Cloze Tests in Measuring Reading Comprehension Levels
Open Access
- 3 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by Turkish Education Association in Education and Science
- Vol. 50, 69-92
Abstract
This study, conducted as correlational research, aims to objectively examine the validity of cloze tests in Turkish, which are commonly used to assess reading comprehension levels, general language proficiency, and the readability of written materials, and to evaluate the procedures for using these tests to measure reading comprehension. The study investigates the consistency between multiple-choice reading comprehension tests, frequently used in national exams for their functionality and objectivity, and cloze tests designed and scored using various methods. During the study, a total of eight measurement tools were administered to a sample group of 90 seventh-grade students. These tools consisted of four multiple-choice reading comprehension tests based on four distinct texts and four cloze tests, each systematically deleting a word at a different position within the text. Two scoring methods were applied to the cloze tests, one considering only the exact words as correct and the other accepting alternative words that preserved the meaning of the sentence. Within this scope, approximately 23,000 test items were presented to the students in the study group, and around 43,000 evaluations were conducted on these items. Data collected during the 2023-2024 academic year were analyzed using Pearson correlation analysis, revealing a significant positive relationship between cloze tests and multiple-choice tests. Tests scored by considering only the exact words demonstrated greater consistency, while the correlation decreased when context-preserving alternatives were accepted as correct. The highest correlation occurred when every sixth word was systematically deleted. Based on the findings, it is recommended that in cloze tests, exact words should be accepted as correct instead of context-preserving words, every 6th word should be systematically deleted, and the tests should be systematically integrated into measurement and evaluation practices.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Measuring college students' reading comprehension ability using cloze testsJournal of Research in Reading, 2011
- Reading Comprehension Tests Vary in the Skills They Assess: Differential Dependence on Decoding and Oral ComprehensionScientific Studies of Reading, 2008
- Insights into Second Language Reading2005
- Assessing Reading2000
- CLOZE, DICTATION, AND THE TEST OF ENGLISH AS A FOREIGN LANGUAGELanguage Learning, 1974
- CLOZE TESTS OF SECOND LANGUAGE PROFICIENCY AND WHAT THEY MEASURE1Language Learning, 1973
- CLOZE TESTS IN ENGLISH, THAI, AND VIETNAMESE: NATIVE AND NON-NATIVE PERFORMANCELanguage Learning, 1972
- THE CLOZE PROCEDURE: A CONVENIENT READABILITY TEST FOR TRAINING MATERIALS AND TRANSLATIONSApplied Psychology, 1972
- Clozentropy: A procedure for testing English language proficiency of foreign studentsSpeech Monographs, 1970
- A new readability yardstick.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1948