Can Empirical Catch Allocation Strategies Based on Single‐Region Stock Assessments Provide Adequate Advice for Managing Spatially Structured Fish Populations?
Open Access
- 18 November 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
Abstract
Spatial structure and movement are common features of marine fish populations, yet many fisheries management systems continue to rely on single‐region stock assessments. When stock‐level catch advice is generated at a broader spatial scale than management implementation, empirical catch allocation strategies provide a way to distribute harvest among regions and fleets. However, the performance of spatial catch allocation approaches remains poorly understood in terms of their ability to achieve robust management outcomes, especially when confronted with uncertainty in underlying population structure, movement and recruitment dynamics. Using a closed‐loop management strategy evaluation (MSE) conditioned on a demersal fish population (western Atlantic black sea bass, Centropristis striata ), we compared uniform, catch‐based, survey‐based, and catch‐survey hybrid catch allocation strategies across operating model scenarios that varied in population structure, movement directionality and magnitude, and recruitment dynamics. Across scenarios, catch allocation strategy generally affected regional outcomes more strongly than system‐level outcomes, redistributing catch, biomass, interannual variability in catch and depletion risk among regions. Differences among strategies were modest under bidirectional movement and recruitment varying around regional means, but stronger regional tradeoffs emerged when movement was unidirectional or recruitment declined in one population component. Uniform and catch‐based strategies generally produced steadier catches, whereas survey‐based strategies were more responsive to changes in regional biomass distribution but increased interannual variability in catch. No single strategy consistently outperformed others across metrics or spatial scales. Empirical catch allocation can provide a useful bridge between spatially aggregated assessment advice and spatial management, but its performance is conditional on underlying spatial processes.Funding Information
- Northeast Fisheries Science Center
- Alaska Fisheries Science Center
- Northwest Fisheries Science Center
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Equilibrium reference point calculations for the next generation of spatial assessmentsFisheries Research, 2021
- The Woods Hole Assessment Model (WHAM): A general state-space assessment framework that incorporates time- and age-varying processes via random effects and links to environmental covariatesFisheries Research, 2021
- Defining spatial structure for fishery stock assessmentFisheries Research, 2020
- Overcoming challenges of harvest quota allocation in spatially structured populationsFisheries Research, 2019
- "So, where do you come from?" The impact of assumed spatial population structure on estimates of recruitmentFisheries Research, 2019
- Spatial stock assessment methods: A viewpoint on current issues and assumptionsFisheries Research, 2019
- Evaluating the conservation risks of aggregate harvest management in a spatially-structured herring fisheryFisheries Research, 2015
- Fishery Management Strategies for Addressing Complex Spatial Structure in Marine Fish Stocks2014
- Zonal attachment of fish stocks and management cooperationFisheries Research, 2013
- Reconciling stock assessment and management scales under conditions of spatially varying catch historiesFisheries Research, 2011