Nils T. Hagen
Nils T. Hagen has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Cagan Hakki Sekercioglu
School of Biological Sciences, University of Utah Salt Lake City Utah USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 December 2014
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 1
Publication metrics: Improved accuracy is necessary and attainable
The primary purpose of metrics is to measure publication performance. Individual, institutional and national players involved in knowledge production all want to know how well they are doing in relation to others. Their shared concern is to avoid being misguided by flawed metrics. Nevertheless, a common flaw is that contemporary metrics ignore differential coauthor contribution, by allocating equal publication credit to all coauthors irrespective of their actual contribution. The ensuing equalizing bias (EqB) skews bibliometric assessments, and accounts for a massive shift of credit from primary to secondary authors.Biased equal credit scores produce distorted publication performance rankings that are fundamentally different from rankings obtained from estimates of actual coauthor credit (Hagen 2014a). Furthermore, the powerful distortional effect of EqB is inevitably compounded in derived bibliometric indices and indicators. EqB may also provide an incentive for unethical behaviour, including unwarranted claims for “honorary authorship” or “institutional plagiarism”. Nonetheless, EqB is still universally unaccounted for in modern metrics-based research evaluation.The key to more reliable publication metrics is accurate accreditation of coauthors, based on all relevant byline information in bibliometric source data. This task is facilitated by the harmonic formula, which provides a transparent and verifiable quantification of the byline hierarchy. The harmonic formula provides accuracy and parsimony by adhering to three simple ethical criteria for the equitable distribution of authorship credit, and also accommodates additional byline information indicating the equality of some or all coauthors, or the presence of a senior author.A recent study found that the harmonic formula explained nearly 97% of the variation in a composite empirical dataset (Hagen 2013). In contrast, biased equal credit explained less than 40% of the variation, while EqB accounted for the approximately 60% discrepancy between the equal and harmonic estimates. A follow-up theoretical analysis showed that the amount of EqB increases as the number of coauthors increases, and suggested that most conventional credit scores are likely to be dominated by EqB when the number of coauthors exceeds 12 (Hagen 2014b). The implication is that a quantum leap in the accuracy of publication metrics is readily attainable, with minor source-level modification of existing information retrieval technology.References (Open access)Hagen, N.T. 2013. Harmonic coauthor credit: A parsimonious quantification of the byline hierarchy. Journal of Informetrics 7(4):784–791. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2013.06.005Hagen, N.T. 2014a. Counting and comparing publication output with and without equalizing and inflationary bias. Journal of Informetrics 8(2):310-317. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2014.01.003Hagen, N.T. 2014b. Reversing the byline hierarchy: The effect of equalizing bias on the accreditation of primary, secondary and senior authors. Journal of Informetrics 8(3):618-627. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2014.05.003
- 10 December 2014
- Published by UiT The Arctic University of Norway in Septentrio Conference Series
- No. 1
Open AccessPublication metrics: Improved accuracy is necessary and attainable
The primary purpose of metrics is to measure publication performance. Individual, institutional and national players involved in knowledge production all want to know how well they are doing in relation to others. Their shared concern is to avoid being misguided by flawed metrics. Nevertheless, a common flaw is that contemporary metrics ignore differential coauthor contribution, by allocating equal publication credit to all coauthors irrespective of their actual contribution. The ensuing equalizing bias (EqB) skews bibliometric assessments, and accounts for a massive shift of credit from primary to secondary authors.Biased equal credit scores produce distorted publication performance rankings that are fundamentally different from rankings obtained from estimates of actual coauthor credit (Hagen 2014a). Furthermore, the powerful distortional effect of EqB is inevitably compounded in derived bibliometric indices and indicators. EqB may also provide an incentive for unethical behaviour, including unwarranted claims for “honorary authorship” or “institutional plagiarism”. Nonetheless, EqB is still universally unaccounted for in modern metrics-based research evaluation.The key to more reliable publication metrics is accurate accreditation of coauthors, based on all relevant byline information in bibliometric source data. This task is facilitated by the harmonic formula, which provides a transparent and verifiable quantification of the byline hierarchy. The harmonic formula provides accuracy and parsimony by adhering to three simple ethical criteria for the equitable distribution of authorship credit, and also accommodates additional byline information indicating the equality of some or all coauthors, or the presence of a senior author.A recent study found that the harmonic formula explained nearly 97% of the variation in a composite empirical dataset (Hagen 2013). In contrast, biased equal credit explained less than 40% of the variation, while EqB accounted for the approximately 60% discrepancy between the equal and harmonic estimates. A follow-up theoretical analysis showed that the amount of EqB increases as the number of coauthors increases, and suggested that most conventional credit scores are likely to be dominated by EqB when the number of coauthors exceeds 12 (Hagen 2014b). The implication is that a quantum leap in the accuracy of publication metrics is readily attainable, with minor source-level modification of existing information retrieval technology.References (Open access)Hagen, N.T. 2013. Harmonic coauthor credit: A parsimonious quantification of the byline hierarchy. Journal of Informetrics 7(4):784–791. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2013.06.005Hagen, N.T. 2014a. Counting and comparing publication output with and without equalizing and inflationary bias. Journal of Informetrics 8(2):310-317. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2014.01.003Hagen, N.T. 2014b. Reversing the byline hierarchy: The effect of equalizing bias on the accreditation of primary, secondary and senior authors. Journal of Informetrics 8(3):618-627. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2014.05.003
- Open Access
- 31 March 2010
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientometrics
- Vol. 85 (2) , 567-579
Deconstructing doctoral dissertations: how many papers does it take to make a PhD?
A collection of coauthored papers is the new norm for doctoral dissertations in the natural and biomedical sciences, yet there is no consensus on how to partition authorship credit between PhD candidates and their coauthors. Guidelines for PhD programs vary but tend to specify only a suggested range for the number of papers to be submitted for evaluation, sometimes supplemented with a requirement for the PhD candidate to be the principal author on the majority of submitted papers. Here I use harmonic counting to quantify the actual amount of authorship credit attributable to individual PhD graduates from two Scandinavian universities in 2008. Harmonic counting corrects for the inherent inflationary and equalizing biases of routine counting methods, thereby allowing the bibliometrically identifiable amount of authorship credit in approved dissertations to be analyzed with unprecedented accuracy. Unbiased partitioning of authorship credit between graduates and their coauthors provides a post hoc bibliometric measure of current PhD requirements, and sets a de facto baseline for the requisite scientific productivity of these contemporary PhD’s at a median value of approximately 1.6 undivided papers per dissertation. Comparison with previous census data suggests that the baseline has shifted over the past two decades as a result of a decrease in the number of submitted papers per candidate and an increase in the number of coauthors per paper. A simple solution to this shifting baseline syndrome would be to benchmark the amount of unbiased authorship credit deemed necessary for successful completion of a specific PhD program, and then monitor for departures from this level over time. Harmonic partitioning of authorship credit also facilitates cross-disciplinary and inter-institutional analysis of the scientific output from different PhD programs. Juxtaposing bibliometric benchmarks with current baselines may thus assist the development of harmonized guidelines and transparent transnational quality assurance procedures for doctoral programs by providing a robust and meaningful standard for further exploration of the causes of intra- and inter-institutional variation in the amount of unbiased authorship credit per dissertation.
- 31 March 2010
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientometrics
- Vol. 85 (2) , 567-579
Open AccessDeconstructing doctoral dissertations: how many papers does it take to make a PhD?
A collection of coauthored papers is the new norm for doctoral dissertations in the natural and biomedical sciences, yet there is no consensus on how to partition authorship credit between PhD candidates and their coauthors. Guidelines for PhD programs vary but tend to specify only a suggested range for the number of papers to be submitted for evaluation, sometimes supplemented with a requirement for the PhD candidate to be the principal author on the majority of submitted papers. Here I use harmonic counting to quantify the actual amount of authorship credit attributable to individual PhD graduates from two Scandinavian universities in 2008. Harmonic counting corrects for the inherent inflationary and equalizing biases of routine counting methods, thereby allowing the bibliometrically identifiable amount of authorship credit in approved dissertations to be analyzed with unprecedented accuracy. Unbiased partitioning of authorship credit between graduates and their coauthors provides a post hoc bibliometric measure of current PhD requirements, and sets a de facto baseline for the requisite scientific productivity of these contemporary PhD’s at a median value of approximately 1.6 undivided papers per dissertation. Comparison with previous census data suggests that the baseline has shifted over the past two decades as a result of a decrease in the number of submitted papers per candidate and an increase in the number of coauthors per paper. A simple solution to this shifting baseline syndrome would be to benchmark the amount of unbiased authorship credit deemed necessary for successful completion of a specific PhD program, and then monitor for departures from this level over time. Harmonic partitioning of authorship credit also facilitates cross-disciplinary and inter-institutional analysis of the scientific output from different PhD programs. Juxtaposing bibliometric benchmarks with current baselines may thus assist the development of harmonized guidelines and transparent transnational quality assurance procedures for doctoral programs by providing a robust and meaningful standard for further exploration of the causes of intra- and inter-institutional variation in the amount of unbiased authorship credit per dissertation.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2009
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientometrics
- Vol. 84 (3) , 785-793
Harmonic publication and citation counting: sharing authorship credit equitably – not equally, geometrically or arithmetically
Bibliometric counting methods need to be validated against perceived notions of authorship credit allocation, and standardized by rejecting methods with poor fit or questionable ethical implications. Harmonic counting meets these concerns by exhibiting a robust fit to previously published empirical data from medicine, psychology and chemistry, and by complying with three basic ethical criteria for the equitable sharing of authorship credit. Harmonic counting can also incorporate additional byline information about equal contribution, or the elevated status of a corresponding last author. By contrast, several previously proposed counting schemes from the bibliometric literature including arithmetic, geometric and fractional counting, do not fit the empirical data as well and do not consistently meet the ethical criteria. In conclusion, harmonic counting would seem to provide unrivalled accuracy, fairness and flexibility to the long overdue task of standardizing bibliometric allocation of publication and citation credit.
- 16 December 2009
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientometrics
- Vol. 84 (3) , 785-793
Open AccessHarmonic publication and citation counting: sharing authorship credit equitably – not equally, geometrically or arithmetically
Bibliometric counting methods need to be validated against perceived notions of authorship credit allocation, and standardized by rejecting methods with poor fit or questionable ethical implications. Harmonic counting meets these concerns by exhibiting a robust fit to previously published empirical data from medicine, psychology and chemistry, and by complying with three basic ethical criteria for the equitable sharing of authorship credit. Harmonic counting can also incorporate additional byline information about equal contribution, or the elevated status of a corresponding last author. By contrast, several previously proposed counting schemes from the bibliometric literature including arithmetic, geometric and fractional counting, do not fit the empirical data as well and do not consistently meet the ethical criteria. In conclusion, harmonic counting would seem to provide unrivalled accuracy, fairness and flexibility to the long overdue task of standardizing bibliometric allocation of publication and citation credit.
- 30 January 2009
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science
- Vol. 323 (5914) , 583
Credit for Coauthors
- 30 January 2009
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science
- Vol. 323 (5914) , 583
Credit for Coauthors
- Open Access
- 24 December 2008
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 3 (12) , e4021
Harmonic Allocation of Authorship Credit: Source-Level Correction of Bibliometric Bias Assures Accurate Publication and Citation Analysis
Authorship credit for multi-authored scientific publications is routinely allocated either by issuing full publication credit repeatedly to all coauthors, or by dividing one credit equally among all coauthors. The ensuing inflationary and equalizing biases distort derived bibliometric measures of merit by systematically benefiting secondary authors at the expense of primary authors. Here I show how harmonic counting, which allocates credit according to authorship rank and the number of coauthors, provides simultaneous source-level correction for both biases as well as accommodating further decoding of byline information. I also demonstrate large and erratic effects of counting bias on the original h-index, and show how the harmonic version of the h-index provides unbiased bibliometric ranking of scientific merit while retaining the original's essential simplicity, transparency and intended fairness. Harmonic decoding of byline information resolves the conundrum of authorship credit allocation by providing a simple recipe for source-level correction of inflationary and equalizing bias. Harmonic counting could also offer unrivalled accuracy in automated assessments of scientific productivity, impact and achievement.
- 24 December 2008
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 3 (12) , e4021
Open AccessHarmonic Allocation of Authorship Credit: Source-Level Correction of Bibliometric Bias Assures Accurate Publication and Citation Analysis
Authorship credit for multi-authored scientific publications is routinely allocated either by issuing full publication credit repeatedly to all coauthors, or by dividing one credit equally among all coauthors. The ensuing inflationary and equalizing biases distort derived bibliometric measures of merit by systematically benefiting secondary authors at the expense of primary authors. Here I show how harmonic counting, which allocates credit according to authorship rank and the number of coauthors, provides simultaneous source-level correction for both biases as well as accommodating further decoding of byline information. I also demonstrate large and erratic effects of counting bias on the original h-index, and show how the harmonic version of the h-index provides unbiased bibliometric ranking of scientific merit while retaining the original's essential simplicity, transparency and intended fairness. Harmonic decoding of byline information resolves the conundrum of authorship credit allocation by providing a simple recipe for source-level correction of inflationary and equalizing bias. Harmonic counting could also offer unrivalled accuracy in automated assessments of scientific productivity, impact and achievement.
- Open Access
- 23 November 2007
- Published by Springer Nature in Marine Biology
- Vol. 153 (5) , 907-924
Enlarged lantern size in similar-sized, sympatric, sibling species of Strongylocentrotid sea urchins: from phenotypic accommodation to functional adaptation for durophagy
- 23 November 2007
- Published by Springer Nature in Marine Biology
- Vol. 153 (5) , 907-924
Open AccessEnlarged lantern size in similar-sized, sympatric, sibling species of Strongylocentrotid sea urchins: from phenotypic accommodation to functional adaptation for durophagy