Toward a phenomenology of mystification: The ambivalence of magic among AI technologists
Open Access
- 28 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Anthropological Theory
- Vol. 26 (3) , 260-277
Abstract
By leveraging machine learning, computer scientists and engineers have developed generative AI models so opaque that experimenting on them is often the only means to study their inner workings. In our ethnographic engagements with such technologists, we have frequently witnessed them contemplate model outputs with rapt mystification. Although accusations that AI technologists deliberately mystify investors, regulators, and consumers are certainly valid, we argue that these critiques also obscure the mystification researchers themselves experience. Taking the anthropology of magic as a point of departure, we focus on those experiences to theorize an anthropological phenomenology of mystification. Discussing the awe experienced by AI researchers, we explore how the value of mystification may be not only a byproduct of building constitutively opaque systems, but also an emergent ambition that increasingly animates the design process. Through a contrast with systems of divination, we argue that tech industry scientists experiment on AI systems not only to overcome opacity, but also to stabilize it and make it available as a resource for future interpretative acts. Far from demystifying generative models, interpretability experiments may reproduce the very sense of enchanting metaphysical excess they nominally seek to contain.Keywords
Funding Information
- Sociale en Geesteswetenschappen, NWO (VI.Veni.231S.057)
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Talking LureCurrent Anthropology, 2026
- Why artificial intelligence needs sociology of knowledge: parts I and IIAI & SOCIETY, 2024
- Language at the Limits of the Human: Deceit, Invention, and the Specter of the Unshared SymbolComparative Studies in Society and History, 2023
- The debate over understanding in AI’s large language modelsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2023
- Transparency in Complex Computational SystemsPhilosophy of Science, 2020
- Situating methods in the magic of Big Data and AICommunication Monographs, 2017
- Finance2012
- What Was Life? Answers from Three Limit BiologiesCritical Inquiry, 2011
- Displaying the American genius: the electromagnetic telegraph in the wider worldThe British Journal for the History of Science, 2001
- Divination as a Way of Knowing: Embodiment, Visualisation, Narrative, and InterpretationFolklore, 2001