Robust Tuning of Multiresonant Current Controllers for Grid-Tied Converters and Erroneous Use of the Naslin Polynomial Method
Open Access
- 18 August 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Access
- Vol. 10, 88211-88225
Abstract
The majority of the paper is devoted to debunking flawed methods proposed in the literature within the context of multiresonant control systems for grid-connected converters and then a novel approach is proposed. Several flawed approaches to grid tied power electronic converters (rectifiers and shunt active power filters) are discussed to initiate a critical discussion regarding some tuning methods reported in the topical literature. In this paper we analytically show that some of them are even erroneous from the control theory point of view or are based on mathematically erroneous derivations. That is especially prevalent for papers in which the Naslin polynomial method is employed to tune proportional-multiresonant controllers. Some authors recognize that the resulting control systems are not robust, i.e. not practical, and use obtained gains only as a starting point for further tuning using the trial and error method or evolutionary global optimization. Robustness of such systems is often not guaranteed and if it occurs at all, it is by chance or thanks to a combination of luck and expert knowledge of the engineer (not by deliberate design). Therefore, the absence of such a guarantee motivates the search for better ways to tune such controllers. As a result, a practical robust controller tuning method for multiresonant grid current controllers is proposed and verified experimentally. We are convinced that one of the solutions can be based on the disk margin stability analysis and a global search algorithm. The required robustness is expressed as stability margins. The design procedure is very user-friendly and the disk size is the key design parameter to be selected by an engineer. The practicality of the tuning method is demonstrated empirically in a 10 kVA physical grid-tied converter.Keywords
Funding Information
- frame of statutory funding for the Institute of Control and Industrial Electronics, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Warsaw University of Technology
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Robust Control Scheme for Three-Phase Grid-Connected Inverters With LCL-Filter Under Unbalanced and Distorted Grid ConditionsIEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, 2017
- Tuning of a PI-MR Controller Based on Differential Evolution Metaheuristic Applied to the Current Control Loop of a Shunt-APFIEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 2017
- Selective Harmonic Elimination Model Predictive Control for Multilevel Power ConvertersIEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, 2016
- Improvement of unified power quality conditioner performance with enhanced resonant control strategyIET Generation, Transmission & Distribution, 2014
- Embedded Online Optimization for Model Predictive Control at Megahertz RatesIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 2014
- Particle Swarm Optimization of the Multioscillatory LQR for a Three-Phase Four-Wire Voltage-Source Inverter With an $LC$ Output FilterIEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 2014
- Limitations of Voltage-Oriented PI Current Control of Grid-Connected PWM Rectifiers With $LCL$ FiltersIEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 2008
- High Performance Current Controller for Selective Harmonic Compensation in Active Power FiltersIEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, 2007
- Practical Implementation of Delayed Signal Cancellation Method for Phase-Sequence SeparationIEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, 2006
- Transient response control via characteristic ratio assignmentIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 2003