Third-Party Source Switches: Objective Valuation or Fair Value Opinion Shopping?
Open Access
- 23 October 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Accounting Association in The Accounting Review
- Vol. 98 (7) , 405-433
Abstract
Fair value estimates from external third-party sources are generally considered more reliable than internal estimates based on managerial inputs. However, even externally sourced estimates are subject to managerial opportunism, because firms can switch from one external source to another. In the context of life insurance companies that mostly rely on external sources, we posit that such source switches could be driven by managerial incentive either to faithfully report fair values (objective valuation) or to inflate estimates to avoid OTTI (opinion shopping). Our results support both motives. In instances in which the two incentives yield conflicting predictions for source switching, we find the opinion-shopping motive dominates. We also find that switches that increase fair value estimates are associated with a reduced OTTI likelihood and magnitude, especially for high-impairment-risk securities. On balance, our evidence suggests that opportunism with respect to source switching can compromise the reliability of externally sourced fair value estimates. Data Availability: Data are available from the public sources cited in the text. JEL Classifications: G22; M41.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Monitoring Managers: Does It Matter?The Journal of Finance, 2013
- Missing the marks? Dispersion in corporate bond valuations across mutual fundsJournal of Financial Economics, 2011
- Corporate Bond Market Transaction Costs and TransparencyThe Journal of Finance, 2007
- Do insurers manipulate loss reserves to mask solvency problems?Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2004
- The behaviour of the maximum likelihood estimator of limited dependent variable models in the presence of fixed effectsThe Econometrics Journal, 2004
- External Monitoring of Property Appraisal Estimates and Information AsymmetryJournal of Accounting Research, 2002
- The Association between External Monitoring and Earnings Management in the Property‐Casualty Insurance IndustryJournal of Accounting Research, 2001
- Errors in Accounting Estimates and Their Relation to Audit Firm TypeJournal of Accounting Research, 1996
- Optimistic reporting in the property- casualty insurance industryJournal of Accounting and Economics, 1992
- Transforming the Dependent Variable in Regression ModelsInternational Economic Review, 1990