The Sounds of Desaturation: A Survey of Commercial Pulse Oximeter Sonifications
- 1 May 2016
- journal article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Anesthesia & Analgesia
- Vol. 122 (5) , 1395-1403
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The pulse oximeter has been a standard of care medical monitor for >25 years. Most manufacturers include a variable-pitch pulse tone in their pulse oximeters. Research has shown that the acoustic properties of variable-pitch tones are not standardized. In this study, we surveyed the properties of pulse tones from 21 pulse oximeters, consisting of 1 to 4 instruments of 11 different models and 8 brands. Our goals were to fully document the sounds over saturation values 0% to 100%, test whether tones become quieter at low saturation values, and create a public repository of pulse oximeter recordings for future use. METHODS: A convenience sample of commercial pulse oximeters in use at one hospital was studied. Audiovisual recordings of each pulse oximeter’s display and sounds were taken while it monitored a simulator starting at a saturation of 100% and slowly decreasing in 1% steps until the saturation reached 0%. Recorded pulse tones were analyzed for spectral frequency and total power. Audio files for each pulse oximeter containing 100 pulse tones, one at every saturation value, were created for inclusion in the repository. RESULTS: Recordings containing 509 to 1053 pulse tones were made from the 21 pulse oximeters. Fundamental frequencies at 100% saturation ranged from 479 to 921 Hz, and fundamental frequencies at 1% saturation ranged from 38 to 404 Hz. The pulse tones from all but one model pulse oximeter contained harmonics. Pulse tone step sizes were linear in 6 models and logarithmic in 6 models. Only 6 pulse oximeter models decreased the pulse tone pitch at every decrease in saturation; all others decreased the pitch at only select saturation thresholds. Five pulse oximeter models stopped decreasing pitch altogether once the saturation reached a certain lower threshold. Pulse tone power (perceived as loudness) changed with saturation level for all pulse oximeters, increasing above baseline as saturation decreased from 100% and decreasing to levels below baseline at low saturation values. CONCLUSIONS: Current pulse oximeters use different techniques to address the competing goals of (1) using pitch steps that are large enough to be readily perceived, and (2) conveying saturation values from 0 to 100 within a limited range of sound frequencies. From a clinical perspective, 2 techniques for increasing perceivability (increasing the frequency range and using ratio step sizes) have no drawback, but 2 techniques (not changing pitch at every saturation change and using a lower saturation cutoff) do have potential clinical drawbacks. On the basis of our findings, we have made suggestions for clinicians and manufacturers.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- A comparison of linear and logarithmic auditory tones in pulse oximetersApplied Ergonomics, 2015
- Advanced Auditory Displays and Head-Mounted Displays: Advantages and Disadvantages for Monitoring by the Distracted AnesthesiologistAnesthesia & Analgesia, 2008
- Audio spectrum and sound pressure levels vary between pulse oximetersCanadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie, 2006
- How Well Can Anaesthetists Discriminate Pulse Oximeter Tones?Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, 2005
- Advanced Patient Monitoring Displays: Tools for Continuous InformingAnesthesia & Analgesia, 2005
- The Sounds of SaturationJournal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing, 2004
- Continuous auditory monitoring—how much information do we register?British Journal of Anaesthesia, 1999
- Can people hear the pitch change on a variable-pitch pulse oximeter?Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing, 1992