What the Overpotential Does Not Tell You: Diagnosing Non-Comparability Across Hydrogen and Oxygen Evolution Benchmarking Metrics
Open Access
Abstract
Overpotential at 10 mA cm−2 (η10) is the default benchmark for hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER) electrocatalysts, but the number is rarely comparable across studies. This Perspective identifies six measurement and reporting stages, from synthesis reproducibility to the measurement platform itself, at which undisclosed methodological choices shift reported activity by tens to hundreds of millivolts without changing the catalyst. The benchmark’s device-context origin matches neither laboratory practice nor industrial current density, and its geometric normalization is sensitive to catalyst loading. Comparable artefacts recur in Tafel slope extraction, electrochemically active surface area, turnover frequency, and Faradaic efficiency, each traced to a specific undisclosed choice and a minimum reporting requirement. We test the framework on literature values checked against their primary sources. Of 11 NiFe oxyhydroxide reports, five give η10 on a matched basis (1 M KOH, room temperature), and these span 134 to 372 mV. For commercial Pt/C, the field’s own reference material, five matched-basis reports span 33 to 93 mV, and loading is stated directly in only two of the seven reports checked. We close with a concise reporting checklist organized by metric.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Research Foundation of South Africa (RA240201203480)
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Structural Changes of NiFe Layered Double Hydroxides During the Oxygen Evolution Reaction: A Diffraction and Total Scattering Operando StudySmall, 2025
- Enhanced oxygen evolution reaction in hierarchical NiFe/NiO electrocatalysts: Effects of electrodeposition condition on electrodeElectrochemistry Communications, 2024
- An outstanding NiFe/NF oxygen evolution reaction boosted by the hydroxyl oxidesElectrochimica Acta, 2023
- Non‐Kinetic Effects Convolute Activity and Tafel Analysis for the Alkaline Oxygen Evolution Reaction on NiFeOOH ElectrocatalystsAngewandte Chemie International Edition, 2023
- Electrodeposition of nickel–iron on stainless steel as an efficient electrocatalyst coating for the oxygen evolution reaction in alkaline conditionsJournal of Applied Electrochemistry, 2022
- Common Pitfalls of Reporting Electrocatalysts for Water SplittingChemical Research in Chinese Universities, 2020
- Highly active oxygen evolution reaction model electrode based on supported gas-phase NiFe clustersCatalysis Today, 2019
- The Comprehensive Understanding of as an Evaluation Parameter for Electrochemical Water SplittingSmall Methods, 2018
- A mini review of NiFe-based materials as highly active oxygen evolution reaction electrocatalystsNano Research, 2014
- Universality in Oxygen Evolution Electrocatalysis on Oxide SurfacesChemCatChem, 2011