Where Judgement Fails: Pitfalls in the Selection Process for Medical Personnel
Authors:
- Kevin W. EvaKEKevin W. Eva
- Harold I. ReiterHRHarold I. Reiter
- 1 June 2004
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Advances in Health Sciences Education
- Vol. 9 (2) , 161-174
Abstract
Despite the critical importance of maintaining a valid and transparent selection process that serves the values held by all stakeholders involved in medical education (i.e., students, faculty, society), there continue to be problems with the current state of available admissions protocols. Some problems derive from inertia induced by inaccurate intuitions pertaining to the nature of admissions protocols and the underlying qualities being measured. Others arise from the lack of reliable and valid admissions protocols to capture the non-cognitive qualities of candidates. Still other issues arise from the problem of rumor-based perceptions regarding the qualities for which selection protocols select. Three articles in this issue of Advances in Health Sciences Education present evidence pertaining to the selection of medical personnel. This commentary represents an attempt to bind together these unique perspectives on the admissions process while also casting light on other ways in which human judgment can fail in this domain in the hope that it might help steer decision-makers away from these pitfalls.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Investigating the Reliability of the Medical School Admissions InterviewAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2004
- Use of the Paired-Comparison Technique to Determine the Most Valued Qualities of the McMaster Medical Programme Admissions ProcessAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2004
- The Lore of Admissions Policies: Contrasting Formal and Informal Understandings of the Residency Selection ProcessAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2004
- On the generality of specificityMedical Education, 2003
- Assessing Personal Qualities in Medical School AdmissionsAcademic Medicine, 2003
- Reliability and Validity of Admissions Tools Used to Select Students for the Health ProfessionsAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2001
- Self-reports: How the questions shape the answers.American Psychologist, 1999
- Exploring the Etiology of Content SpecificityAcademic Medicine, 1998
- An objective structured clinical examination for the licentiate of the Medical Council of CanadaAcademic Medicine, 1993
- The interview in the admission processAcademic Medicine, 1990