Two Paths of Conversation: How Stories and Statistics are Associated With Community Engagement in Online Debate Surrounding Vaccine Science Skeptical Content
- 17 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Communication Research
Abstract
Statistical and narrative evidence represent two distinct ways of substantiating claims in public reasoning, but does this distinction matter for how people engage with vaccine science skeptical (VSS) content and the discursive spaces surrounding it? This study addresses this question through a large-scale, LLM-assisted observational analysis of online engagement with VSS posts and comments that support or counter such content using statistical versus narrative evidence in the Reddit community r/DebateVaccines . Building on Fisher’s distinction between rational and narrative paradigms , we theorize two paths of conversation through which evidentiary forms are associated with audience engagement with contentious vaccine discourses in a naturalistic social media setting: a rational pathway, marked by concentrated participation and corrective contestation around statistical claims and counterclaims, tending toward a single evidence-based truth “approved” by one-click reactions; and a narrative pathway, characterized by generative engagement featuring broader and more distributed participation, more discursive and generative engagement, and greater acceptance of competing viewpoints. These findings provide a springboard for theorizing evidentiary form as a key epistemic logic associated with how conversations evolve in real-world engagement with contentious, socially consequential issues such as vaccine misinformation, while informing hybrid approaches to addressing skepticism toward established vaccine science.Keywords
Funding Information
- Provost’s Fund for Research Resilience at Cornell University
This publication has 79 references indexed in Scilit:
- Stories that engage the audience: An investigation of popular breast cancer narratives on social mediaTelematics and Informatics, 2023
- Communication of COVID-19 Misinformation on Social Media by Physicians in the USJAMA Network Open, 2023
- Narrative counters: Understanding the efficacy of narratives in combating anecdote-based vaccine misinformationPublic Relations Review, 2022
- Primacy effect of emotions in social stories: User engagement behaviors with breast cancer narratives on FacebookComputers in Human Behavior, 2022
- The Psychology of Fake NewsTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2021
- Can science literacy help individuals identify misinformation in everyday life?Science Education, 2020
- How stories generate consumer engagement: An exploratory studyJournal of Business Research, 2019
- “This is fake news”: Investigating the role of conformity to other users’ views when commenting on and spreading disinformation in social mediaComputers in Human Behavior, 2019
- What to Believe? Social Media Commentary and Belief in MisinformationPolitical Behavior, 2018
- Understanding lurkers in online communities: A literature reviewComputers in Human Behavior, 2014