Harmonic publication and citation counting: sharing authorship credit equitably – not equally, geometrically or arithmetically
Author:
Open Access
- 16 December 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientometrics
- Vol. 84 (3) , 785-793
Abstract
Bibliometric counting methods need to be validated against perceived notions of authorship credit allocation, and standardized by rejecting methods with poor fit or questionable ethical implications. Harmonic counting meets these concerns by exhibiting a robust fit to previously published empirical data from medicine, psychology and chemistry, and by complying with three basic ethical criteria for the equitable sharing of authorship credit. Harmonic counting can also incorporate additional byline information about equal contribution, or the elevated status of a corresponding last author. By contrast, several previously proposed counting schemes from the bibliometric literature including arithmetic, geometric and fractional counting, do not fit the empirical data as well and do not consistently meet the ethical criteria. In conclusion, harmonic counting would seem to provide unrivalled accuracy, fairness and flexibility to the long overdue task of standardizing bibliometric allocation of publication and citation credit.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Loads of special authorship functions: Linear growth in the percentage of “equal first authors” and corresponding authorsJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2009
- Research Note—The Researcher as a Consumer of Scientific Publications: How Do Name-Ordering Conventions Affect Inferences About Contribution Credits?Marketing Science, 2009
- Credit for CoauthorsScience, 2009
- Harmonic Allocation of Authorship Credit: Source-Level Correction of Bibliometric Bias Assures Accurate Publication and Citation AnalysisPLOS ONE, 2008
- The write positionEMBO Reports, 2007
- Methods for accrediting publications to authors or countries: Consequences for evaluation studiesJournal of the American Society for Information Science, 2000
- Multiple AuthorshipScience, 1981
- Production and Citation Measures in the Sociology of Science: The Problem of Multiple AuthorshipSocial Studies of Science, 1980
- Patterns of Name Ordering Among Authors of Scientific Papers: A Study of Social Symbolism and Its AmbiguityAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1968
- Mathematical AuthorshipScience, 1964