Graham M. Jones
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Graham M. Jones has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Arvind Satyanarayan
CSAIL, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA
4 shared publications - Amy Rae Fox
MIT CSAIL, USA
2 shared publications Arvind Satyanarayan
2 shared publicationsMichelle Morgenstern
2 shared publications- Vesper Keyi Long
Wellesley College, USA
2 shared publications Amy Rae Fox
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Anthropological Theory
- Vol. 26 (3) , 260-277
Toward a phenomenology of mystification: The ambivalence of magic among AI technologists
By leveraging machine learning, computer scientists and engineers have developed generative AI models so opaque that experimenting on them is often the only means to study their inner workings. In our ethnographic engagements with such technologists, we have frequently witnessed them contemplate model outputs with rapt mystification. Although accusations that AI technologists deliberately mystify investors, regulators, and consumers are certainly valid, we argue that these critiques also obscure the mystification researchers themselves experience. Taking the anthropology of magic as a point of departure, we focus on those experiences to theorize an anthropological phenomenology of mystification. Discussing the awe experienced by AI researchers, we explore how the value of mystification may be not only a byproduct of building constitutively opaque systems, but also an emergent ambition that increasingly animates the design process. Through a contrast with systems of divination, we argue that tech industry scientists experiment on AI systems not only to overcome opacity, but also to stabilize it and make it available as a resource for future interpretative acts. Far from demystifying generative models, interpretability experiments may reproduce the very sense of enchanting metaphysical excess they nominally seek to contain.
- 28 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Anthropological Theory
- Vol. 26 (3) , 260-277
Open AccessToward a phenomenology of mystification: The ambivalence of magic among AI technologists
By leveraging machine learning, computer scientists and engineers have developed generative AI models so opaque that experimenting on them is often the only means to study their inner workings. In our ethnographic engagements with such technologists, we have frequently witnessed them contemplate model outputs with rapt mystification. Although accusations that AI technologists deliberately mystify investors, regulators, and consumers are certainly valid, we argue that these critiques also obscure the mystification researchers themselves experience. Taking the anthropology of magic as a point of departure, we focus on those experiences to theorize an anthropological phenomenology of mystification. Discussing the awe experienced by AI researchers, we explore how the value of mystification may be not only a byproduct of building constitutively opaque systems, but also an emergent ambition that increasingly animates the design process. Through a contrast with systems of divination, we argue that tech industry scientists experiment on AI systems not only to overcome opacity, but also to stabilize it and make it available as a resource for future interpretative acts. Far from demystifying generative models, interpretability experiments may reproduce the very sense of enchanting metaphysical excess they nominally seek to contain.
- Open Access
- 13 July 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1268-1273
The Attestation: Belief Polarization in Visual Action – A Case Study Using Magic
- 13 July 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1268-1273
Open AccessThe Attestation: Belief Polarization in Visual Action – A Case Study Using Magic
- Open Access
- 26 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 102-114
“I Need a New Name”
By taking a fictional autoethnographic approach, Yilia Yijia Qu, Vesper Long, Jamie Wong, and Graham M. Jones create an imagined narrative from a fictional fangirl's diary to investigate how fangirls in China mobilize usernames to pursue agency in a patriarchal society, as well as anonymity in the face of ubiquitous surveillance. Simultaneously shielding themselves from prying eyes and creating internal distinctions by displaying signs of allegiance to celebrity idols, fans create usernames that both conceal and reveal identity. By adopting this creative form of fictionalized but ethnographically true-to-life approach, they consider the politics of naming as a form of verbal artistry within the online subculture of Chinese fandom, offering an intimate glimpse into the ways names are involved in navigating membership in digital publics. They follow their fictional narrative with an explanation of naming conventions in China and how fandom has been one of the few spaces for the critique of traditional gender norms.
- 26 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 102-114
Open Access“I Need a New Name”
By taking a fictional autoethnographic approach, Yilia Yijia Qu, Vesper Long, Jamie Wong, and Graham M. Jones create an imagined narrative from a fictional fangirl's diary to investigate how fangirls in China mobilize usernames to pursue agency in a patriarchal society, as well as anonymity in the face of ubiquitous surveillance. Simultaneously shielding themselves from prying eyes and creating internal distinctions by displaying signs of allegiance to celebrity idols, fans create usernames that both conceal and reveal identity. By adopting this creative form of fictionalized but ethnographically true-to-life approach, they consider the politics of naming as a form of verbal artistry within the online subculture of Chinese fandom, offering an intimate glimpse into the ways names are involved in navigating membership in digital publics. They follow their fictional narrative with an explanation of naming conventions in China and how fandom has been one of the few spaces for the critique of traditional gender norms.
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics
- Vol. 32 (1) , 1273-1283
Quantifying Visualization Vibes: Measuring Socio-Indexicality at Scale
What impressions might readers form with visualizations that go beyond the data they encode? In this paper, we build on recent work that demonstrates the socio-indexical function of visualization, showing that visualizations communicate more than the data they explicitly encode. Bridging this with prior work examining public discourse about visualizations, we contribute an analytic framework for describing inferences about an artifact's social provenance. Via a series of attribution-elicitation surveys, we offer descriptive evidence that these social inferences: (1) can be studied asynchronously, (2) are not unique to a particular sociocultural group or a function of limited data literacy, and (3) may influence assessments of trust. Further, we demonstrate (4) how design features act in concert with the topic and underlying messages of an artifact's data to give rise to such ‘beyond-data’ readings. We conclude by discussing the design and research implications of inferences about social provenance, and why we believe broadening the scope of research on human factors in visualization to include sociocultural phenomena can yield actionable design recommendations to address urgent challenges in public data communication.
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics
- Vol. 32 (1) , 1273-1283
Quantifying Visualization Vibes: Measuring Socio-Indexicality at Scale
What impressions might readers form with visualizations that go beyond the data they encode? In this paper, we build on recent work that demonstrates the socio-indexical function of visualization, showing that visualizations communicate more than the data they explicitly encode. Bridging this with prior work examining public discourse about visualizations, we contribute an analytic framework for describing inferences about an artifact's social provenance. Via a series of attribution-elicitation surveys, we offer descriptive evidence that these social inferences: (1) can be studied asynchronously, (2) are not unique to a particular sociocultural group or a function of limited data literacy, and (3) may influence assessments of trust. Further, we demonstrate (4) how design features act in concert with the topic and underlying messages of an artifact's data to give rise to such ‘beyond-data’ readings. We conclude by discussing the design and research implications of inferences about social provenance, and why we believe broadening the scope of research on human factors in visualization to include sociocultural phenomena can yield actionable design recommendations to address urgent challenges in public data communication.
- Open Access
Quantifying Visualization Vibes: Measuring Socio-Indexicality at Scale
What impressions might readers form with visualizations that go beyond the data they encode? In this paper, we build on recent work that demonstrates the socio-indexical function of visualization, showing that visualizations communicate more than the data they explicitly encode. Bridging this with prior work examining public discourse about visualizations, we contribute an analytic framework for describing inferences about an artifact's social provenance. Via a series of attribution-elicitation surveys, we offer descriptive evidence that these social inferences: (1) can be studied asynchronously, (2) are not unique to a particular sociocultural group or a function of limited data literacy, and (3) may influence assessments of trust. Further, we demonstrate (4) how design features act in concert with the topic and underlying messages of an artifact's data to give rise to such 'beyond-data' readings. We conclude by discussing the design and research implications of inferences about social provenance, and why we believe broadening the scope of research on human factors in visualization to include sociocultural phenomena can yield actionable design recommendations to address urgent challenges in public data communication.
Open AccessQuantifying Visualization Vibes: Measuring Socio-Indexicality at Scale
What impressions might readers form with visualizations that go beyond the data they encode? In this paper, we build on recent work that demonstrates the socio-indexical function of visualization, showing that visualizations communicate more than the data they explicitly encode. Bridging this with prior work examining public discourse about visualizations, we contribute an analytic framework for describing inferences about an artifact's social provenance. Via a series of attribution-elicitation surveys, we offer descriptive evidence that these social inferences: (1) can be studied asynchronously, (2) are not unique to a particular sociocultural group or a function of limited data literacy, and (3) may influence assessments of trust. Further, we demonstrate (4) how design features act in concert with the topic and underlying messages of an artifact's data to give rise to such 'beyond-data' readings. We conclude by discussing the design and research implications of inferences about social provenance, and why we believe broadening the scope of research on human factors in visualization to include sociocultural phenomena can yield actionable design recommendations to address urgent challenges in public data communication.
- Open Access
Visualization Vibes: The Socio-Indexical Function of Visualization Design
In contemporary information ecologies saturated with misinformation, disinformation, and a distrust of science itself, public data communication faces significant hurdles. Although visualization research has broadened criteria for effective design, governing paradigms privilege the accurate and efficient transmission of data. Drawing on theory from linguistic anthropology, we argue that such approaches-focused on encoding and decoding propositional content-cannot fully account for how people engage with visualizations and why particular visualizations might invite adversarial or receptive responses. In this paper, we present evidence that data visualizations communicate not only semantic, propositional meaning$\unicode{x2013}$meaning about data$\unicode{x2013}$but also social, indexical meaning$\unicode{x2013}$meaning beyond data. From a series of ethnographically-informed interviews, we document how readers make rich and varied assessments of a visualization's "vibes"$\unicode{x2013}$inferences about the social provenance of a visualization based on its design features. Furthermore, these social attributions have the power to influence reception, as readers' decisions about how to engage with a visualization concern not only content, or even aesthetic appeal, but also their sense of alignment or disalignment with the entities they imagine to be involved in its production and circulation. We argue these inferences hinge on a function of human sign systems that has thus far been little studied in data visualization: socio-indexicality, whereby the formal features (rather than the content) of communication evoke social contexts, identities, and characteristics. Demonstrating the presence and significance of this socio-indexical function in visualization, this paper offers both a conceptual foundation and practical intervention for troubleshooting breakdowns in public data communication.
Open AccessVisualization Vibes: The Socio-Indexical Function of Visualization Design
In contemporary information ecologies saturated with misinformation, disinformation, and a distrust of science itself, public data communication faces significant hurdles. Although visualization research has broadened criteria for effective design, governing paradigms privilege the accurate and efficient transmission of data. Drawing on theory from linguistic anthropology, we argue that such approaches-focused on encoding and decoding propositional content-cannot fully account for how people engage with visualizations and why particular visualizations might invite adversarial or receptive responses. In this paper, we present evidence that data visualizations communicate not only semantic, propositional meaning$\unicode{x2013}$meaning about data$\unicode{x2013}$but also social, indexical meaning$\unicode{x2013}$meaning beyond data. From a series of ethnographically-informed interviews, we document how readers make rich and varied assessments of a visualization's "vibes"$\unicode{x2013}$inferences about the social provenance of a visualization based on its design features. Furthermore, these social attributions have the power to influence reception, as readers' decisions about how to engage with a visualization concern not only content, or even aesthetic appeal, but also their sense of alignment or disalignment with the entities they imagine to be involved in its production and circulation. We argue these inferences hinge on a function of human sign systems that has thus far been little studied in data visualization: socio-indexicality, whereby the formal features (rather than the content) of communication evoke social contexts, identities, and characteristics. Demonstrating the presence and significance of this socio-indexical function in visualization, this paper offers both a conceptual foundation and practical intervention for troubleshooting breakdowns in public data communication.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 29 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 12 (1)
Toward cultural interpretability: A linguistic anthropological framework for describing and evaluating large language models
This article proposes a new integration of linguistic anthropology and machine learning (ML) around convergent interests in both the underpinnings of language and making language technologies more socially responsible. While linguistic anthropology focuses on interpreting the cultural basis for human language use, the ML field of interpretability is concerned with uncovering the patterns that Large Language Models (LLMs) learn from human verbal behavior. Through the analysis of a conversation between a human user and an LLM-powered chatbot, we demonstrate the theoretical feasibility of a new, conjoint field of inquiry, cultural interpretability (CI). By focusing attention on the communicative competence involved in the way human users and AI chatbots coproduce meaning in the articulatory interface of human-computer interaction, CI emphasizes how the dynamic relationship between language and culture makes contextually sensitive, open-ended conversation possible. We suggest that, by examining how LLMs internally “represent” relationships between language and culture, CI can: (1) provide insight into long-standing linguistic anthropological questions about the patterning of those relationships; and (2) aid model developers and interface designers in improving value alignment between language models and stylistically diverse speakers and culturally diverse speech communities. Our discussion proposes three critical research axes: relativity, variation, and indexicality.
- 29 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 12 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessToward cultural interpretability: A linguistic anthropological framework for describing and evaluating large language models
This article proposes a new integration of linguistic anthropology and machine learning (ML) around convergent interests in both the underpinnings of language and making language technologies more socially responsible. While linguistic anthropology focuses on interpreting the cultural basis for human language use, the ML field of interpretability is concerned with uncovering the patterns that Large Language Models (LLMs) learn from human verbal behavior. Through the analysis of a conversation between a human user and an LLM-powered chatbot, we demonstrate the theoretical feasibility of a new, conjoint field of inquiry, cultural interpretability (CI). By focusing attention on the communicative competence involved in the way human users and AI chatbots coproduce meaning in the articulatory interface of human-computer interaction, CI emphasizes how the dynamic relationship between language and culture makes contextually sensitive, open-ended conversation possible. We suggest that, by examining how LLMs internally “represent” relationships between language and culture, CI can: (1) provide insight into long-standing linguistic anthropological questions about the patterning of those relationships; and (2) aid model developers and interface designers in improving value alignment between language models and stylistically diverse speakers and culturally diverse speech communities. Our discussion proposes three critical research axes: relativity, variation, and indexicality.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Knowledge Futures
Intelligence as Agency: Evaluating the Capacity of Generative AI to Empower or Constrain Human Action
The advent of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has ushered in an era of more open-ended computer systems. Trained to learn patterns from vast datasets of human expression, these technologies exhibit tremendous flexibility in the kinds of input they can parse and produce output that is far more contextually responsive to open-ended interactions with users. Faced with these rapidly burgeoning capabilities, researchers and designers are confronted with an urgent question: how should GenAI be harnessed in ways that empower rather than disempower people? We argue that addressing this question requires three fundamental conceptual shifts to redefine: (1) intelligence as agency, the capacity to meaningfully act, rather than the capacity to perform a task; (2) design as the delegation of constrained agency, rather than the specification of affordances; and (3) ethics as care, an ongoing relation of stewardship toward AI agents, rather than one-time responsibility audits. Developed through an interdisciplinary dialogue between computer science and anthropology, this framework centers convergent interests in design as the intentional shaping of cultural patterns. It offers technologists not only a novel descriptive instrument, capable of better characterizing the outputs and effects of GenAI models, but also suggests possible evaluative methods emphasizing the cultural bases of agentive intelligence.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Knowledge Futures
Open AccessIntelligence as Agency: Evaluating the Capacity of Generative AI to Empower or Constrain Human Action
The advent of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has ushered in an era of more open-ended computer systems. Trained to learn patterns from vast datasets of human expression, these technologies exhibit tremendous flexibility in the kinds of input they can parse and produce output that is far more contextually responsive to open-ended interactions with users. Faced with these rapidly burgeoning capabilities, researchers and designers are confronted with an urgent question: how should GenAI be harnessed in ways that empower rather than disempower people? We argue that addressing this question requires three fundamental conceptual shifts to redefine: (1) intelligence as agency, the capacity to meaningfully act, rather than the capacity to perform a task; (2) design as the delegation of constrained agency, rather than the specification of affordances; and (3) ethics as care, an ongoing relation of stewardship toward AI agents, rather than one-time responsibility audits. Developed through an interdisciplinary dialogue between computer science and anthropology, this framework centers convergent interests in design as the intentional shaping of cultural patterns. It offers technologists not only a novel descriptive instrument, capable of better characterizing the outputs and effects of GenAI models, but also suggests possible evaluative methods emphasizing the cultural bases of agentive intelligence.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Media + Society
- Vol. 7 (2)
“Let’s Go, Baby Forklift!”: Fandom Governance and the Political Power of Cuteness in China
This article describes how the Chinese state borrows from the culture of celebrity fandom to implement a novel strategy of governing that we term “fandom governance.” We illustrate how state-run social media employed fandom governance early in the COVID-19 pandemic when the country was convulsed with anxiety. As the state faced a crisis, state social media responded with a propagandistic display of state efficacy, broadcasting a round-the-clock livestream of a massive emergency hospital construction project. Chinese internet users playfully embellished imagery from the livestream. They unexpectedly transformed the construction vehicles into cute personified memes, with Baby Forklift and Baby Mud Barfer (a cement mixer) among the most popular. In turn, state social media strategically channeled this playful engagement in politically productive directions by resignifying the personified vehicles as celebrity idols. Combining social media studies with cultural and linguistic anthropology, we offer a processual account of the semiotic mediations involved in turning vehicles into memes, memes into idols, and citizens into fans. We show how, by embedding cute memes within modules of fandom management such as celebrity ranking lists, state social media rendered them artificially vulnerable to a fall in status. Fans, in turn, rallied around to “protect” these cute idols with small but significant acts of digital devotion and care, organizing themselves into fan circles and exhorting each other to vote. In elevating the memes to the status of celebrity idols, state social media thereby created a disposable pantheon of virtual avatars for the state, and consolidated state power around citizens’ voluntary response to vulnerability. We analyze fandom governance as a new development in the Chinese state’s long history of governing citizens through the management of emotion.
- 1 April 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Media + Society
- Vol. 7 (2)
Open Access“Let’s Go, Baby Forklift!”: Fandom Governance and the Political Power of Cuteness in China
This article describes how the Chinese state borrows from the culture of celebrity fandom to implement a novel strategy of governing that we term “fandom governance.” We illustrate how state-run social media employed fandom governance early in the COVID-19 pandemic when the country was convulsed with anxiety. As the state faced a crisis, state social media responded with a propagandistic display of state efficacy, broadcasting a round-the-clock livestream of a massive emergency hospital construction project. Chinese internet users playfully embellished imagery from the livestream. They unexpectedly transformed the construction vehicles into cute personified memes, with Baby Forklift and Baby Mud Barfer (a cement mixer) among the most popular. In turn, state social media strategically channeled this playful engagement in politically productive directions by resignifying the personified vehicles as celebrity idols. Combining social media studies with cultural and linguistic anthropology, we offer a processual account of the semiotic mediations involved in turning vehicles into memes, memes into idols, and citizens into fans. We show how, by embedding cute memes within modules of fandom management such as celebrity ranking lists, state social media rendered them artificially vulnerable to a fall in status. Fans, in turn, rallied around to “protect” these cute idols with small but significant acts of digital devotion and care, organizing themselves into fan circles and exhorting each other to vote. In elevating the memes to the status of celebrity idols, state social media thereby created a disposable pantheon of virtual avatars for the state, and consolidated state power around citizens’ voluntary response to vulnerability. We analyze fandom governance as a new development in the Chinese state’s long history of governing citizens through the management of emotion.
- 3 April 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Early Popular Visual Culture
- Vol. 16 (2) , 146-156
Indigenous illusionism and the global magic system
A spectacular commodification of pure illusion, the modern magic of conjuring’s golden age was also part of a loose assemblage of cultural industries – including colonial anthropology – involved in visualizing ethnic differences in ways that tended to naturalize imperialist models of globalization by denying coevalness to cultural others. Inspired by the work of scholars who emphasize multiple, alternative and indigenous forms of global modernity, I ask whether it might be possible to decenter modern magic as a category and genre, writing its history from geographical and cultural margins, and speaking in the plural about contemporaneous, but not necessarily contiguous, ‘golden ages’. Shifting attention from the metropolitan theater as the iconic site of golden-age magic performance to other synchronic settings of visual display and cultural production more closely linked to colonial peripheries, I focus on the elaboration of intercultural magic performance as a form of tourist attraction and imperial spectacle in colonial contact zones. The resulting interpretation underscores the importance of power, conflict and resistance in magic performance.
- 3 April 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Early Popular Visual Culture
- Vol. 16 (2) , 146-156
Indigenous illusionism and the global magic system
A spectacular commodification of pure illusion, the modern magic of conjuring’s golden age was also part of a loose assemblage of cultural industries – including colonial anthropology – involved in visualizing ethnic differences in ways that tended to naturalize imperialist models of globalization by denying coevalness to cultural others. Inspired by the work of scholars who emphasize multiple, alternative and indigenous forms of global modernity, I ask whether it might be possible to decenter modern magic as a category and genre, writing its history from geographical and cultural margins, and speaking in the plural about contemporaneous, but not necessarily contiguous, ‘golden ages’. Shifting attention from the metropolitan theater as the iconic site of golden-age magic performance to other synchronic settings of visual display and cultural production more closely linked to colonial peripheries, I focus on the elaboration of intercultural magic performance as a form of tourist attraction and imperial spectacle in colonial contact zones. The resulting interpretation underscores the importance of power, conflict and resistance in magic performance.