Abstract
In June 2023, the German Federal Cartel Office decided that the refusal by the German national railway company Deutsche Bahn (DB) to provide non-discriminatory access to those real-time railway mobility data that are exclusively held by DB and are essential to provide multimodal mobility services, constitute an abuse of market power in relation to competing integrated (multimodal) mobility service providers. This article analyses and assesses the case against DB, and asks whether other policy instruments (than competition law) would be more suitable to achieve sufficient access to mobility data. It shows that the existing EU regulations for mandatory data sharing to foster multimodal mobility might not be sufficient to solve the complex competition problems in cases like the DB case. Therefore, we analyze data trustee solutions as new policy options for solving the access problems to railway mobility data. In a last step, we analyze policy options of how to integrate a neutral railway mobility data trustee into the sectoral regulation on access to the railway infrastructure (natural monopoly). This includes, in particular, the option to extend the scope of the sectoral regulation for non-discriminatory access also to railway mobility data, and the more far-reaching policy option to effectively separate railway infrastructure and railway transport service (ownership unbundling), and mandate the operator of the railway infrastructure to be a neutral public interest-oriented trustee for both physical railway infrastructure and railway mobility data.