Abstract
“…a staged trial in which the verdict is known before the trial has begun”. W. Heisenberg Every homeopath at some point in his career faces negative or contrary opinions. Almost every year our profession is threatened by sceptics brandishing articles – with dubious methodologies to say the least – whose sole purpose is to declare ‘the end of homeopathy’. When we examine the posture of these sceptics a little more carefully, it is possible to recognise a pattern: when the object of study is homeopathy, they pose as defenders of the scientific method at the same time that they condemn it. I have selected three examples of this inconsistent and anti-scientific attitude. These authors span a spectrum from the most academic to the most popular. Our first example is taken from an article of which one of the authors is Dr Guyatt, one of the fathers of evidence-based medicine (EBM), i.e., making medical decisions based on the best information available. In this text, considerations are made about the philosophical assumptions of this approach.[1] Let's look at these two excerpts: ‘(...) what counts as “true” scientific knowledge is tentative and remains revisable as science progresses’.[1] ‘The emphasis of EBM on skepticism and uncertainty (...) agrees with the philosophical view that scientific knowledge is never complete and ultimately falible’.[1] The main characteristic of science is brilliantly described there: our knowledge is provisional. In the human activity called science, we deal with hypotheses and never with dogmas. The confrontation of several hypotheses that can result in a change of understanding is what we call the scientific method. The authors provide a didactic example: ‘... observations obtained in the clinical trial on hormone replacement therapy were accepted as accurate despite contradicting the prevailing theory of the day (resulting in the change of practice almost overnight)’.[1] That is, despite the initial theory suggesting a type of treatment, the tests showed that the theory could be wrong, a fact that led to a change in conduct to adapt to the new evidence. In other words: facts trump arguments. But see how, in the same article, the reasoning changes when it comes to homeopathy: ‘However, results from homeopathy trials that were obtained from RCTs [randomized controlled trials] were dismissed to a large extent due to the extreme skepticism regarding homeopathic theory’.[1] What?! In the case of hormone replacement, the best evidence has caused the medical approach to change overnight, even if it contradicts the theory. However, when it comes to homeopathy, the authors argue that, if the evidence contradicts the theory, we should continue clinging to the theory. That is, against the arguments, the facts do not matter. And we are not talking about just any evidence, but exactly those obtained by the type of test that in EBM is considered of high quality. The authors themselves confirm: ‘Evidence obtained in homeopathy RCTs consists of high-quality placebo-controlled trials in that both patients and physicians were “blinded” to intervention’.[1] So, what's the argument for snubbing high-quality tests? What is this powerful argument capable of making critics ignore the facts? In debates about homeopathy, the topic that is always placed in the dock – and without the right to be defended – is the ultra-dilution. ‘However, homeopathic drugs are prepared by serial dilutions of remedy, the result of which is that the drug is diluted to the point that there is little to no likelihood that a single molecule from the original solution is present in the final product. As a result, the homeopathic solution is not believed to adhere to contemporary chemical principles, thereby making any claim about its effects pharmacologically implausible’.[1] That is: what is valid for other fields of science is not valid for homeopathy. At this point in the text, the authors have already forgotten those important words with which they characterised scientific knowledge: revisable, uncertainty, never complete, fallible. It seems that in the case of ‘contemporary chemical principles’ the best adjectives to qualify them would then be: certain, absolute, complete, immutable. Our second example is taken from one of the greatest authors in epistemology: Michael Polanyi. This philosopher of science was responsible for some of the most important insights for understanding the structure of scientific knowledge. We read in his book called ‘Personal Knowledge’[2]: ‘Formal operations relying on one framework of interpretation cannot demonstrate a proposition to persons who rely on another framework. Its advocates may not even succeed in getting a hearing from these, since they must first teach them a new language, and no one can learn a new language unless he first trusts that it means something’.[2] Nothing seems to better describe the situation of a homeopath vis-a-vis sceptics than these words. Homeopathy presents a new language and critics are unwilling to learn it. Therefore, the doors are already closed at the beginning of the debate, for them homeopathy simply has no right to exist. Polanyi continues: ‘Proponents of a new system can convince their audience only by first winning their intellectual sympathy for a doctrine they have not yet grasped (...) Such an acceptance is a heuristic process, a self-modifying act, and to this extension a conversion (...) They think differently, speak different language, live in different world...’.[2] That is, in science, new discoveries provoke a rupture, not only with the previous way of thinking, but also with the language itself. Polanyi calls this rupture a conversion: we abandon a hitherto accepted interpretation and commit ourselves to another interpretive...
Keywords

This publication has 2 references indexed in Scilit: