Donald S. Maier
Donald S. Maier has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
International Association for Environmental Philosophy
2 shared publications- Alan Feest
University of Bristol
1 shared publication - Daniel Simberloff
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, USA
1 shared publication Jeffrey A. Lockwood
1 shared publication- Justin Donhauser
Bowling Green State University
1 shared publication Michael Weber
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 9 June 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Disruptive Innovations and the Environmental Crisis
This book probes the ethical, practical, and sociopolitical implications of leveraging innovative and disruptive means to address the world’s various environmental crises. Packed with keen observations and analyses, the volume brings together research from seasoned scholars and rising stars to cast important new light on urgent issues engendered by humankind’s disruption of environments, such as climate change and biodiversity loss. It tackles the question of exactly what has been disrupted in the world—environmentally, economically, socially, and politically. It also examines an assortment of innovative interventions that aim to address disruptions and explores the question of what further disruptions may lurk behind assorted innovative interventions intended to address already existing disruptions. Chapters wrestle with the social, ethical, and ecological implications of disruptions, both pre-existing and those brought about by interventions, connected with deploying artificial gene drives, substituting robotic pollinators for living ones, synthesizing organisms to replace ones lost, installing economic regimes that work well for both citizens and the environment, making science subservient to non-scientific commitments, involving citizens in environmentally consequential decisions, choosing scientific and technological projects that most promise immediate practical payoff, and ensuring that respect for human rights is part and parcel of any technology-infused project. These discussions draw on a rich mix of science, philosophy of science, political theory, economics, sociology, network theory, ethics, and theories of justice and human rights. This book will be of great interest to students and scholars of environmental science, environmental decision-making, ecology, climate change, environmental philosophy, and the philosophy of science.
- 9 June 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Disruptive Innovations and the Environmental Crisis
This book probes the ethical, practical, and sociopolitical implications of leveraging innovative and disruptive means to address the world’s various environmental crises. Packed with keen observations and analyses, the volume brings together research from seasoned scholars and rising stars to cast important new light on urgent issues engendered by humankind’s disruption of environments, such as climate change and biodiversity loss. It tackles the question of exactly what has been disrupted in the world—environmentally, economically, socially, and politically. It also examines an assortment of innovative interventions that aim to address disruptions and explores the question of what further disruptions may lurk behind assorted innovative interventions intended to address already existing disruptions. Chapters wrestle with the social, ethical, and ecological implications of disruptions, both pre-existing and those brought about by interventions, connected with deploying artificial gene drives, substituting robotic pollinators for living ones, synthesizing organisms to replace ones lost, installing economic regimes that work well for both citizens and the environment, making science subservient to non-scientific commitments, involving citizens in environmentally consequential decisions, choosing scientific and technological projects that most promise immediate practical payoff, and ensuring that respect for human rights is part and parcel of any technology-infused project. These discussions draw on a rich mix of science, philosophy of science, political theory, economics, sociology, network theory, ethics, and theories of justice and human rights. This book will be of great interest to students and scholars of environmental science, environmental decision-making, ecology, climate change, environmental philosophy, and the philosophy of science.
- 9 June 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 92-126
Disruption of science in a disrupted world
Of all the disruptions that the Anthropocene is thought to have wrought, few are more discussed or more lamented than the die-off of non-human life on earth. And few disruptions have engendered such missionary zeal on the part of scientists as this disruption did (and does) to come up with a science-based mandate for curbing it. The result is a now-massive, decades-long research program to “prove” that biodiversity is causally responsible for ecosystem functions and therefore (it is claimed) the services on which humankind depends. This thesis has been hailed as a new paradigm for ecology and an innovative basis for justifying conservation. However, its greatest disruption has been to science itself, as scientists blinded themselves to the glaring design and interpretative flaws that systematically undermine the credibility of their evidence. This chapter explains how so many highly trained scientists could have gotten so far off track for so long and so utterly convinced themselves of the soundness of “findings” that so lacked evidential warrant. It first recounts four norms-violating behaviors, which pervade this scientific community: foregrounding a narrowly conceived conservation mission ahead of scientific investigation, making sweepingly general claims that greatly transcend even the profoundly flawed evidence for them, promoting their claims via self-referring panegyrics, and expressing absolute certainty about them. The chapter then views this community of scientists as a social network with the five telling characteristics of being: tightly knit, very compact, epistemically isolated, homophilic, and led by a prominent few. The chapter then leverages social network theory in conjunction with principles of social psychology and sociology to explain how this community’s norms-violating behaviors could have led it to settle intransigently on unwarranted beliefs. It concludes by observing that the taking hostage of scientific judgment by non-scientific commitments may have broad social significance in a disrupted world.
- 9 June 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 92-126
Disruption of science in a disrupted world
Of all the disruptions that the Anthropocene is thought to have wrought, few are more discussed or more lamented than the die-off of non-human life on earth. And few disruptions have engendered such missionary zeal on the part of scientists as this disruption did (and does) to come up with a science-based mandate for curbing it. The result is a now-massive, decades-long research program to “prove” that biodiversity is causally responsible for ecosystem functions and therefore (it is claimed) the services on which humankind depends. This thesis has been hailed as a new paradigm for ecology and an innovative basis for justifying conservation. However, its greatest disruption has been to science itself, as scientists blinded themselves to the glaring design and interpretative flaws that systematically undermine the credibility of their evidence. This chapter explains how so many highly trained scientists could have gotten so far off track for so long and so utterly convinced themselves of the soundness of “findings” that so lacked evidential warrant. It first recounts four norms-violating behaviors, which pervade this scientific community: foregrounding a narrowly conceived conservation mission ahead of scientific investigation, making sweepingly general claims that greatly transcend even the profoundly flawed evidence for them, promoting their claims via self-referring panegyrics, and expressing absolute certainty about them. The chapter then views this community of scientists as a social network with the five telling characteristics of being: tightly knit, very compact, epistemically isolated, homophilic, and led by a prominent few. The chapter then leverages social network theory in conjunction with principles of social psychology and sociology to explain how this community’s norms-violating behaviors could have led it to settle intransigently on unwarranted beliefs. It concludes by observing that the taking hostage of scientific judgment by non-scientific commitments may have broad social significance in a disrupted world.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2023
- Published by University of Michigan Library in Philosophy, Theory, and Practice in Biology
- Vol. 15
Chasing Biodiversity Off the Scientific and Conservation Tracks
The idea of conserving biodiversity has become central to the very meaning of biological conservation-in the public imagination and for conservation organizations worldwide. Identification of conservation with biodiversity conservation owes extensively to the idea that warrant for biodiversity's conservation is anchored in the empirical thesis that biodiversity causally determines ecosystem functioning, and thereby, somehow, important ecosystem services. This idea has fueled an enormous research program dedicated to producing the requisite causal evidence. This essay first reviews the data that are supposed to constitute direct evidence for biodiversity's causal influence. It proceeds by answering a heretofore unasked, yet foundational, question for causal hypotheses: Do these data meet basic requirements for credibility as causal evidence? By virtue of mistakenly reading causal significance into (i) massive numbers of causally irrelevant data points, (ii) an equation that simply equates a stipulated definition to an algebraically equivalent expression, and (iii) correlations produced by arbitrary computations over previously collected data sets, these data fall well short of meeting these requirements. Mistakes also suffuse the notion that biodiversity's supposed causal influence gives reasons to conserve it. These mistakes are exposed when the conservation argument that was supposed to proceed from the premise of biodiversity's causal influence is clearly spelled out. Once made explicit, each step is seen to rely on a questionable assumption, invalid logic, or both. The essay concludes with implications for conservation, biodiversity research, and scientific inquiry more generally.
- 22 May 2023
- Published by University of Michigan Library in Philosophy, Theory, and Practice in Biology
- Vol. 15
Open AccessChasing Biodiversity Off the Scientific and Conservation Tracks
The idea of conserving biodiversity has become central to the very meaning of biological conservation-in the public imagination and for conservation organizations worldwide. Identification of conservation with biodiversity conservation owes extensively to the idea that warrant for biodiversity's conservation is anchored in the empirical thesis that biodiversity causally determines ecosystem functioning, and thereby, somehow, important ecosystem services. This idea has fueled an enormous research program dedicated to producing the requisite causal evidence. This essay first reviews the data that are supposed to constitute direct evidence for biodiversity's causal influence. It proceeds by answering a heretofore unasked, yet foundational, question for causal hypotheses: Do these data meet basic requirements for credibility as causal evidence? By virtue of mistakenly reading causal significance into (i) massive numbers of causally irrelevant data points, (ii) an equation that simply equates a stipulated definition to an algebraically equivalent expression, and (iii) correlations produced by arbitrary computations over previously collected data sets, these data fall well short of meeting these requirements. Mistakes also suffuse the notion that biodiversity's supposed causal influence gives reasons to conserve it. These mistakes are exposed when the conservation argument that was supposed to proceed from the premise of biodiversity's causal influence is clearly spelled out. Once made explicit, each step is seen to rely on a questionable assumption, invalid logic, or both. The essay concludes with implications for conservation, biodiversity research, and scientific inquiry more generally.
- 28 July 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in AMBIO
- Vol. 47 (6) , 737-738
Response to “Biodiversity’s option value: A comment on Maier (2018)” by Faith
- 28 July 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in AMBIO
- Vol. 47 (6) , 737-738
Response to “Biodiversity’s option value: A comment on Maier (2018)” by Faith
- 14 December 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in AMBIO
- Vol. 47 (4) , 477-492
Should biodiversity and nature have to earn their keep? What it really means to bring environmental goods into the marketplace
Pursuit of economic gain has sponsored much of our planet’s despoliation. Yet conservation increasingly operates as an economic sector that markets biodiversity, ecosystems, and nature as natural capital, service provider, or option value. This essay first elucidates what basic moral theory says about the principle that the goodness of biodiversity and nature is largely economic. It explains why economic valuations may be morally unimportant, inapt for environmental goods, and subversive of more important ideals. It also shows why neither econometric notions of option value nor Daniel Faith’s qualitative one credibly applies. The essay then turns to what an economic conception of goodness implies for conservation practice. It refers to two prominent conservation organizations, whose conservation principles match the market-based ones of the World Business Council on Sustainable Development’s. The environmental record of the latter organization’s practices according to these principles predicts what their adoption for conservation entails.
- 14 December 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in AMBIO
- Vol. 47 (4) , 477-492
Should biodiversity and nature have to earn their keep? What it really means to bring environmental goods into the marketplace
Pursuit of economic gain has sponsored much of our planet’s despoliation. Yet conservation increasingly operates as an economic sector that markets biodiversity, ecosystems, and nature as natural capital, service provider, or option value. This essay first elucidates what basic moral theory says about the principle that the goodness of biodiversity and nature is largely economic. It explains why economic valuations may be morally unimportant, inapt for environmental goods, and subversive of more important ideals. It also shows why neither econometric notions of option value nor Daniel Faith’s qualitative one credibly applies. The essay then turns to what an economic conception of goodness implies for conservation practice. It refers to two prominent conservation organizations, whose conservation principles match the market-based ones of the World Business Council on Sustainable Development’s. The environmental record of the latter organization’s practices according to these principles predicts what their adoption for conservation entails.
- 6 August 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics
- Vol. 29 (5) , 857-882
Assisted Migration in Normative and Scientific Context
- 6 August 2016
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics
- Vol. 29 (5) , 857-882
Assisted Migration in Normative and Scientific Context
- 1 January 2016
- Published by Philosophy Documentation Center in Environmental Philosophy
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-33
Taking Nature Seriously in the Anthropocene
- 1 January 2016
- Published by Philosophy Documentation Center in Environmental Philosophy
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-33
Taking Nature Seriously in the Anthropocene
- 26 November 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics
- Vol. 29 (2) , 327-347
The IPBES Conceptual Framework: An Unhelpful Start
- 26 November 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics
- Vol. 29 (2) , 327-347
The IPBES Conceptual Framework: An Unhelpful Start
- 1 January 2015
- Published by Philosophy Documentation Center in Environmental Philosophy
- Vol. 12 (1) , 99-119
Conservation as Picking up Trash in Nature
- 1 January 2015
- Published by Philosophy Documentation Center in Environmental Philosophy
- Vol. 12 (1) , 99-119
Conservation as Picking up Trash in Nature