EHElizabeth Holman

Elizabeth Holman

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Elizabeth Holman has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    From Talk to Text: Improving Feedback Concordance With a Simple Intervention

    by Rachael Tesorero, Isabel J. Hsu, Beth Holman, Joseph House, Dan Dinh, Laura R. Hopson

    Background: High‐quality written feedback is critical to learner development. Actionable feedback is essential in emergency medicine (EM), where students do not consistently rotate with the same supervisor. Medical students frequently report dissatisfaction with feedback due to inadequate quantity, vagueness, and discordance between verbal and written elements. Educational scripts, sometimes referred to as “scaffolds”, prompt people to respond in a desired manner and show potential as an intervention to encourage clinical feedback. Methods: We incorporated a “stop and think” verification question in medical student assessments. Supervisors answered yes or no to the statement: “I discussed this feedback with the student.” We hypothesized this would improve students' assessment of feedback quality and verbal‐written feedback concordance. Outcomes include three feedback perception questions added to the end‐of‐clerkship student evaluations and qualitative analysis of the types of narrative feedback provided. We prospectively collected 8 months of assessment data ( n = 82) and compared pre‐intervention data to 5 months of post‐intervention data ( n = 49) for length and content. Results: The percentage of students rating the quality of clerkship feedback as excellent or very good remained stable (62% vs. 74%, p 0.76). Students reporting concordance of the verbal and written feedback the majority of the time improved significantly from 72% to 87% ( p < 0.001). Importantly, the proportion of students reporting feedback concordance more than 75% of the time increased from 37% to 67%. The content and type of written feedback did not change. The intervention did not change assessment response rate for supervisors or learners (36% vs. 36%; 74% vs. 72%, respectively). Conclusions: A verification question added to student assessment forms can positively impact student perceptions of verbal‐written feedback concordance without altering the content of feedback provided, including actionability. This easy‐to‐implement strategy provides one mechanism to encourage supervisors to provide more feedback to trainees.

  • Open Access

    Analysis of emergency medicine clerkship grades by identification as underrepresented in medicine (URiM) versus non‐URiM

    by Kevin Walsh, Joseph House, Elizabeth Holman, Laura R. Hopson

    Background: Previous studies identified racial differences in core clinical clerkship evaluations and components of residency applications, including the medical school performance evaluation and standard letter of evaluation. However, there are no studies that have examined grading differences in the emergency medicine (EM) clerkship. Our goal was to determine whether there are differences in EM clerkship grades and its components (National Board of Medical Examiners [NBME] exam scores and clinical assessments) between underrepresented in medicine (URiM) and non‐URiM students.Methods: This retrospective sample was drawn from University of Michigan Medical School students with graduation year (GY) 2021 or 2022 who completed the required EM clerkship. We compared overall composite scores on the EM clerkship, EM NBME exam score, and clinical assessments between URiM and non‐URiM students.Results: A total of 334 students completed an EM rotation in GY 2021 and 2022. Eleven students with “missing” race data were excluded. Fifty‐two (16.1%) identified as URiM while 271 (83.9%) identified as non‐URiM. Non‐URiM students significantly outperformed the URiM group (non‐URiM mean 81.2, URiM mean 77.6; p = 0.0001). There was no statistically significant difference for clinical performance (6.71 vs 6.49 p = 0.057). Overall clerkship grades differed, as URiM students had higher percentages of “pass” grades (32.7%) and lower percentages of “honors” grades (40.4%) than non‐URiM students (13.7%, 59.4%). When controlling for NBME shelf exam score, there were still differences in outcomes between URiM and non‐URiM students.Conclusions: There are grading differences between students who identified as URiM and non‐URiM. There is a statistically significant difference with respect to outcomes on NBME shelf exam scores, which is responsible for a portion of these differences; however, when controlled for NBME scores, there was still a difference between these two groups. This calls for a change in how students are evaluated to address equity concerns in clinical assessments.