Pedestal penalty factors for ELM-free regimes in DIII-D and extension to fusion pilot plant design
Open Access
- 1 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 68 (10) , 105048
Abstract
Though the EPED model, which provides a first-principles-based predictive capability for the pedestal height and width in H-mode tokamak plasmas, has been validated extensively in type-I edge-localized mode (ELM) regimes, significant uncertainties remain in predicting the height of the pressure pedestal in fusion pilot plants that must deploy ELM mitigation or suppression techniques. In this work, we compare the EPED1 NN surrogate to measurements from a broad dataset on the DIII-D tokamak, spanning ELMy, Small-ELM, QH-mode, Wide-Pedestal QH-mode, resonant magnetic perturbation-suppressed, I-mode, EDA H-mode, QCE and ELM-free NT scenarios. Using a robust Bayesian profile-fitting framework, we find that the measured pedestal pressure is systematically reduced relative to the EPED prediction in nearly all regimes, with regime-median pedestal pressures ranging from ∼ 93% of the predicted value in H-mode like regimes to below 40% in scenarios in which the edge region is governed by other transport mechanisms. We show that this deficit—termed a ‘pedestal penalty’ – is not a fixed per-regime offset and that some scenarios recover toward the EPED prediction at high normalized pressure ( β N ) and low pedestal collisionality ( ν e , ped ∗ ). While a simple scaling for the pedestal penalty can help illustrate model uncertainties on the DIII-D database, it misses key scenario-specific physics and should not be taken as a substitute for the development of predictive pedestal models for ELM-free FPPs. Uncertainties in FPP performance associated with a reduction of the pedestal height relative to EPED are quantified using the FUSE code, which shows that the achievable fusion power on ITER may be reduced by a factor of two if the pedestal is limited to 60% of the EPED prediction, a value well within the uncertainties observed on DIII-D. Further implications for FPP design are discussed, including the need for regime-dependent pedestal models that do not rely on a degraded EPED variant.Keywords
Funding Information
- Next Step Fusion Inc
- U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science (DE-FC02-04ER54698)
This publication has 130 references indexed in Scilit:
- The separatrix electron density in JET, ASDEX upgrade and alcator C-Mod H-mode plasmas: A common evaluation procedure and correlation with engineering parametersNuclear Materials and Energy, 2025
- Prospects of core–edge integrated no-ELM and small-ELM scenarios for future fusion devicesNuclear Materials and Energy, 2022
- The EU DEMO staged design approach in the Pre-Concept Design PhaseFusion Engineering and Design, 2021
- Interpretative SOL modeling throughout multiple ELM cycles in DIII-DNuclear Materials and Energy, 2021
- CAKE: Consistent Automatic Kinetic Equilibrium reconstructionFusion Engineering and Design, 2021
- Predictions of core plasma performance for the SPARC tokamakJournal of Plasma Physics, 2020
- Projections of H-mode access and edge pedestal in the SPARC tokamakJournal of Plasma Physics, 2020
- Uncertainties in power plant design point evaluationsFusion Engineering and Design, 2017
- ELM divertor peak energy fluence scaling to ITER with data from JET, MAST and ASDEX upgradeNuclear Materials and Energy, 2017
- ELM mitigation techniquesJournal of Nuclear Materials, 2013