-shot fuel scheduling as a combustion management technique for DME under low NOx emissions. The heterogeneous nature of direct injection combustion involves an intimate coupling of fuel delivering process and the combustion process. In this study, the management of DME fuel injection and combustion was investigated in a single-shot strategy. Diesel fuel was also investigated at matching conditions for relevance. An offline rate of injection measurement bench was used to study the injection characteristics of the fuels and the combustion characteristics were investigated on a single cylinder research engine. The fueling system was configured to adapt on-board and off-board high-pressure fueling systems suitable for diesel and DME fuels, respectively. This setup has enabled high-pressure direct injection and combustion studies with alternative fuels including those of low viscosity, high vapour pressure, and inadequate elastomer compatibility. Due to the predominance of diffusion combustion control, effective combustion control requires fast and precise instrumentation that can be readily adjusted. The unique physical fuel properties of DME compared with diesel fuel raise concern about the fuel injection behaviour regarding the real transient discharge process and the subsequent plume formation. In this section, the system specifications and testing procedure will be discussed. The Bosch long-tube method was utilized to analyze the injection rate profile for DME fuel. The results were then compared to those of diesel injection under the same conditions. The rate of injection measurement platform included a high-pressure injection pump, an injector installed in a reservoir connected to a 50-meter-long tube, and a host computer for monitoring, control, and data acquisition. An overview of the rate of injection platform is illustrated in Figure 3. The signals transmitted and received during testing were managed by an RT-FPGA system interfaced with the host computer, all orchestrated through the National Instruments LabVIEW software environment. Figure 3. Rate of injection research platform. The fuel properties of DME prevent its direct substitution for diesel fuel using traditional diesel injection systems due to DME’s higher vapour pressure, lower viscosity and lubricity, and its corrosive effects on elastomers. A list of selected fuel properties is given in Table 3. To address these challenges, a pneumatically driven double-air drive piston pump (Maximator LSF100-2) was used to supply high-pressure DME. This system accommodates a variety of alternative fuels regardless of physical properties, as the plunger was pneumatically driven and the sealing materials are chemically resistant. Liquid DME was fed from the bottom of a 1-gallon stainless steel tank, with the DME pressure maintained at approximately 20 bar absolute using a nitrogen supply at the top of the tank. Throughout the tests, a back-pressure range of 30~50 bar yielded the best results without noticeable differences. A stainless-steel chamber was designed and fabricated to hold a conventional diesel injector (8 × 140 µm). The pressure transducer was flush-mounted on the side of the chamber. Signals were sent to a piezoelectric injector driver to send the tuned opening and closing power signals to the injector. The pressure inside the chamber increased as the fuel was injected into the chamber. The corresponding rate of injection shape is proportional to the magnitude of pressure change recorded by the pressure transducer. The theoretical calculation from the measured chamber pressure mass flow rate is proportional to the total nozzle hole area and inversely proportional to the local speed of sound for the respective fluid [34]. Hydraulic delays can be categorized into opening and closing delays. More detailed information about the offline testing methodology can be found in [35]. The start of fuel delivery is considered reliable and has been validated with high-speed video recordings. The end of fuel delivery required assumptions in data processing. In this work, the raw signal exhibits an exponential delay as the ROI decreases at the end of fuel delivery. It is assumed that the needle effectively cuts off the fuel upon closing. Consequently, the end of the fuel delivery slope was extended using a linear fit line. The system was validated by recording an extended period and observing the pressure wave reflections. The reflected frequencies for diesel and DME resulted in estimated speeds of sound of 1389 m/s and 980 m/s, respectively. Similar speeds of sound for DME have been confirmed by Kapus and Ofner [13], as well as other studies [14–16]. The agreement between the speed of sound measurements in this study and those reported in the literature instills confidence in the results obtained from the long tube system. The engine is configured for direct injection CI research with an independent fuel injection system. A summary of engine geometry specifications is given in Table 4. An overview of the complete engine system is shown in Figure 4. All data acquisition and engine control programs are designed within the National Instruments LabVIEW software environment. The raw pressure data and fuel scheduling programs were programmed into the real-time operating systems on embedded NI controllers. A piezoelectric pressure transducer was flush-mounted to the cylinder head. The pressure measurements are synced with the optical encoder at a frequency of 7200 points per cycle, or every 0.1 °CA. Each operating condition logged a continuous 200 cycles of pressure recordings. Thermocouples and pressure sensors are...Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- The potential of dimethyl ether (DME) to meet current and future emissions standards in heavy-duty compression-ignition enginesFuel, 2023
- Combustion control of DME HCCI using charge dilution and spark assistanceProceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering, 2022
- Combustion in the future: The importance of chemistryProceedings of the Combustion Institute, 2021
- Application of Diesel Particulate Filter on in-use On-road VehiclesEnergy Procedia, 2017
- Developments in internal combustion engines and implications for combustion science and future transport fuelsProceedings of the Combustion Institute, 2015
- Computational Analysis of the Extended Zeldovich MechanismArabian Journal for Science and Engineering, 2014
- Investigation on the fuel spray and emission reduction characteristics for dimethyl ether (DME) fueled multi-cylinder diesel engine with common-rail injection systemFuel Processing Technology, 2011
- Macroscopic spray characteristics and breakup performance of dimethyl ether (DME) fuel at high fuel temperatures and ambient conditionsFuel, 2010
- Implementation of multiple-pulse injection strategies to enhance the homogeneity for simultaneous low-NOx and -soot diesel combustionInternational Journal of Thermal Sciences, 2009
- Diesel engine development in view of reduced emission standardsEnergy, 2008