PZPengfei Zhao

Pengfei Zhao

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Pengfei Zhao has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Two Paths of Conversation: How Stories and Statistics are Associated With Community Engagement in Online Debate Surrounding Vaccine Science Skeptical Content

    by Han Li, Inhwan Bae, Pengfei Zhao, Natalie Bazarova, Drew Margolin

    Statistical and narrative evidence represent two distinct ways of substantiating claims in public reasoning, but does this distinction matter for how people engage with vaccine science skeptical (VSS) content and the discursive spaces surrounding it? This study addresses this question through a large-scale, LLM-assisted observational analysis of online engagement with VSS posts and comments that support or counter such content using statistical versus narrative evidence in the Reddit community r/DebateVaccines . Building on Fisher’s distinction between rational and narrative paradigms , we theorize two paths of conversation through which evidentiary forms are associated with audience engagement with contentious vaccine discourses in a naturalistic social media setting: a rational pathway, marked by concentrated participation and corrective contestation around statistical claims and counterclaims, tending toward a single evidence-based truth “approved” by one-click reactions; and a narrative pathway, characterized by generative engagement featuring broader and more distributed participation, more discursive and generative engagement, and greater acceptance of competing viewpoints. These findings provide a springboard for theorizing evidentiary form as a key epistemic logic associated with how conversations evolve in real-world engagement with contentious, socially consequential issues such as vaccine misinformation, while informing hybrid approaches to addressing skepticism toward established vaccine science.

  • Open Access

    Involving AI in Public Moral Dialogue: Can AI Serve as a Legitimate Moral Actor to Address Problematic Online Speech?

    by Pengfei Zhao, Natalie Bazarova, Drew Margolin

    AI is increasingly used in domains requiring moral evaluation. As AI becomes more capable of producing human-like communication, a fundamental question emerges: can AI be accepted not only as a tool, but as a legitimate moral voice? We address this question through two preregistered experiments (Study 1: N = 1,295; Study 2: N = 1,276) examining responses to AI as a counter-speaker against online toxicity. Across both studies, evaluations of AI in moral contexts were multi-dimensional: on one hand, AI was perceived as fairer than humans, and this fairness enhanced evaluations of AI-delivered counterspeech. On the other hand, AI was perceived as lower in agency, undermining its legitimacy as a moral actor. These competing perceptions explain why AI-delivered counterspeech is pragmatically effective yet morally uncomfortable. The findings advance theorizing about AI as a moral actor in public communication and reveal when AI counterspeech is most likely to be accepted.

  • Open Access

    When Countering Toxicity Becomes the Norm: Competing Forces of Harassment and Objection in Online Communities

    by Inhwan Bae, Natalie Bazarova, Pengfei Zhao, Winice Hui, René Kizilcec, Drew Margolin

    While online harassment is commonplace on many social media platforms, it often does not go unanswered, prompting counterspeech from community members who object to problematic behavior. As competing social normative forces, harassment and objections to it can shape the community's perceptions of its norms. To investigate their influence, we conducted a large-scale experiment (N = 1,092) on a simulated social media with full functionality. Our results indicate that the increased actual frequency of harassment and objection leads to correspondingly stronger norm perceptions. We find that more objections strengthened disapproval of harassment, but only when harassment was frequent. Notably, when frequent harassment was largely met with objections, subjects’ sense that the community disapproved of harassment was comparable to that in a harassment-free community. Furthermore, harassment increased participants’ willingness to object in the future, but reduced their intention to continue using the community. Our results highlight how community-driven objections can effectively establish prosocial social norms, effectively overriding the influence of harassment.

  • Open Access

    Restorative justice appeals trump retributive vigilance on social media

    by Pengfei Zhao, Natalie N Bazarova, Inhwan Bae, Winice Hui, René F Kizilcec, Drew Margolin

    Human beings have a powerful urge to confront wrongdoing and reestablish justice. In online spaces, this typically takes the form of vigilante-like actions that shame or threaten wrongdoers. Though morally motivated, these retributive actions can draw disapproval, and even reciprocal shaming and threats, from others in the community, creating a toxic environment. This study investigates a prosocial alternative to retribution—restorative vigilance—aimed at reestablishing community values through moral appeals and encouraging apologies from offenders. We conducted two randomized experiments (N = 3,516 in total) on a simulated social media platform to examine how community members perceive and respond to different forms of vigilante interventions. Through observing actual user behaviors, our study demonstrates the effectiveness of restorative justice appeals in facilitating prosocial norms and achieving community goals. Specifically, the results reveal that while retribution is considered a legitimate response, restorative appeals are seen as a more effective way to achieve justice. Consequently, restorative responses elicit more supportive behaviors from the community, evidenced by increased upvotes and reduced downvotes/flags, as well as enhancing community members' satisfaction and future engagement intentions. However, in cases involving morally irredeemable offenders, the preference for restorative approaches over retribution diminishes. Our research sheds light on reasons why retribution is so common and directly informs interventions to promote restorative justice and foster more constructive and civil online communities.

  • Open Access

    Standing up to problematic content on social media: which objection strategies draw the audience’s approval?

    by Pengfei Zhao, Natalie N Bazarova, Dominic DiFranzo, Winice Hui, René F Kizilcec, Drew Margolin

    Problematic content on social media can be countered through objections raised by other community members. While intended to deter offenses, objections can influence the surrounding audience observing the interaction, leading to their collective approval or disapproval. The results of an experiment manipulating seven types of objections against common types of offenses indicate audiences’ support for objections that implore via appeals and disapproval of objections that threaten the offender, as they view the former as more moral, appropriate, and effective compared to the latter. Furthermore, audiences tend to prefer more benign and less threatening objections regardless of the offense severity (following the principle of “taking the high road”) instead of objections proportionate to the offense (“an eye for an eye”). Taken together, these results show how objections to offensive behaviors may impact collective perceptions on social media, paving the way for interventions to foster effective objection strategies in social media discussions.


  • Open Access

    Digital parenting divides: the role of parental capital and digital parenting readiness in parental digital mediation

    by Pengfei Zhao, Natalie N Bazarova, Natercia Valle

    This study investigates digital parenting divides, or how parents' strategies for regulating their children’s online activities differ based on their available resources and digital parenting readiness (i.e., digital parenting self-efficacy, attitudes, and knowledge). We conducted a survey of 530 parents that reflected the composition of the U.S. population to explore how parents’ resources and digital parenting readiness predict their digital mediation strategies. The results indicate that parents’ economic, social, and cultural resources, as well as their digital parenting readiness, play a significant role in how they approach digital mediation. Furthermore, digital parenting readiness has emerged as an underlying mechanism explaining the relationship between parental resources and parental mediation strategies. The presence of digital parenting divides highlights the need for tailored interventions to support parents in effectively using digital mediation strategies based on their family’s circumstances.


  • Individualistic Privacy Theories

    by Natalie N. Bazarova, Pengfei Zhao

    Individualistic privacy approaches have dominated the field of privacy for decades and continue to be a keystone for understanding how people manage privacy offline and online. Some of their assumptions have been recently questioned, however, in light of social media practices for sharing and transferring personal information. In order to understand what is still tenable and what needs to be revisited and redrawn, we seek to establish in this chapter the core assumptions of individualistic privacy approaches and how they are embedded in privacy research. In particular, we discuss the role of control, agency, and bounded rationality in privacy management, with a special focus on what we call situationally bounded privacy and hyper-ambivalent spaces of social media. We also review some of the foundational theories, as well as emergent directions and recent extensions in individualistic privacy research. By reflecting critically on the assumptions, theoretical frameworks, and emergent research extensions, our goal is to contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of privacy in social media.