From Talk to Text: Improving Feedback Concordance With a Simple Intervention
Open Access
- 20 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in AEM Education and Training
- Vol. 10 (3) , e70181
Abstract
Background: High‐quality written feedback is critical to learner development. Actionable feedback is essential in emergency medicine (EM), where students do not consistently rotate with the same supervisor. Medical students frequently report dissatisfaction with feedback due to inadequate quantity, vagueness, and discordance between verbal and written elements. Educational scripts, sometimes referred to as “scaffolds”, prompt people to respond in a desired manner and show potential as an intervention to encourage clinical feedback. Methods: We incorporated a “stop and think” verification question in medical student assessments. Supervisors answered yes or no to the statement: “I discussed this feedback with the student.” We hypothesized this would improve students' assessment of feedback quality and verbal‐written feedback concordance. Outcomes include three feedback perception questions added to the end‐of‐clerkship student evaluations and qualitative analysis of the types of narrative feedback provided. We prospectively collected 8 months of assessment data ( n = 82) and compared pre‐intervention data to 5 months of post‐intervention data ( n = 49) for length and content. Results: The percentage of students rating the quality of clerkship feedback as excellent or very good remained stable (62% vs. 74%, p 0.76). Students reporting concordance of the verbal and written feedback the majority of the time improved significantly from 72% to 87% ( p < 0.001). Importantly, the proportion of students reporting feedback concordance more than 75% of the time increased from 37% to 67%. The content and type of written feedback did not change. The intervention did not change assessment response rate for supervisors or learners (36% vs. 36%; 74% vs. 72%, respectively). Conclusions: A verification question added to student assessment forms can positively impact student perceptions of verbal‐written feedback concordance without altering the content of feedback provided, including actionability. This easy‐to‐implement strategy provides one mechanism to encourage supervisors to provide more feedback to trainees.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Strategies to develop an efficient feedback system in medical education and its outcome – An interventional studyMedical Teacher, 2024
- Virtual suturing skills learning: role of verbal versus written feedback in surgery rotation clerkshipMedical Education Online, 2022
- Numbers Encapsulate, Words Elaborate: Toward the Best Use of Comments for Assessment and Feedback on Entrustment RatingsAcademic Medicine, 2021
- Feedback for Learners in Medical Education: What Is Known? A Scoping ReviewAcademic Medicine, 2017
- The “Educational Alliance” as a Framework for Reconceptualizing Feedback in Medical EducationAcademic Medicine, 2015
- Toward a Script Theory of Guidance in Computer-Supported Collaborative LearningEducational Psychologist, 2013
- Improving Medical Student Feedback With a Clinical Encounter CardAcademic Pediatrics, 2007
- Emergency Department Crowding: The Effect on Resident EducationAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2005
- Using qualitative studies to improve the usability of an EMRJournal of Biomedical Informatics, 2005
- Attending, house officer, and medical student perceptions about teaching in the third-year medical school general surgery clerkshipJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2004