Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Craig Robert Walton has a total of 91 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Is uniformitarianism still necessary for studying Earth-like planets?

    by Craig R. Walton

    Hutton's uniformitarianism has been an instrumental concept in establishing Earth sciences as a rigorous discipline. However, ever since publication of Stephen Gould's famous paper ‘Is uniformitarianism necessary?’ in 1965, we have been wrestling with whether the concept has largely outlived its scientific relevance. Here, I ask this question in the context of so-called Earth-like exoplanets. I argue that, while Earth serves as a valuable initial reference for modelling rocky exoplanets, adhering too closely to uniformitarian assumptions risks greatly oversimplifying the likely diversity of extraterrestrial environments. Stellar nucleosynthesis and disk evolution introduce significant variations in elemental ratios such as C/O and Mg/Si, giving rise to very different mantle mineralogy than observed on Earth. Geologically, tectonic regimes and the carbonate–silicate cycle exhibited non-uniformitarian behaviour even on Earth during its history, implying far greater variability when considering exoplanets. For exo-biology, environmental divergences must meaningfully impact biomechanical scaling and biogeochemical cycling. At the same time, our empirical foundation for extrapolating to model any of the above will largely remain what can be observed or measured on Earth. Therefore, while we must keep Gould's assessment in mind as we work up from the idealized concept of Earth-like planets towards the real and grand diversity of worlds in our galaxy, uniformitarianism is indeed still necessary for studying Earth-like planets.

  • The Only Constant of Life’s Origin Is Change: The Importance of Chemical Fluxes in Prebiotic Environments

    by Craig R. Walton, Skyla B. White, Paul B. Rimmer

    High concentrations have long been thought to be important in prebiotic chemistry as they offer a way to circumvent a lack of available enzymatic catalysis to overcome kinetic barriers. Here, we argue that fluxes and timescales are also of critical importance. Fluxes and timescales determine, in part, whether an environment can achieve high concentrations of reactants and, in particular, place a critical constraint on whether high concentrations of product molecules can be maintained. We focus on closed basin lakes, which offer a viable way to concentrate molecules relative to background sources under benign conditions. From the perspective of P, HCN and its derivatives, and S, these systems may yield competitively high concentrations of reactants. Nonetheless, closed basin lakes often have limited fluxes of reactants, which places tight constraints on the concentrations of product molecules that can be maintained at steady state. In conjunction with experimentally measured reaction kinetics, an opportunity exists to discriminate between the plausibility of environments on the basis of their simulated ability to generate desired concentrations of products over relevant timescales. Crucially, to make such an evaluation is extremely difficult to do with confidence without quantitatively dealing with fluxes and timescales. Therefore, future work should routinely and systematically consider these aspects alongside molecule concentrations in environmental systems of interest and in experiments.


  • Open Access

    Meteorite Radioisotope Ages Reveal Late Dynamical Chaos in the Solar System

    by Craig R. Walton, Maria Schönbächler, Heejin Jeon, Sen Hu, Alessandro Morbidelli, Thomas Bovay, Anne-Sophie Bouvier, Martin Whitehouse, Oliver Shorttle

    The orbital elements of the solar system’s ancient asteroid families are highly dispersed, recording the last dynamical chaos in its history. However, dynamics alone cannot precisely date this when this terminal chaos occurred. Instead, we can precisely date the collisions triggered by such dynamical rearrangement to constrain this event. On planets, erosion, volcanism, and crustal recycling have removed almost all trace of rocks older than 4 Ga, erasing the archive of early solar system history. In contrast, the meteorite record generated by asteroid collisions represents a separate and more complete archive of the solar system’s early dynamical evolution. Here we build a record of in situ ordinary chondrite meteorite apatite U-Pb ages, sensitive to collisions that induce parent-body break-up events. We show that the U-Pb records of strongly shocked and weakly shocked meteorites are distinct. The U-Pb ages of weakly shocked meteorites record the decline of radiogenic heating in asteroidal bodies. Meanwhile, shocked meteorite ages record major collisions. All sampled ordinary chondrite bodies record collisions that occurred 4480 ± 20 Ma million years ago. No further multi-parent-body clusters of shock ages are found in this record until the very recent events that brought the meteorites to Earth. These ages constrain that the last date of major dynamical chaos to modify the orbital elements of asteroids occurred at around 4480 Ma. This date is relatively late in solar system history, possibly representing the timing of an orbital instability of the giant planets.


  • Open Access

    The chemical habitability of Earth and rocky planets prescribed by core formation

    by Craig R. Walton, Laura K. Rogers, Amy Bonsor, Rob Spaargaren, Oliver Shorttle, Maria Schönbächler

    A crucial factor governing the habitability of exoplanets is the availability of bioessential elements such as nitrogen (N) and phosphorous (P), which foster prebiotic chemistry and sustain life after its emergence. However, concentrations of P and N in planetary mantles vary, owing to initial availability and oxidation conditions during planet formation, and thus their characterization and availability in planetary environments are challenging. Here we use a core-formation model to show that moderate oxygen fugacity during core formation is the key parameter to the availability of these two elements, with the existence of a narrow ‘chemical Goldilocks zone’ that allows both P and N to be present with the right abundances in the mantle. Earth falls within this zone, whereas planets with more reducing/oxidizing conditions will sequester P/N into the core, hindering their availability for life. Future observations refining estimates of the oxygen fugacity prevalent during exoplanet core formation will be crucial to properly evaluate exoplanetary habitability and correctly interpret possible biosignatures.


  • Open Access

    Protoplanetary cores drove chondrule formation

    by Mohamad Ali-Dib, Craig Walton

    Chondrules are small spherical objects that formed at high temperatures early in the history of the Solar System. The key compositional characteristics of chondrules may be well explained by high gas pressures in their formation environment. However, such high gas pressures are widely considered astrophysically unreasonable. Here, we propose that chondrules were formed via the processing of dust grains in the dust-rich envelopes of planetary embryos, before getting ejected via convective diffusion. We show that this scenario can explain many salient constraints on chondrule formation, including formation locations; mass and time-scale of chondrule production; repeat chondrule heating events; heating time-scales; and, most crucially, high prevailing gas pressures. Our work suggests that high gas pressures may indeed have prevailed during the formation of chondrules, reconciling previous analytical observations, experimental evidence, and theory. We suggest that chondrules are mostly the products rather than the precursors of planetary embryo formation – a result that would have important implications for our understanding of the early history of the Solar System.


  • Open Access

    Microfaults: Abundant shear deformation and frictional melting in chondrites

    by Craig R. Walton, Mahesh Anand, Maria Schönbächler

    The majority of ordinary chondrite (OC) meteorites record some amount of textural evidence for impact‐induced deformation. Melt veins in some shocked samples have been compared to terrestrial impact‐related pseudotachylites, which form by frictional melting of host rock. However, lacking in situ context, the role of friction in driving impact‐related melting in meteorites remains unclear. Here, we present evidence for an important role for shear deformation and friction in complementing shock melting of OC material. We find microfaults directly associated with textural evidence for quenched frictional shock melt in samples of a broad range of bulk shock stages and across all three classes studied (LL, L, or H). Microfaults occur in 20% of our studied samples. We identify examples of both individual microfaults and, in rare cases, microfault networks, complete with subsidiary shear structures. Our observations indicate that friction plays an important role in melt generation in weakly to moderately shocked samples and may also be relevant for strongly shocked meteorites. Microfault structures may be of underestimated significance in chondrites in general—both with regard to their general abundance and their possible utility for elucidating the geological settings sampled by meteoritic impactites.


  • Open Access

    Large closed-basin lakes sustainably supplied phosphate during the origins of life

    by Craig R. Walton, Jihua Hao, Maria Schönbächler, Oliver Shorttle

    The origin of life on Earth required a supply of phosphorus (P) for the synthesis of universal biomolecules. Closed lakes may have accumulated high P concentrations on early Earth. However, it is not clear whether prebiotic P uptake in such settings would then have been sustainable. We show that large closed-basin lakes can combine high P concentrations at steady state with extremely high rates of biological productivity. Our case study is Mono Lake in California, which has close to 1 millimolar dissolved P at steady state despite extremely high rates of biological productivity, in contrast to smaller closed basins where life is scarce. Hence, large closed-basin lakes offer an environment where high rates of prebiotic P productivity can plausibly coexist with high steady-state P concentrations. Such lakes should have readily formed on the heavily cratered and volcanically active surface of early Earth.


  • Open Access

    The plausibility of origins scenarios requiring two impactors

    by R. J. Anslow, A. Bonsor, P. B. Rimmer, A. S. P. Rae, C. H. McDonald, C. R. Walton

    Hydrogen cyanide delivered by cometary impactors can be concentrated as ferrocyanide salts, which may support the initial stages of prebiotic chemistry on the early Earth. One way to achieve the conditions required for a variety of prebiotic scenarios, requiring, for example, the formation of cyanamide and cyanoacetylene, is through the arrival of a secondary impactor. In this work, we consider the bombardment of the early Earth, and quantitatively evaluate the likelihood of origins scenarios that invoke double impacts. Such scenarios are found to be possible only at very early times (>4 Gya), and are extremely unlikely settings for the initial stages of prebiotic chemistry, unless (i) ferrocyanide salts are stable on 1000 yr timescales in crater environments, (ii) there was a particularly high impact rate on the Hadean Earth, and (iii) environmental conditions on the Hadean Earth were conducive to successful cometary delivery (i.e. limited oceanic coverage and low (≲1 bar) atmospheric surface pressure). Whilst environmental conditions on the early Earth remain subject to debate, this work highlights the need to measure the typical lifetime of ferrocyanide salts in geochemically realistic environments, which will determine the plausibility of double impact scenarios.


  • Open Access

    Prebiotic Environmental Conditions Impact the Type of Iron‐Sulfur Cluster Formed

    by Luca Valer, Yin Juan Hu, Alberto Cini, Marco Lantieri, Craig R. Walton, Oliver Shorttle, Maria Fittipaldi, Sheref S. Mansy

    Iron‐sulfur clusters are ancient cofactors that could have played a role in the prebiotic chemistry leading to the emergence of protometabolism. Previous research has shown that certain iron‐sulfur clusters can form from prebiotically plausible components, such as cysteine‐containing oligopeptides. However, it is unclear if these iron‐sulfur clusters could have survived in prebiotically plausible environments. To begin exploring this possibility, we tested the stability of iron‐sulfur clusters coordinated to a tripeptide and to N ‐acetyl‐L‐cysteine methyl ester in a variety of solutions meant to mimic prebiotically plausible environments. We also assessed the impact of individual chemical components on stability. We find that iron‐sulfur clusters form over a wide variety of conditions but that the type of iron‐sulfur cluster formed is strongly impacted by the chemical environment and the coordinating scaffold. These findings support the general hypothesis that iron‐sulfur clusters were present on the prebiotic Earth and that different types of iron‐sulfur cluster predominated in different environments.