Ruy Madsen
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Latest Publications
- 31 March 2023
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 36 (01) , 003-005
Against Arguments There Are No Facts—The Inconsistencies of Critics of Homeopathy
“…a staged trial in which the verdict is known before the trial has begun”. W. Heisenberg Every homeopath at some point in his career faces negative or contrary opinions. Almost every year our profession is threatened by sceptics brandishing articles – with dubious methodologies to say the least – whose sole purpose is to declare ‘the end of homeopathy’. When we examine the posture of these sceptics a little more carefully, it is possible to recognise a pattern: when the object of study is homeopathy, they pose as defenders of the scientific method at the same time that they condemn it. I have selected three examples of this inconsistent and anti-scientific attitude. These authors span a spectrum from the most academic to the most popular. Our first example is taken from an article of which one of the authors is Dr Guyatt, one of the fathers of evidence-based medicine (EBM), i.e., making medical decisions based on the best information available. In this text, considerations are made about the philosophical assumptions of this approach.[1] Let's look at these two excerpts: ‘(...) what counts as “true” scientific knowledge is tentative and remains revisable as science progresses’.[1] ‘The emphasis of EBM on skepticism and uncertainty (...) agrees with the philosophical view that scientific knowledge is never complete and ultimately falible’.[1] The main characteristic of science is brilliantly described there: our knowledge is provisional. In the human activity called science, we deal with hypotheses and never with dogmas. The confrontation of several hypotheses that can result in a change of understanding is what we call the scientific method. The authors provide a didactic example: ‘... observations obtained in the clinical trial on hormone replacement therapy were accepted as accurate despite contradicting the prevailing theory of the day (resulting in the change of practice almost overnight)’.[1] That is, despite the initial theory suggesting a type of treatment, the tests showed that the theory could be wrong, a fact that led to a change in conduct to adapt to the new evidence. In other words: facts trump arguments. But see how, in the same article, the reasoning changes when it comes to homeopathy: ‘However, results from homeopathy trials that were obtained from RCTs [randomized controlled trials] were dismissed to a large extent due to the extreme skepticism regarding homeopathic theory’.[1] What?! In the case of hormone replacement, the best evidence has caused the medical approach to change overnight, even if it contradicts the theory. However, when it comes to homeopathy, the authors argue that, if the evidence contradicts the theory, we should continue clinging to the theory. That is, against the arguments, the facts do not matter. And we are not talking about just any evidence, but exactly those obtained by the type of test that in EBM is considered of high quality. The authors themselves confirm: ‘Evidence obtained in homeopathy RCTs consists of high-quality placebo-controlled trials in that both patients and physicians were “blinded” to intervention’.[1] So, what's the argument for snubbing high-quality tests? What is this powerful argument capable of making critics ignore the facts? In debates about homeopathy, the topic that is always placed in the dock – and without the right to be defended – is the ultra-dilution. ‘However, homeopathic drugs are prepared by serial dilutions of remedy, the result of which is that the drug is diluted to the point that there is little to no likelihood that a single molecule from the original solution is present in the final product. As a result, the homeopathic solution is not believed to adhere to contemporary chemical principles, thereby making any claim about its effects pharmacologically implausible’.[1] That is: what is valid for other fields of science is not valid for homeopathy. At this point in the text, the authors have already forgotten those important words with which they characterised scientific knowledge: revisable, uncertainty, never complete, fallible. It seems that in the case of ‘contemporary chemical principles’ the best adjectives to qualify them would then be: certain, absolute, complete, immutable. Our second example is taken from one of the greatest authors in epistemology: Michael Polanyi. This philosopher of science was responsible for some of the most important insights for understanding the structure of scientific knowledge. We read in his book called ‘Personal Knowledge’[2]: ‘Formal operations relying on one framework of interpretation cannot demonstrate a proposition to persons who rely on another framework. Its advocates may not even succeed in getting a hearing from these, since they must first teach them a new language, and no one can learn a new language unless he first trusts that it means something’.[2] Nothing seems to better describe the situation of a homeopath vis-a-vis sceptics than these words. Homeopathy presents a new language and critics are unwilling to learn it. Therefore, the doors are already closed at the beginning of the debate, for them homeopathy simply has no right to exist. Polanyi continues: ‘Proponents of a new system can convince their audience only by first winning their intellectual sympathy for a doctrine they have not yet grasped (...) Such an acceptance is a heuristic process, a self-modifying act, and to this extension a conversion (...) They think differently, speak different language, live in different world...’.[2] That is, in science, new discoveries provoke a rupture, not only with the previous way of thinking, but also with the language itself. Polanyi calls this rupture a conversion: we abandon a hitherto accepted interpretation and commit ourselves to another interpretive...
- 31 March 2023
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 36 (01) , 003-005
Against Arguments There Are No Facts—The Inconsistencies of Critics of Homeopathy
“…a staged trial in which the verdict is known before the trial has begun”. W. Heisenberg Every homeopath at some point in his career faces negative or contrary opinions. Almost every year our profession is threatened by sceptics brandishing articles – with dubious methodologies to say the least – whose sole purpose is to declare ‘the end of homeopathy’. When we examine the posture of these sceptics a little more carefully, it is possible to recognise a pattern: when the object of study is homeopathy, they pose as defenders of the scientific method at the same time that they condemn it. I have selected three examples of this inconsistent and anti-scientific attitude. These authors span a spectrum from the most academic to the most popular. Our first example is taken from an article of which one of the authors is Dr Guyatt, one of the fathers of evidence-based medicine (EBM), i.e., making medical decisions based on the best information available. In this text, considerations are made about the philosophical assumptions of this approach.[1] Let's look at these two excerpts: ‘(...) what counts as “true” scientific knowledge is tentative and remains revisable as science progresses’.[1] ‘The emphasis of EBM on skepticism and uncertainty (...) agrees with the philosophical view that scientific knowledge is never complete and ultimately falible’.[1] The main characteristic of science is brilliantly described there: our knowledge is provisional. In the human activity called science, we deal with hypotheses and never with dogmas. The confrontation of several hypotheses that can result in a change of understanding is what we call the scientific method. The authors provide a didactic example: ‘... observations obtained in the clinical trial on hormone replacement therapy were accepted as accurate despite contradicting the prevailing theory of the day (resulting in the change of practice almost overnight)’.[1] That is, despite the initial theory suggesting a type of treatment, the tests showed that the theory could be wrong, a fact that led to a change in conduct to adapt to the new evidence. In other words: facts trump arguments. But see how, in the same article, the reasoning changes when it comes to homeopathy: ‘However, results from homeopathy trials that were obtained from RCTs [randomized controlled trials] were dismissed to a large extent due to the extreme skepticism regarding homeopathic theory’.[1] What?! In the case of hormone replacement, the best evidence has caused the medical approach to change overnight, even if it contradicts the theory. However, when it comes to homeopathy, the authors argue that, if the evidence contradicts the theory, we should continue clinging to the theory. That is, against the arguments, the facts do not matter. And we are not talking about just any evidence, but exactly those obtained by the type of test that in EBM is considered of high quality. The authors themselves confirm: ‘Evidence obtained in homeopathy RCTs consists of high-quality placebo-controlled trials in that both patients and physicians were “blinded” to intervention’.[1] So, what's the argument for snubbing high-quality tests? What is this powerful argument capable of making critics ignore the facts? In debates about homeopathy, the topic that is always placed in the dock – and without the right to be defended – is the ultra-dilution. ‘However, homeopathic drugs are prepared by serial dilutions of remedy, the result of which is that the drug is diluted to the point that there is little to no likelihood that a single molecule from the original solution is present in the final product. As a result, the homeopathic solution is not believed to adhere to contemporary chemical principles, thereby making any claim about its effects pharmacologically implausible’.[1] That is: what is valid for other fields of science is not valid for homeopathy. At this point in the text, the authors have already forgotten those important words with which they characterised scientific knowledge: revisable, uncertainty, never complete, fallible. It seems that in the case of ‘contemporary chemical principles’ the best adjectives to qualify them would then be: certain, absolute, complete, immutable. Our second example is taken from one of the greatest authors in epistemology: Michael Polanyi. This philosopher of science was responsible for some of the most important insights for understanding the structure of scientific knowledge. We read in his book called ‘Personal Knowledge’[2]: ‘Formal operations relying on one framework of interpretation cannot demonstrate a proposition to persons who rely on another framework. Its advocates may not even succeed in getting a hearing from these, since they must first teach them a new language, and no one can learn a new language unless he first trusts that it means something’.[2] Nothing seems to better describe the situation of a homeopath vis-a-vis sceptics than these words. Homeopathy presents a new language and critics are unwilling to learn it. Therefore, the doors are already closed at the beginning of the debate, for them homeopathy simply has no right to exist. Polanyi continues: ‘Proponents of a new system can convince their audience only by first winning their intellectual sympathy for a doctrine they have not yet grasped (...) Such an acceptance is a heuristic process, a self-modifying act, and to this extension a conversion (...) They think differently, speak different language, live in different world...’.[2] That is, in science, new discoveries provoke a rupture, not only with the previous way of thinking, but also with the language itself. Polanyi calls this rupture a conversion: we abandon a hitherto accepted interpretation and commit ourselves to another interpretive...
- 2 June 2020
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 33 (02) , 104-106
COVID and Classical Homeopathy
‘So discuss them no further, just observe and pass by’ Dante (Inferno, canto III) The different homeopathic schools can affirm that they all are based on the Hahnemannian principle of similarity. For this reason, totally different practices are classified under the same name. Kent warned that ‘to say that Homeopathy is based on the law of similars is only to delimit the base of a cone leaving its apex projected in space’.[1] There is much more in Homeopathy than the principle of similarity. That is why it was necessary to call Classical Homeopathy the tradition that maintained the spirit of the doctrine. As I pointed out in this Journal in an article of 2016, among the foundations of the Classical Homeopathy tradition, the principle of individualisation stands out.[2] In the search for a single medicine, the peculiarities of each individual case are of great importance. Each patient is seen by the classical homeopath as an unrepeatable changed mode of being. It is common place, but never enough to say that we treat the patient and not the disease. If we are facing two patients with the same pathological diagnosis, each one will probably receive a different homeopathic remedy, depending on the characteristic totality of their symptoms. And symptoms in Homeopathy are not just the signs of the pathology, but everything that characterises mentally and physically that specific individual. It is difficult for a conventional doctor (whom we usually call an allopath) to understand this homeopathic premise, because all his training leads him to look for what is common in several patients to classify them according to the same pathological diagnosis and institute the therapy that is based on that same diagnosis. In science, as in almost everything, to change the way you think is painful, it is almost a conversion process. For those recently converted from allopathy to Classical Homeopathy, the principle of individualisation is the key point, it is the biggest source of errors, the biggest cause of failure. When we lose sight of the need to individualise, we forget the patient and focus on pathology, we automatically direct drugs to disease names. Hahnemann warned that when the homeopath assesses the symptomatic totality of a clinical case, he is ‘indifferent whether anything similar ever existed before in the world or not, under any name whatever’.[3] For Stuart Close,[4] individualisation ‘has been the burden of the message of every great teacher’ of Homeopathy since Hahnemann. The importance of individualisation cannot be overemphasised. Each case is unique. This is the challenge that all of us homeopaths have to impose on us: to fight the temptation to see the patient as just another case among many that we have seen. As Kent confesses: ‘I have to fight that with every fresh case I come to’.[5] If individualisation is the key to success, what is the factor that makes it so difficult to put into practice? Professor Massimo Mangialavori[6] replies: ‘To be fair, in some urgent situations, classical homeopaths may not have the time to employ their usual careful, complex approach. There may be too many patients in a particular day to individualize treatment as well as one would like; there may be an epidemic’. I write this letter in 2020, a pandemic has been declared by the WHO and has been repeatedly disseminated by the media. The population freaks out, containment measures are taken, national borders are closed, quarantines are instituted. Faced with the chaos, we could think that as homeopaths we are facing a limit to our ‘usual careful, complex approach’, we will not be able to individualise, we will have to appeal to the Hahnemannian strategy of the epidemic genius, as often used in history with success in various epidemics—a specific medication that has the characteristics of the epidemic disease to be used at that time as treatment and prophylaxis. But the question I ask myself is: am I stumbling over cases to the point where I can't individualise them? Am I faced with an endless line of sick patients without time to evaluate them one by one? The answer, at least for me and in my country, is a big ‘no!’. The moment in Brazil is one of disinformation. The media broadcasts a scenario of panic 24 hours a day as if the coronavirus disease (COVID) was the only disease in the world. Each new death is reported exhaustively. They comment on national television the number of ventilators in the ICUs. They show scenes of open graves waiting for a large number of deaths. But when we turn off the TV and close the newspapers, the reality is different. Health services were prepared, hospitals were set up, all attention was directed to an explosion of cases that did not happen. What we see are empty hospitals in the majority of the cities and few medical appointments. Patients who must follow their treatments for other conditions cannot be treated, as they were forced to stay at home, frightened by the media and by some doctors, the clinics were closed and nothing is said about anything else: only the pandemic exists. The data[7] show us that the coronavirus is not more lethal than the common flu. From January to the day I write in mid-April 2020, the number of deaths from complications with the common flu (world data) is approximately 140,000, while the number for coronavirus is approximately 130,000. More than 600,000 people die every year in consequence of seasonal flu. Have these thousands of annual deaths ever been reported on TV and newspapers? It seems that everyone forgot that every year a part of the patients presents severe conditions after a viral infection; they forgot that some people really die every year due to complications of viral conditions. Every year we deal with mutations of the influenza virus that are far more lethal than the coronavirus. In other words, the present health...
- 2 June 2020
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 33 (02) , 104-106
COVID and Classical Homeopathy
‘So discuss them no further, just observe and pass by’ Dante (Inferno, canto III) The different homeopathic schools can affirm that they all are based on the Hahnemannian principle of similarity. For this reason, totally different practices are classified under the same name. Kent warned that ‘to say that Homeopathy is based on the law of similars is only to delimit the base of a cone leaving its apex projected in space’.[1] There is much more in Homeopathy than the principle of similarity. That is why it was necessary to call Classical Homeopathy the tradition that maintained the spirit of the doctrine. As I pointed out in this Journal in an article of 2016, among the foundations of the Classical Homeopathy tradition, the principle of individualisation stands out.[2] In the search for a single medicine, the peculiarities of each individual case are of great importance. Each patient is seen by the classical homeopath as an unrepeatable changed mode of being. It is common place, but never enough to say that we treat the patient and not the disease. If we are facing two patients with the same pathological diagnosis, each one will probably receive a different homeopathic remedy, depending on the characteristic totality of their symptoms. And symptoms in Homeopathy are not just the signs of the pathology, but everything that characterises mentally and physically that specific individual. It is difficult for a conventional doctor (whom we usually call an allopath) to understand this homeopathic premise, because all his training leads him to look for what is common in several patients to classify them according to the same pathological diagnosis and institute the therapy that is based on that same diagnosis. In science, as in almost everything, to change the way you think is painful, it is almost a conversion process. For those recently converted from allopathy to Classical Homeopathy, the principle of individualisation is the key point, it is the biggest source of errors, the biggest cause of failure. When we lose sight of the need to individualise, we forget the patient and focus on pathology, we automatically direct drugs to disease names. Hahnemann warned that when the homeopath assesses the symptomatic totality of a clinical case, he is ‘indifferent whether anything similar ever existed before in the world or not, under any name whatever’.[3] For Stuart Close,[4] individualisation ‘has been the burden of the message of every great teacher’ of Homeopathy since Hahnemann. The importance of individualisation cannot be overemphasised. Each case is unique. This is the challenge that all of us homeopaths have to impose on us: to fight the temptation to see the patient as just another case among many that we have seen. As Kent confesses: ‘I have to fight that with every fresh case I come to’.[5] If individualisation is the key to success, what is the factor that makes it so difficult to put into practice? Professor Massimo Mangialavori[6] replies: ‘To be fair, in some urgent situations, classical homeopaths may not have the time to employ their usual careful, complex approach. There may be too many patients in a particular day to individualize treatment as well as one would like; there may be an epidemic’. I write this letter in 2020, a pandemic has been declared by the WHO and has been repeatedly disseminated by the media. The population freaks out, containment measures are taken, national borders are closed, quarantines are instituted. Faced with the chaos, we could think that as homeopaths we are facing a limit to our ‘usual careful, complex approach’, we will not be able to individualise, we will have to appeal to the Hahnemannian strategy of the epidemic genius, as often used in history with success in various epidemics—a specific medication that has the characteristics of the epidemic disease to be used at that time as treatment and prophylaxis. But the question I ask myself is: am I stumbling over cases to the point where I can't individualise them? Am I faced with an endless line of sick patients without time to evaluate them one by one? The answer, at least for me and in my country, is a big ‘no!’. The moment in Brazil is one of disinformation. The media broadcasts a scenario of panic 24 hours a day as if the coronavirus disease (COVID) was the only disease in the world. Each new death is reported exhaustively. They comment on national television the number of ventilators in the ICUs. They show scenes of open graves waiting for a large number of deaths. But when we turn off the TV and close the newspapers, the reality is different. Health services were prepared, hospitals were set up, all attention was directed to an explosion of cases that did not happen. What we see are empty hospitals in the majority of the cities and few medical appointments. Patients who must follow their treatments for other conditions cannot be treated, as they were forced to stay at home, frightened by the media and by some doctors, the clinics were closed and nothing is said about anything else: only the pandemic exists. The data[7] show us that the coronavirus is not more lethal than the common flu. From January to the day I write in mid-April 2020, the number of deaths from complications with the common flu (world data) is approximately 140,000, while the number for coronavirus is approximately 130,000. More than 600,000 people die every year in consequence of seasonal flu. Have these thousands of annual deaths ever been reported on TV and newspapers? It seems that everyone forgot that every year a part of the patients presents severe conditions after a viral infection; they forgot that some people really die every year due to complications of viral conditions. Every year we deal with mutations of the influenza virus that are far more lethal than the coronavirus. In other words, the present health...
- 1 September 2019
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 32 (03) , 181-184
‘I Think I Was Born in the Wrong Place’: A Case of Ammonium muriaticum
This is the case of a woman with recurrent sinusitis. The remedy was selected according to the themes and classifications proposed by the contemporary authors of Classical Homeopathy: Mangialavori, Scholten and Sankaran. The result was a long-lasting physical and mental improvement.
- 1 September 2019
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 32 (03) , 181-184
‘I Think I Was Born in the Wrong Place’: A Case of Ammonium muriaticum
This is the case of a woman with recurrent sinusitis. The remedy was selected according to the themes and classifications proposed by the contemporary authors of Classical Homeopathy: Mangialavori, Scholten and Sankaran. The result was a long-lasting physical and mental improvement.
- 1 March 2019
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 32 (01) , 018-022
Characteristics of Contemporary Methodologies of Classic Homeopathy
In the early 21st century, the methodologies of Massimo Mangialavori, Rajan Sankaran and Jan Scholten stood in classic homeopathy. These authors criticise the traditional methods of case analysis and propose new instruments to the search for the most appropriate remedy. These contemporary methodologies present common points: the study of themes, classification in groups, interrelation of substance-remedy-patient and predictive character. These characteristics were already presented by other authors throughout the history of homeopathy, but they were only systematised as a practical instrument in the past decades.
- 1 March 2019
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 32 (01) , 018-022
Characteristics of Contemporary Methodologies of Classic Homeopathy
In the early 21st century, the methodologies of Massimo Mangialavori, Rajan Sankaran and Jan Scholten stood in classic homeopathy. These authors criticise the traditional methods of case analysis and propose new instruments to the search for the most appropriate remedy. These contemporary methodologies present common points: the study of themes, classification in groups, interrelation of substance-remedy-patient and predictive character. These characteristics were already presented by other authors throughout the history of homeopathy, but they were only systematised as a practical instrument in the past decades.
- 1 December 2018
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 31 (04) , 223-228
Ringworm: The New Psora
In Sankaran's miasmatic classification, the Psora—Hahnemann's fundamental miasm—is reduced to a few drugs. The similarities between the patterns of psora and ringworm suggest that they are the same miasm. This hypothesis is confirmed by the understanding of the alternating pattern of the remedies still considered psoric.
- 1 December 2018
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 31 (04) , 223-228
Ringworm: The New Psora
In Sankaran's miasmatic classification, the Psora—Hahnemann's fundamental miasm—is reduced to a few drugs. The similarities between the patterns of psora and ringworm suggest that they are the same miasm. This hypothesis is confirmed by the understanding of the alternating pattern of the remedies still considered psoric.
- 1 September 2018
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 31 (03) , 180-181
In Response to the Article ‘Homeopathy in the Context of a World in Crisis by Joerg Wichmann’
In the article ‘Homeopathy in the Context of a World in Crisis’ [Links 2018; 31(1):9–13], the author states that the world is going through a crisis and that the homeopath has a role to play, but which crisis does he refer to? He seems to give us some tips when he talks about the environment, the civilisation, the water or in a poem that speaks of losing plants, animals, stars, etc. It seems that this crisis is such an obvious fact for the author that he does not even need to explain it. The corruption and economic crisis provoked by socialist governments seems to be a bigger problem for the Brazilians than for the Germans. The crisis caused by the Syrian refugees seems to be a bigger problem for the Germans than for the Brazilians. That is, even when we speak of crisis, we have to characterise, individualise, as the classic homeopathy teaches us. In reminding us of our highest mission according to Hahnemann, the author emphasises that we must dedicate ‘all our resources and our full commitment’. But here comes the magic: restoring health suddenly becomes ‘restoring this world’, making it a place ‘where health can exist’. It seems that health in this ‘insane’ world is something impossible like lighting a ‘candle under water’. Now, if crises happen all the time and everywhere, then health never existed? The patients who were healed by Hahnemann 200 years ago and those healed today by thousands of homeopaths had no real health afterwards? May be that the author wants to remind us of a primordial state in a lost paradise. But from the biblical report that came to us from this idyllic age, it seems that there was no need for homeopaths, simply because there was no illness. The author criticises the traditional purpose of our treatment (‘we are looking only at the individual human being’) and states that our mission is to do more. Now, with a rhetorical blow, the homeopath becomes the divine representative who needs to ‘open the eyes’ of the world so that everyone understands what true health is. But how could the homeopath teach what the ideal health is if, in the author's view, that health never really happened, if it is impossible in this ‘insane world’? He claims that we know only theoretically that there is no health of the part when the whole is sick. Did the homeopaths in 200 years just repeat a theory? Have we never witnessed this truth? I see this theory being confirmed day by day in homeopathic practice, so I really know that the disease is indeed an ‘altered state’ as Hahnemann said and that when we cure that state the part also heals. This is health, and we can see it in reality. This healing and health occurs even in this ‘insane world in crisis’. The author questions how a ‘permanent restoration of health’ is possible if we have to send the patient back to the world that made him ill. For a few seconds, I thought we would have to send our patients to Mars, but then the author explains that we are called to a great task in this very world: to be part of the community of those who remove obstacles to healing and restore the health of the whole world. I, who already found it difficult to choose between 7,000 drugs, one who is as similar as possible to the altered state of each patient, was informed by the author that this is not enough. I'm not fulfilling my mission. Organon has just been rewritten and our supreme mission now is to heal the world. And I, who thought that the world was made of individuals, people of flesh and blood, was informed that the world is an abstract entity, insane and in crisis. I had learned from the great authors of Homeopathy and witnessed in my daily practice that what makes a human sick is not the same thing that sickens the other. One is sensitive to relationship issues, while the other is sensitive to financial issues. One gets sick from the competition that he sees everywhere and the other from extreme sensitivity to big world problems. I thought that in helping these people heal their altered state, that is, balancing their vital energy, I was helping them to live the present in freedom and allowing them to make their own choices including how to maintain their own health state. In this article, all our efforts as homeopaths were considered less noble than the work of those who want to change the world. Noble activities according to the author are those that aim something greater than just the healing of individuals. But the problem is that all the great activities that he suggests have to do with the healing of individuals. What do ‘Homeopaths without borders’ do besides treating individuals? What was Jeremy Sherr doing in Africa but healing individuals? Are they treating an abstract entity called ‘the world in crisis’ or real people with real individual sufferings? African patients are as real as the patients in the offices of those homeopathic colleagues who work from morning till night and who have little time to take care of themselves and their families. Why do good examples of homeopathic activity come only from Africa or from places of extreme poverty and not from our own practice? The task is to devote ‘all resources and our full commitment’ to the one supreme mission to heal our neighbour, isn't it? So why did our neighbour in Africa become closer than the sick person who lives in my hometown and sends e-mails on Sunday evenings? Ideas like those in this article seem beautiful, they convey a commendable concern, but are far from reality and are dangerous as so many historical examples have shown us. We must never forget that the best ideas to improve the world have also stimulated the greatest dictators. If we want to improve the society in which we live, we must first of all improve ourselves. As the psychologist Jordan Peterson teaches us, one of...
- 1 September 2018
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 31 (03) , 180-181
In Response to the Article ‘Homeopathy in the Context of a World in Crisis by Joerg Wichmann’
In the article ‘Homeopathy in the Context of a World in Crisis’ [Links 2018; 31(1):9–13], the author states that the world is going through a crisis and that the homeopath has a role to play, but which crisis does he refer to? He seems to give us some tips when he talks about the environment, the civilisation, the water or in a poem that speaks of losing plants, animals, stars, etc. It seems that this crisis is such an obvious fact for the author that he does not even need to explain it. The corruption and economic crisis provoked by socialist governments seems to be a bigger problem for the Brazilians than for the Germans. The crisis caused by the Syrian refugees seems to be a bigger problem for the Germans than for the Brazilians. That is, even when we speak of crisis, we have to characterise, individualise, as the classic homeopathy teaches us. In reminding us of our highest mission according to Hahnemann, the author emphasises that we must dedicate ‘all our resources and our full commitment’. But here comes the magic: restoring health suddenly becomes ‘restoring this world’, making it a place ‘where health can exist’. It seems that health in this ‘insane’ world is something impossible like lighting a ‘candle under water’. Now, if crises happen all the time and everywhere, then health never existed? The patients who were healed by Hahnemann 200 years ago and those healed today by thousands of homeopaths had no real health afterwards? May be that the author wants to remind us of a primordial state in a lost paradise. But from the biblical report that came to us from this idyllic age, it seems that there was no need for homeopaths, simply because there was no illness. The author criticises the traditional purpose of our treatment (‘we are looking only at the individual human being’) and states that our mission is to do more. Now, with a rhetorical blow, the homeopath becomes the divine representative who needs to ‘open the eyes’ of the world so that everyone understands what true health is. But how could the homeopath teach what the ideal health is if, in the author's view, that health never really happened, if it is impossible in this ‘insane world’? He claims that we know only theoretically that there is no health of the part when the whole is sick. Did the homeopaths in 200 years just repeat a theory? Have we never witnessed this truth? I see this theory being confirmed day by day in homeopathic practice, so I really know that the disease is indeed an ‘altered state’ as Hahnemann said and that when we cure that state the part also heals. This is health, and we can see it in reality. This healing and health occurs even in this ‘insane world in crisis’. The author questions how a ‘permanent restoration of health’ is possible if we have to send the patient back to the world that made him ill. For a few seconds, I thought we would have to send our patients to Mars, but then the author explains that we are called to a great task in this very world: to be part of the community of those who remove obstacles to healing and restore the health of the whole world. I, who already found it difficult to choose between 7,000 drugs, one who is as similar as possible to the altered state of each patient, was informed by the author that this is not enough. I'm not fulfilling my mission. Organon has just been rewritten and our supreme mission now is to heal the world. And I, who thought that the world was made of individuals, people of flesh and blood, was informed that the world is an abstract entity, insane and in crisis. I had learned from the great authors of Homeopathy and witnessed in my daily practice that what makes a human sick is not the same thing that sickens the other. One is sensitive to relationship issues, while the other is sensitive to financial issues. One gets sick from the competition that he sees everywhere and the other from extreme sensitivity to big world problems. I thought that in helping these people heal their altered state, that is, balancing their vital energy, I was helping them to live the present in freedom and allowing them to make their own choices including how to maintain their own health state. In this article, all our efforts as homeopaths were considered less noble than the work of those who want to change the world. Noble activities according to the author are those that aim something greater than just the healing of individuals. But the problem is that all the great activities that he suggests have to do with the healing of individuals. What do ‘Homeopaths without borders’ do besides treating individuals? What was Jeremy Sherr doing in Africa but healing individuals? Are they treating an abstract entity called ‘the world in crisis’ or real people with real individual sufferings? African patients are as real as the patients in the offices of those homeopathic colleagues who work from morning till night and who have little time to take care of themselves and their families. Why do good examples of homeopathic activity come only from Africa or from places of extreme poverty and not from our own practice? The task is to devote ‘all resources and our full commitment’ to the one supreme mission to heal our neighbour, isn't it? So why did our neighbour in Africa become closer than the sick person who lives in my hometown and sends e-mails on Sunday evenings? Ideas like those in this article seem beautiful, they convey a commendable concern, but are far from reality and are dangerous as so many historical examples have shown us. We must never forget that the best ideas to improve the world have also stimulated the greatest dictators. If we want to improve the society in which we live, we must first of all improve ourselves. As the psychologist Jordan Peterson teaches us, one of...
- 30 March 2018
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 31 (01) , 083
Dog, Yogi, Banyan Tree
Veritas filia temporis (Truth is the daughter of time) It was St. Augustine who initiated the tradition of autobiographies. Much more than telling the story of a lifetime, the aim is to make a confession. The story of a soul that presents itself fully and honestly before God. ‘Dog, Yogi, Banyan Tree’ by Rajan Sankaran is a confession. A man with high goals, thirst for knowledge and therefore open to knowledge, wherever it comes from. A man who early in life learned that the secret to seeing further is by standing on the shoulders of giants. Sankaran reveals to us, one by one, his guides, his role models, his examples, men of high moral and intellectual stature, who contributed to the timid boy, hidden under the shadow of an admirable father, to become one of the greatest names in the history of homeopathy. The short chapters of this book, like small poems in prose, reveal a human being with the strength, steadiness and greatness of an elephant. In the words of the Indian poet Kabir: ‘the elephant walks at its own pace, not bothered about the dogs that bark’. Today, the dogs that bark along the straight path are invited to recognise the invaluable contributions of Sankaran. Contributions that stand the test of time and have done immense good to the profession. Contrary to what critics say, the new methods of the great contemporary authors retained all Hahnemannian foundations. We do not witness a revolution, but a reform. In epistemological language: the hard core of classical homeopathy (vitalism, proving, similitude, totality, individualisation, single medicine, minimal dose) has been preserved and Sankaran has added many useful tools to the defense belt (auxiliary theories). History shows us that there is no such thing as collective discoveries; the subject of knowledge is the individual. The history of homeopathy could not be different. The real engines that make the profession move forward are the forces of individual consciousness, in search of truth, above any other authority. The recognition as being part of a tradition—a lineage of giants—forces us to conserve and, on the other hand, to explore. We should not go down, but we can always add. How many of Hahnemann's disciples did not feel the reborn of the flame of the true art of healing when faced with the so-called method of sensation? How many colleagues who had given up or who were about to give up saw this lighthouse that Sankaran lit with his new approaches and navigated back to the port of classical homeopathy? How many homeopaths did not find themselves full of courage trying to imitate this master in their case-taking and analysis? How many patients around the world were not benefited by having their suitable homeopathic medicines elucidated by the new methods of this young Indian who wanted to be the best in the world? Sankaran confesses his ambitions, his needs, his contradictions. In confessing the anguish generated by the conflict between selfishness and altruism, he shows with his own life the tension between these forces and, finally, recognises the importance of their balance. He has pursued his own interests as a free individual, and we homeopaths and our patients have gained a lot from this. It is a living proof of the classic idea of Adam Smith: ‘It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest…’. As Hahnemann taught, the doctor's only mission is to heal. So, doctor Sankaran after so many cures, books and contributions seems to want to achieve an even higher cure with this work. He wants to take us, with or without simillimum, to the highest purpose of our existence. Knowing the sensibilities and weaknesses of the homeopaths of the four corners of the world, he discovered that he could do much more than teach. By sharing his experiences he contributes to healing the sick homeopathic community. This book is the testimony of the journey of a homeopath, an invitation to confess our ambitions, our interests, to rethink our journey and, most of all, the honesty and integrity with which we adhere to the path of truth.
- 30 March 2018
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Homœopathic Links
- Vol. 31 (01) , 083
Dog, Yogi, Banyan Tree
Veritas filia temporis (Truth is the daughter of time) It was St. Augustine who initiated the tradition of autobiographies. Much more than telling the story of a lifetime, the aim is to make a confession. The story of a soul that presents itself fully and honestly before God. ‘Dog, Yogi, Banyan Tree’ by Rajan Sankaran is a confession. A man with high goals, thirst for knowledge and therefore open to knowledge, wherever it comes from. A man who early in life learned that the secret to seeing further is by standing on the shoulders of giants. Sankaran reveals to us, one by one, his guides, his role models, his examples, men of high moral and intellectual stature, who contributed to the timid boy, hidden under the shadow of an admirable father, to become one of the greatest names in the history of homeopathy. The short chapters of this book, like small poems in prose, reveal a human being with the strength, steadiness and greatness of an elephant. In the words of the Indian poet Kabir: ‘the elephant walks at its own pace, not bothered about the dogs that bark’. Today, the dogs that bark along the straight path are invited to recognise the invaluable contributions of Sankaran. Contributions that stand the test of time and have done immense good to the profession. Contrary to what critics say, the new methods of the great contemporary authors retained all Hahnemannian foundations. We do not witness a revolution, but a reform. In epistemological language: the hard core of classical homeopathy (vitalism, proving, similitude, totality, individualisation, single medicine, minimal dose) has been preserved and Sankaran has added many useful tools to the defense belt (auxiliary theories). History shows us that there is no such thing as collective discoveries; the subject of knowledge is the individual. The history of homeopathy could not be different. The real engines that make the profession move forward are the forces of individual consciousness, in search of truth, above any other authority. The recognition as being part of a tradition—a lineage of giants—forces us to conserve and, on the other hand, to explore. We should not go down, but we can always add. How many of Hahnemann's disciples did not feel the reborn of the flame of the true art of healing when faced with the so-called method of sensation? How many colleagues who had given up or who were about to give up saw this lighthouse that Sankaran lit with his new approaches and navigated back to the port of classical homeopathy? How many homeopaths did not find themselves full of courage trying to imitate this master in their case-taking and analysis? How many patients around the world were not benefited by having their suitable homeopathic medicines elucidated by the new methods of this young Indian who wanted to be the best in the world? Sankaran confesses his ambitions, his needs, his contradictions. In confessing the anguish generated by the conflict between selfishness and altruism, he shows with his own life the tension between these forces and, finally, recognises the importance of their balance. He has pursued his own interests as a free individual, and we homeopaths and our patients have gained a lot from this. It is a living proof of the classic idea of Adam Smith: ‘It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest…’. As Hahnemann taught, the doctor's only mission is to heal. So, doctor Sankaran after so many cures, books and contributions seems to want to achieve an even higher cure with this work. He wants to take us, with or without simillimum, to the highest purpose of our existence. Knowing the sensibilities and weaknesses of the homeopaths of the four corners of the world, he discovered that he could do much more than teach. By sharing his experiences he contributes to healing the sick homeopathic community. This book is the testimony of the journey of a homeopath, an invitation to confess our ambitions, our interests, to rethink our journey and, most of all, the honesty and integrity with which we adhere to the path of truth.