Analysis of Iron Manganese Nickel Oxide/Hard Carbon Na-Ion Battery Degradation Modes and Mechanisms

Authors:

Abstract
Since the start of Sandia’s study on commercially available Na-ion batteries, more suppliers have entered the Na-ion battery market. However, the ability of these new systems to serve as drop-in replacements for Li-ion technologies has yet to be fully evaluated. Initial results from our cycling study of Na-ion cells, featuring a sodium iron manganese nickel oxide (Na(FexMnyNiz)O) positive electrode and a hard carbon negative electrode from two different manufacturers, were obtained by cycling at various temperatures and C rates. These results indicated that the first generation of cells we purchased was not ready for widespread commercial adoption. After 300 cycles, all cells from both manufacturers reached 80% of their initial capacity, with many cells dropping below 40% capacity. This suggests that the first generation of cells is unsuitable for broad commercial use in high-intensity applications. Initial materials characterization revealed that both cells had similar chemistries, with only minor differences in electrolyte composition and operating ranges, suggesting shared origins for the high degradation rate. Both cells exhibited similar sensitivities to temperature and discharge rate, with lower temperatures accelerating degradation. Discharge rates did not show clear trends during cycling for either cell. XCT analysis of the cycled cells indicates significant deformation of the jelly roll in most cases, with some cells exhibiting substantial cracking of the electrode material. We will present data from postmortem teardown analysis of the cells, including XRD, SEM, ICP-OES, and XPS analyses of the electrodes, to determine the degradation modes that occurred during cycling. Additionally, we will present initial results from our survey of the cycling performance of various cells purchased eighteen months after acquiring the first generation, to assess changes in manufacturing quality. SNL is managed and operated by NTESS under DOE NNSA contract DE-NA0003525. SAND2025-04498A This material is based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Electricity (OE), Energy Storage Division.