Abstract
Of all the disruptions that the Anthropocene is thought to have wrought, few are more discussed or more lamented than the die-off of non-human life on earth. And few disruptions have engendered such missionary zeal on the part of scientists as this disruption did (and does) to come up with a science-based mandate for curbing it. The result is a now-massive, decades-long research program to “prove” that biodiversity is causally responsible for ecosystem functions and therefore (it is claimed) the services on which humankind depends. This thesis has been hailed as a new paradigm for ecology and an innovative basis for justifying conservation. However, its greatest disruption has been to science itself, as scientists blinded themselves to the glaring design and interpretative flaws that systematically undermine the credibility of their evidence. This chapter explains how so many highly trained scientists could have gotten so far off track for so long and so utterly convinced themselves of the soundness of “findings” that so lacked evidential warrant. It first recounts four norms-violating behaviors, which pervade this scientific community: foregrounding a narrowly conceived conservation mission ahead of scientific investigation, making sweepingly general claims that greatly transcend even the profoundly flawed evidence for them, promoting their claims via self-referring panegyrics, and expressing absolute certainty about them. The chapter then views this community of scientists as a social network with the five telling characteristics of being: tightly knit, very compact, epistemically isolated, homophilic, and led by a prominent few. The chapter then leverages social network theory in conjunction with principles of social psychology and sociology to explain how this community’s norms-violating behaviors could have led it to settle intransigently on unwarranted beliefs. It concludes by observing that the taking hostage of scientific judgment by non-scientific commitments may have broad social significance in a disrupted world.