WKWolfgang Kerber

Wolfgang Kerber

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Wolfgang Kerber has a total of 39 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Digital Decade: How the EU Shapes Digitalisation Research, Rita Gsenger and Marie-Therese Sekwenz (eds) (2025)

    by Wolfgang Kerber

    Review of: Digital Decade: How the EU Shapes Digitalisation Research , Rita Gsenger and Marie-Therese Sekwenz (eds) (2025) Baden-Baden: Nomos, 524 pp., ISBN 978-3-75601-741-6, h/bk, EUR 174.00

  • Open Access

    The Commission's Art. 5(2) DMA Meta Decision Between Data Protection Law and Competition Policy: A Missed Opportunity?

    by Wolfgang Kerber

    The application of Art. 5(2) DMA is difficult due to its objectives of achieving both more contestability and data protection regarding data combination of gatekeepers. This paper analyses from a law & economics perspective the Meta implementation decision (April 2025), in which the Commission rejects the binary "consent or pay" model of Meta and requires an additional free equivalent option without behavioural advertising ("third option"), as suggested in the innovative EDPB Opinion 08/2024. Economically, this additional third option can lead to far-reaching effects of reducing the "data price" of end users, to less data accumulation and less behavioural advertising. However, it is unclear whether this choice architecture is sufficient for achieving significant positive effects on contestability through inducing many end users to reject the familiar option with behavioural advertising. The analysis of the Meta decision shows that the Commission uses only data protection reasoning in its assessment of the "consent or pay" model of Meta, whereas the effects on contestability do not play any role. With this one-sided focus the Commission is in danger of reducing the role of Art. 5(2) DMA to a pure instrument of better enforcement of data protection law. It has missed the opportunity to develop an own approach for Art. 5(2) DMA with a better combination of stricter rules against the data combination and data power of gatekeepers for achieving more contestability and data protection. In the paper some ideas are discussed how such an approach can be developed. It would also allow Art. 5(2) DMA and the Commission to play an independent role in the interplay between competition policy and data protection law.


  • Open Access

    Decentralised Coordination Order, Market Regulation and Economics: The Perspective of Heike Schweitzer

    by Wolfgang Kerber, Philipp Hornung

    Heike Schweitzer, one of the most influential competition law scholars in Europe, in particular, with regard to the new challenges of the digital economy, passed away much too early in 2024. This paper, written by one of her coauthors and one of her Ph.D. students for the MaCCI law and economics conference 2025 in memoriam of Heike Schweitzer, analyses the methodological approach of her very innovative research with regard to competition law, data policy, and market regulation in the digital era. The paper shows that her research has deep roots in her vision of a market economy, which is based upon private autonomy, individual liberty, and competition under a framework of rules that ensure a well-functioning decentralised coordination order, influenced by Franz Böhm's concept of Privatrechtsgesellschaft. For the analysis of the need for market regulation and making policy proposals she applied in a very reflected way economic insights and methods, for example, the market failure theory and the error costs approach (with regard to the Art. 102 TFEU guidelines discussion). She also used these economic approaches for developing her very innovative and thought-provoking research about significant failures in the markets for personal data, leading to her critical position about the new phenomenon of "paying with data" instead of money in the digital economy.


  • Open Access

    The German Competition Case "Deutsche Bahn", Governance of Railway Mobility Data, and Data Trustee Solutions

    by Wolfgang Kerber, Daniel Gill

    In June 2023, the German Federal Cartel Office decided that the refusal by the German national railway company Deutsche Bahn (DB) to provide non-discriminatory access to those real-time railway mobility data that are exclusively held by DB and are essential to provide multimodal mobility services, constitute an abuse of market power in relation to competing integrated (multimodal) mobility service providers. This article analyses and assesses the case against DB, and asks whether other policy instruments (than competition law) would be more suitable to achieve sufficient access to mobility data. It shows that the existing EU regulations for mandatory data sharing to foster multimodal mobility might not be sufficient to solve the complex competition problems in cases like the DB case. Therefore, we analyze data trustee solutions as new policy options for solving the access problems to railway mobility data. In a last step, we analyze policy options of how to integrate a neutral railway mobility data trustee into the sectoral regulation on access to the railway infrastructure (natural monopoly). This includes, in particular, the option to extend the scope of the sectoral regulation for non-discriminatory access also to railway mobility data, and the more far-reaching policy option to effectively separate railway infrastructure and railway transport service (ownership unbundling), and mandate the operator of the railway infrastructure to be a neutral public interest-oriented trustee for both physical railway infrastructure and railway mobility data.

  • EU Data Act: Will new user access and sharing rights on IoT data help competition and innovation?

    by Wolfgang Kerber

    The recently enacted Data Act (DA) is an important part of the European Union (EU) data strategy, which intends to increase the sharing and use of data, based upon the economic rationale that data (like information) is non-rivalrous in use, that is the same data can be used by several or many firms. EU data policy has step-by-step developed policies for supporting voluntary data sharing but has recently also started to introduce more mandatory rules for opening data through more data access and data sharing. 1 The DA introduces with its provisions of Chapter II new mandatory data access and sharing rights for the users of IoT devices, leading to a broad institutional framework for the governance of data in the fast-expanding field of the ‘Internet of Things’. 2 Connected Internet of Things (IoT) devices, like connected cars, smart watches, smart home appliances, smart machines in industrial manufacturing, or agriculture, are spreading very fast and will generate huge amounts of data. This article will explain and assess, whether and to what extent the DA can help to solve the current IoT data governance problems, which are primarily caused by the often exclusive control over the IoT data by the manufacturers of IoT devices. The main focus of this article will be on the question whether the DA can have positive effects on competition and innovation through making more IoT data available.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Property rights theory, bundles of rights on IoT data, and the EU Data Act

    by Martina Eckardt, Wolfgang Kerber

    With the advance of smart IoT devices (Internet of Things) the amount of valuable data will increase dramatically. With its recently enacted Data Act (DA) the EU introduces new data access and sharing rights for the users of IoT devices. This article analyzes how the DA will change the bundle of rights on non-personal IoT data regarding who can control, access, use, share, and monetize this data. In a first step, we apply the property rights theory (esp. the approach of Barzel) for explaining the status quo of IoT data governance. Here the manufacturers can get through the technical design of their IoT devices exclusive de facto control over IoT data ("capture" of data). In a second step, we analyze how the DA changes this de facto bundle of rights in order to unlock more IoT data for innovation, competition, and empowerment of users. Since the DA is not very clear and partly contradictory, three different concepts for the design of this bundle of rights are analyzed and compared: A data holder-centric IP-like concept, a user-centric concept, and the concept of co-generated data. The article analyzes all three concepts from an economic perspective including relevant market failures regarding IoT data in B2B and B2C contexts. For achieving the objectives of the DA, especially regarding unlocking of data for innovation, bundles of rights should be chosen which reject notions of exclusivity and enable broad access and sharing of IoT data. The enacted Data Act, which still clings too much to the exclusivity of data and includes too many hurdles for data sharing, cannot be expected to contribute much to achieving these objectives.


  • Open Access

    Property Rights Theory, Bundles of Rights on IoT Data, and the Data Act

    by Martina Eckardt, Wolfgang Kerber

    With the advance of smart IoT devices (Internet of Things) the amount of valuable data will increase dramatically. For much of the thus generated non-personal data no legal rights exist. In its Data Act (DA) draft the EU Commission proposes new data access and sharing rights for the users of IoT devices. Based upon the economic property rights theory, this article analyzes how the DA would change the bundle of rights on non-personal IoT data regarding who can control, access, use, share, and monetize this data. In a first step, we apply the property rights theory (esp. the ap-proach of Barzel) for explaining the status quo of IoT data governance: Through the technical design of their IoT devices the manufacturers can get exclusive de facto control over IoT data, i.e. they can technologically capture the data, exclude others from accessing and using this data, and draw value from this data as if they have ex-clusive property rights on them. In a second step, we analyze how the DA would change this de facto bundle of rights in order to unlock more IoT data for innovation, competition, and empowerment of users. Since the DA proposal is not very clear and partly contradictory, three different concepts for the design of this bundle of rights are analyzed and compared: A data holder-centric IP-like concept, a user-centric concept, and the concept of co-generated data. For achieving the objectives of the DA, espe-cially regarding unlocking of data for innovation, bundles of rights should be chosen which reject notions of exclusivity and enable broad access and sharing of IoT data. The current DA proposal, which is dominated by the data holder-centric IP-like con-cept, will not achieve these objectives.


  • Open Access

    Ex-Post Analysis of Pharmaceutical Merger Cases in the EU and US: The Identification of the Relevant R&D Projects

    by Ute Laermann-Nguyen, Wolfgang Kerber

    In this ex-post analysis, we have used three large pharmaceutical merger cases to examine the correctness of the market definition carried out by the FTC and the European Commission with regard to innovation competition. In doing so, we selected three merger cases that were reviewed by both competition authorities between 2000 and 2015 with regard to their impact on innovation. We compared the authorities' approaches to identifying competing R&D projects with data from an independent database, which is the most comprehensive concerning pharmaceutical R&D projects. We found that the authorities' approaches have varied considerably in the past, and their performance in identifying relevant R&D projects has been mixed. Often, the competing projects were correctly identified (especially by the FTC). However, some mistakes were also made that may have led to partially wrong decisions by the European Commission. Overall, our investigation has shown that there are still many open questions regarding the appropriate method for identifying competing R&D projects and thus for market definition in relation to innovation competition.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Governance of IoT Data: Why the EU Data Act Will not Fulfill Its Objectives

    by Wolfgang Kerber

    The EU Data Act proposal (DA) seeks to introduce new rights for the users of internet of things (IoT) devices regarding access, use and sharing of the data generated through their use of these devices. This paper presents the results of a first analysis of the effectiveness of this ‘user rights’ mechanism from a ‘law and economics’ perspective. It concludes that the DA will not achieve its objectives of (a) empowering the users of IoT devices (especially the consumers), (b) unlocking large amounts of IoT data for innovation (for IoT-related services and across sectors), and (c) contributing to a fair sharing of the value from the generated IoT data. Although the DA correctly identifies the main problem arising from manufacturers’ technical design of IoT devices, which grants them exclusive de facto control over the generated IoT data, its proposals for solving it are not close to being sufficient: (1) The proposed user rights mechanism suffers from manifold serious problems which will make it weak and largely ineffective (insufficient scope of data; lacking technical interoperability; high transaction costs, especially through the need for a negotiated contract with FRAND conditions; unclarity regarding data markets). (2) Also, the option for users to gain more control over the use of the IoT data, which operates through the requirement that the data holders can only use the IoT data on the basis of a contract with the users, will not work due to unsolved serious market failure problems in B2C situations. Therefore, all the rights to use the IoT data will end up with the data holders (and leave the consumers with only these weak user rights). The main reason for this negative assessment of the DA is its overemphasis on the protection of the exclusive de facto control position of the data holders. However, it is very doubtful whether in the case of IoT devices, whose price can cover the costs of data generation, any general incentive problem for investing in data-generating IoT devices exists. Therefore, a far-reaching rebalancing in favor of easier and increased data sharing and user empowerment is necessary, especially for enabling more innovation in the data economy.


  • Hayek

    by Wolfgang Kerber