Is uniformitarianism still necessary for studying Earth-like planets?
Open Access
- 18 September 2026
- journal article
- Published by Geological Society of London in Geological Society, London, Special Publications
- Vol. 567 (1)
Abstract
Hutton's uniformitarianism has been an instrumental concept in establishing Earth sciences as a rigorous discipline. However, ever since publication of Stephen Gould's famous paper ‘Is uniformitarianism necessary?’ in 1965, we have been wrestling with whether the concept has largely outlived its scientific relevance. Here, I ask this question in the context of so-called Earth-like exoplanets. I argue that, while Earth serves as a valuable initial reference for modelling rocky exoplanets, adhering too closely to uniformitarian assumptions risks greatly oversimplifying the likely diversity of extraterrestrial environments. Stellar nucleosynthesis and disk evolution introduce significant variations in elemental ratios such as C/O and Mg/Si, giving rise to very different mantle mineralogy than observed on Earth. Geologically, tectonic regimes and the carbonate–silicate cycle exhibited non-uniformitarian behaviour even on Earth during its history, implying far greater variability when considering exoplanets. For exo-biology, environmental divergences must meaningfully impact biomechanical scaling and biogeochemical cycling. At the same time, our empirical foundation for extrapolating to model any of the above will largely remain what can be observed or measured on Earth. Therefore, while we must keep Gould's assessment in mind as we work up from the idealized concept of Earth-like planets towards the real and grand diversity of worlds in our galaxy, uniformitarianism is indeed still necessary for studying Earth-like planets.Keywords
Funding Information
- Trinity College, University of Cambridge (JRF)
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- Silicate weathering as a feedback and forcing in Earth's climate and carbon cycleEarth-Science Reviews, 2020
- When Did Life Likely Emerge on Earth in an RNA‐First Process?ChemSystemsChem, 2020
- Cycling phosphorus on the Archean Earth: Part I. Continental weathering and riverine transport of phosphorusGeochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 2020
- COPSE reloaded: An improved model of biogeochemical cycling over Phanerozoic timeEarth-Science Reviews, 2018
- Phosphorylation on the early earthChemical Geology, 2017
- The Origin of Life—Out of the BlueAngewandte Chemie International Edition, 2015
- Did phosphorus derived from the weathering of large igneous provinces fertilize the Neoproterozoic ocean?Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems, 2015
- Mitochondrial copper metabolism and delivery to cytochrome c oxidaseIUBMB Life, 2008
- A Cosmochemical Determinism in the Formation of Earth-like PlanetsIcarus, 2000
- The influence of gravity on structure and function of animalsAdvances In Space Research, 1984