Aaron M. Berger
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Aaron M. Berger has a total of 131 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Daniel R. Goethel
Auke Bay Lab, Alaska Fisheries Science Center National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Juneau Alaska USA
10 shared publications - Brian J. Langseth
Northwest Fisheries Science Center, NMFS–NOAA Seattle Washington USA
6 shared publications - Jonathan J. Deroba
Northeast Fisheries Science Center, NMFS–NOAA Woods Hole Massachusetts USA
4 shared publications - Patrick D. Lynch
Assessment and Monitoring Division, Office of Science & Technology, National Marine Fisheries Service, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration , Silver Spring, MD 20910
4 shared publications Amy M. Schueller
Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Beaufort Laboratory, NMFS–NOAA Beaufort North Carolina USA
3 shared publications- Francisco Izquierdo
Institut de Ciències del Mar Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (ICM‐CSIC) Barcelona Spain
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
Can Empirical Catch Allocation Strategies Based on Single‐Region Stock Assessments Provide Adequate Advice for Managing Spatially Structured Fish Populations?
Spatial structure and movement are common features of marine fish populations, yet many fisheries management systems continue to rely on single‐region stock assessments. When stock‐level catch advice is generated at a broader spatial scale than management implementation, empirical catch allocation strategies provide a way to distribute harvest among regions and fleets. However, the performance of spatial catch allocation approaches remains poorly understood in terms of their ability to achieve robust management outcomes, especially when confronted with uncertainty in underlying population structure, movement and recruitment dynamics. Using a closed‐loop management strategy evaluation (MSE) conditioned on a demersal fish population (western Atlantic black sea bass, Centropristis striata ), we compared uniform, catch‐based, survey‐based, and catch‐survey hybrid catch allocation strategies across operating model scenarios that varied in population structure, movement directionality and magnitude, and recruitment dynamics. Across scenarios, catch allocation strategy generally affected regional outcomes more strongly than system‐level outcomes, redistributing catch, biomass, interannual variability in catch and depletion risk among regions. Differences among strategies were modest under bidirectional movement and recruitment varying around regional means, but stronger regional tradeoffs emerged when movement was unidirectional or recruitment declined in one population component. Uniform and catch‐based strategies generally produced steadier catches, whereas survey‐based strategies were more responsive to changes in regional biomass distribution but increased interannual variability in catch. No single strategy consistently outperformed others across metrics or spatial scales. Empirical catch allocation can provide a useful bridge between spatially aggregated assessment advice and spatial management, but its performance is conditional on underlying spatial processes.
- 18 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
Open AccessCan Empirical Catch Allocation Strategies Based on Single‐Region Stock Assessments Provide Adequate Advice for Managing Spatially Structured Fish Populations?
Spatial structure and movement are common features of marine fish populations, yet many fisheries management systems continue to rely on single‐region stock assessments. When stock‐level catch advice is generated at a broader spatial scale than management implementation, empirical catch allocation strategies provide a way to distribute harvest among regions and fleets. However, the performance of spatial catch allocation approaches remains poorly understood in terms of their ability to achieve robust management outcomes, especially when confronted with uncertainty in underlying population structure, movement and recruitment dynamics. Using a closed‐loop management strategy evaluation (MSE) conditioned on a demersal fish population (western Atlantic black sea bass, Centropristis striata ), we compared uniform, catch‐based, survey‐based, and catch‐survey hybrid catch allocation strategies across operating model scenarios that varied in population structure, movement directionality and magnitude, and recruitment dynamics. Across scenarios, catch allocation strategy generally affected regional outcomes more strongly than system‐level outcomes, redistributing catch, biomass, interannual variability in catch and depletion risk among regions. Differences among strategies were modest under bidirectional movement and recruitment varying around regional means, but stronger regional tradeoffs emerged when movement was unidirectional or recruitment declined in one population component. Uniform and catch‐based strategies generally produced steadier catches, whereas survey‐based strategies were more responsive to changes in regional biomass distribution but increased interannual variability in catch. No single strategy consistently outperformed others across metrics or spatial scales. Empirical catch allocation can provide a useful bridge between spatially aggregated assessment advice and spatial management, but its performance is conditional on underlying spatial processes.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (10)
Incorporating environmental drivers and productivity changes into management strategy evaluation
Uncertainty in the effects of environmental changes on stock productivity remains a central problem and research priority for fisheries management. Management strategy evaluation (MSE) is increasingly advocated and used to simulation-test harvest strategies against environmental effects on productivity; however, the complexity of the data, models, and decisions entailed remain significant challenges for developers and practitioners. Moreover, practical guidance for conditioning and projecting environment–productivity relationships within MSE is still sparse. Based on the experiences of a diverse group of modelling experts, a generic workflow is devised and presented for developing and subsequently using environment–productivity relationships within single-species, nonspatial operating models (OMs) in MSE. In the first part, key data types, modelling objectives, and approaches for estimating and validating these relationships are described. Importantly, environment–productivity relationships should be based on clear hypotheses (potentially with stakeholder input), have covariates that match temporal and spatial scale of productivity processes, and have unexplained variability (i.e. process error) carefully scrutinized for patterns (e.g. nonstationarity) and projected accordingly. The second part of the paper identifies and describes methods for projecting environmental effects on productivity using climate models and without (i.e. altering productivity dynamics directly). Key tactical considerations are presented for designing OMs (e.g. include an OM with no climate forcing to benchmark results from OMs with forcing, devise edge cases for robustness) and evaluating management performance (e.g. define appropriate projection periods, consider dynamic reference points to calculate metrics). Despite the common use of single-species OMs, it is important to consider multispecies interactions, and fine-scale population and fishery dynamics, to better understand potential environmental effects on a target stock’s productivity. In summarizing key decision points and range of methods applied to date, this work serves to support informed choices and shared vocabulary for developing and conducting these MSEs, rather than a prescriptive checklist.
- 1 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (10)
Open AccessIncorporating environmental drivers and productivity changes into management strategy evaluation
Uncertainty in the effects of environmental changes on stock productivity remains a central problem and research priority for fisheries management. Management strategy evaluation (MSE) is increasingly advocated and used to simulation-test harvest strategies against environmental effects on productivity; however, the complexity of the data, models, and decisions entailed remain significant challenges for developers and practitioners. Moreover, practical guidance for conditioning and projecting environment–productivity relationships within MSE is still sparse. Based on the experiences of a diverse group of modelling experts, a generic workflow is devised and presented for developing and subsequently using environment–productivity relationships within single-species, nonspatial operating models (OMs) in MSE. In the first part, key data types, modelling objectives, and approaches for estimating and validating these relationships are described. Importantly, environment–productivity relationships should be based on clear hypotheses (potentially with stakeholder input), have covariates that match temporal and spatial scale of productivity processes, and have unexplained variability (i.e. process error) carefully scrutinized for patterns (e.g. nonstationarity) and projected accordingly. The second part of the paper identifies and describes methods for projecting environmental effects on productivity using climate models and without (i.e. altering productivity dynamics directly). Key tactical considerations are presented for designing OMs (e.g. include an OM with no climate forcing to benchmark results from OMs with forcing, devise edge cases for robustness) and evaluating management performance (e.g. define appropriate projection periods, consider dynamic reference points to calculate metrics). Despite the common use of single-species OMs, it is important to consider multispecies interactions, and fine-scale population and fishery dynamics, to better understand potential environmental effects on a target stock’s productivity. In summarizing key decision points and range of methods applied to date, this work serves to support informed choices and shared vocabulary for developing and conducting these MSEs, rather than a prescriptive checklist.
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Fisheries Research
- Vol. 299
Quantifying potential impacts of ocean-use sectors on biomass and density estimates for fisheries stock assessments
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Fisheries Research
- Vol. 299
Quantifying potential impacts of ocean-use sectors on biomass and density estimates for fisheries stock assessments
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 83, 1-19
Tuning into Tuna: investigating spatial complexity tradeoffs in stock assessment models based on a high-resolution simulation experiment of Yellowfin Tuna in the Indian Ocean
Understanding spatial heterogeneity is critical for improving fish stock assessments and sustainable management strategies, especially for highly migratory species such as Yellowfin Tuna ( Thunnus albacares). This study investigates trade-offs associated with incorporating spatial complexity into stock assessment models, using a high-resolution blinded simulation experiment based on Yellowfin Tuna in the Indian Ocean. We developed a suite of spatially structured assessment models within the Stock Synthesis 3 framework, incorporating recruitment apportionment, movement dynamics, tagging data, and standardized catch-per-unit-effort indices via Bayesian spatiotemporal models. Under the blinded design, a stepwise modeling process was first applied to a reference dataset to identify the preferred spatial configuration. Selected model steps were then evaluated across 100 stochastic replicates to assess their ability to reproduce the true operating model dynamics. Results highlight that simpler models captured population depletion trends better but substantially underestimated absolute stock size (SSB), whereas increasing spatial complexity greatly reduced SSB bias. Our findings emphasize the importance of balancing model complexity, realism, and management needs when developing stock assessments and offer recommendations for incorporating spatial processes.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 83, 1-19
Tuning into Tuna: investigating spatial complexity tradeoffs in stock assessment models based on a high-resolution simulation experiment of Yellowfin Tuna in the Indian Ocean
Understanding spatial heterogeneity is critical for improving fish stock assessments and sustainable management strategies, especially for highly migratory species such as Yellowfin Tuna ( Thunnus albacares). This study investigates trade-offs associated with incorporating spatial complexity into stock assessment models, using a high-resolution blinded simulation experiment based on Yellowfin Tuna in the Indian Ocean. We developed a suite of spatially structured assessment models within the Stock Synthesis 3 framework, incorporating recruitment apportionment, movement dynamics, tagging data, and standardized catch-per-unit-effort indices via Bayesian spatiotemporal models. Under the blinded design, a stepwise modeling process was first applied to a reference dataset to identify the preferred spatial configuration. Selected model steps were then evaluated across 100 stochastic replicates to assess their ability to reproduce the true operating model dynamics. Results highlight that simpler models captured population depletion trends better but substantially underestimated absolute stock size (SSB), whereas increasing spatial complexity greatly reduced SSB bias. Our findings emphasize the importance of balancing model complexity, realism, and management needs when developing stock assessments and offer recommendations for incorporating spatial processes.
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 83, 1-18
Random effects on numbers-at-age transitions implicitly account for movement dynamics and improve stock assessment and management
Implementing operational assessment models that account for spatial structure and movement dynamics is challenging, especially with limited tagging data. Random effects on numbers-at-age (NAA) transitions in state–space models offer a potential solution to circumvent direct movement estimation by attributing movement variation to NAA random effects. However, whether this approach reliably achieves desirable management outcomes remains unclear. In this study, we conducted a management strategy evaluation that emulated a generic medium-lived fish that exhibit natal homing dynamics, using assessment models with varying levels of spatial complexity. We compared the performance of each spatial implementation with and without NAA random effects to evaluate their effectiveness in achieving management outcomes. Our results showed that models with NAA random effects consistently outperformed those without, although the benefits of NAA random effects degraded at high rates of movement. Therefore, NAA random effects could serve as a practical intermediate solution when explicit movement modeling is not feasible due to insufficient movement information. Our findings suggest that incorporating NAA random effects should be a default starting point in state–space stock assessments.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 83, 1-18
Top Cited PapersRandom effects on numbers-at-age transitions implicitly account for movement dynamics and improve stock assessment and management
Implementing operational assessment models that account for spatial structure and movement dynamics is challenging, especially with limited tagging data. Random effects on numbers-at-age (NAA) transitions in state–space models offer a potential solution to circumvent direct movement estimation by attributing movement variation to NAA random effects. However, whether this approach reliably achieves desirable management outcomes remains unclear. In this study, we conducted a management strategy evaluation that emulated a generic medium-lived fish that exhibit natal homing dynamics, using assessment models with varying levels of spatial complexity. We compared the performance of each spatial implementation with and without NAA random effects to evaluate their effectiveness in achieving management outcomes. Our results showed that models with NAA random effects consistently outperformed those without, although the benefits of NAA random effects degraded at high rates of movement. Therefore, NAA random effects could serve as a practical intermediate solution when explicit movement modeling is not feasible due to insufficient movement information. Our findings suggest that incorporating NAA random effects should be a default starting point in state–space stock assessments.
- Open Access
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 27 (2) , 196-212
‘Building the (Im)perfect Beast’: Strategies for Identifying Appropriate Spatial Stock Assessment Model Complexity From an International, Blinded High‐Resolution Simulation Experiment
Despite their potential to inform sustainable regional harvest and climate‐resilient fisheries management, spatial stock assessment models remain underused for management advice. To identify barriers that inhibit broader use of these methods, we conducted a blinded international simulation experiment mimicking real‐world stock assessment development when confronting spatial complexity. Seven analyst teams built spatially aggregated and spatially explicit assessment models using data simulated from high‐resolution operating models based on Indian Ocean yellowfin tuna and Ross Sea Antarctic toothfish dynamics. Each team documented how assessment software platform, data analyses, model building approach, and diagnostics influenced model complexity and realism. A consensus emerged on key assessment building approaches: (1) conduct high‐resolution data analyses to identify appropriate spatial structure; (2) start with simplified models and incrementally add complexity; (3) iteratively evaluate diagnostics to determine necessary spatial complexity; and (4) maintain models with different spatial structures to aid interpretation. The experiment also revealed several valuable insights for parameterising assessments, including consideration of data pre‐processing with spatiotemporal models to better inform data‐sparse regions; regression trees to identify fleet and spatial structure; trade‐offs in complexity between productivity and movement dynamics to achieve tractable and stable model structures; and ensemble modelling approaches to address structural uncertainty. Our findings demonstrate that international collaborations and simulation experiments are crucial for addressing challenges in implementing spatial stock assessments and for evaluating whether their added complexity is justified given management objectives. Broader collaborations are encouraged to foster innovation in fisheries management and to help recognise the practical trade‐offs between model parsimony and complexity.
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 27 (2) , 196-212
Open Access‘Building the (Im)perfect Beast’: Strategies for Identifying Appropriate Spatial Stock Assessment Model Complexity From an International, Blinded High‐Resolution Simulation Experiment
Despite their potential to inform sustainable regional harvest and climate‐resilient fisheries management, spatial stock assessment models remain underused for management advice. To identify barriers that inhibit broader use of these methods, we conducted a blinded international simulation experiment mimicking real‐world stock assessment development when confronting spatial complexity. Seven analyst teams built spatially aggregated and spatially explicit assessment models using data simulated from high‐resolution operating models based on Indian Ocean yellowfin tuna and Ross Sea Antarctic toothfish dynamics. Each team documented how assessment software platform, data analyses, model building approach, and diagnostics influenced model complexity and realism. A consensus emerged on key assessment building approaches: (1) conduct high‐resolution data analyses to identify appropriate spatial structure; (2) start with simplified models and incrementally add complexity; (3) iteratively evaluate diagnostics to determine necessary spatial complexity; and (4) maintain models with different spatial structures to aid interpretation. The experiment also revealed several valuable insights for parameterising assessments, including consideration of data pre‐processing with spatiotemporal models to better inform data‐sparse regions; regression trees to identify fleet and spatial structure; trade‐offs in complexity between productivity and movement dynamics to achieve tractable and stable model structures; and ensemble modelling approaches to address structural uncertainty. Our findings demonstrate that international collaborations and simulation experiments are crucial for addressing challenges in implementing spatial stock assessments and for evaluating whether their added complexity is justified given management objectives. Broader collaborations are encouraged to foster innovation in fisheries management and to help recognise the practical trade‐offs between model parsimony and complexity.
- Open Access
- 6 October 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Climate
- Vol. 4 (10) , e0000624
Course corrections responding to climate impacts produce divergent effects on population biomass and harvest in fisheries
Climate change will alter ecological dynamics, affecting the relative abundance of species. A primary challenge is whether and how to modify natural resource management practices to address these changes. We explored a model of a harvested fish population experiencing climate-driven changes in demography, finding that climate impacts impose a choice between management strategies that favor fishery yield or population biomass but not both. When climate caused a population’s carrying capacity to increase, or its productivity to decrease, a climate adaptive strategy relying upon this updated information maintained higher population biomass but produced similar or lower yield than fixed management pegged to historical conditions. In contrast, when climate caused a population’s carrying capacity to decrease, or its productivity to increase, a climate adaptive strategy produced greater yield but maintained lower population biomass. Both strategies prevented a population from becoming overfished (too small to achieve maximum yield), but the fixed management strategy could impose more excessive annual harvest rates (overfishing). These insights suggest climate adaptive management may not always outperform a fixed strategy. Yet in U.S. fisheries we found routine assessment of population status modifies demographic parameters, implicitly shifting management reference points that affect fishery yield and population biomass. Participatory processes can illuminate these impacts, creating opportunities to co-develop weightings for conservation and harvest objectives.
- 6 October 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Climate
- Vol. 4 (10) , e0000624
Open AccessCourse corrections responding to climate impacts produce divergent effects on population biomass and harvest in fisheries
Climate change will alter ecological dynamics, affecting the relative abundance of species. A primary challenge is whether and how to modify natural resource management practices to address these changes. We explored a model of a harvested fish population experiencing climate-driven changes in demography, finding that climate impacts impose a choice between management strategies that favor fishery yield or population biomass but not both. When climate caused a population’s carrying capacity to increase, or its productivity to decrease, a climate adaptive strategy relying upon this updated information maintained higher population biomass but produced similar or lower yield than fixed management pegged to historical conditions. In contrast, when climate caused a population’s carrying capacity to decrease, or its productivity to increase, a climate adaptive strategy produced greater yield but maintained lower population biomass. Both strategies prevented a population from becoming overfished (too small to achieve maximum yield), but the fixed management strategy could impose more excessive annual harvest rates (overfishing). These insights suggest climate adaptive management may not always outperform a fixed strategy. Yet in U.S. fisheries we found routine assessment of population status modifies demographic parameters, implicitly shifting management reference points that affect fishery yield and population biomass. Participatory processes can illuminate these impacts, creating opportunities to co-develop weightings for conservation and harvest objectives.
- Open Access
- 24 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
Panmictic Panacea? Demonstrating Good Practices for Developing Spatial Stock Assessments Through Application to Alaska Sablefish (Anoplopoma fimbria)
Marine species and associated fisheries demonstrate complex spatial dynamics driven by biological, ecosystem and socioeconomic factors and integrating these spatial dynamics into stock assessment models can improve fishery management advice. While preliminary good practices for developing spatial stock assessment models have been proposed, comprehensive demonstrations applying these practices remain limited. Drawing on these good practices, we provide an end‐to‐end demonstration of developing a spatial stock assessment using Alaska sablefish (Anoplopoma fimbria). Our demonstration emphasises the utility of high‐resolution data analysis and conceptual models for informing key model structure decisions, the joint development of spatial and spatially‐aggregated models to enhance understanding of population dynamics, and the need for further guidance on integrating tagging data and diagnostic tools in spatial assessments. Spatial models highlighted regional differences in sablefish biomass, recruitment and age structure, but total population estimates generally aligned with outputs from spatially aggregated models. Moreover, the spatial model identified ontogenetic movement patterns for this highly mobile species. Overall, the spatially aggregated model for Alaska sablefish is likely adequate for management advice, but periodic spatial model updates could offer insights into spatial dynamics and regional depletion levels. Thus, we recommend concomitant use of both models: spatially aggregated models for informing population‐wide status, and spatial models for informing spatial fishery dynamics and local depletion. The sablefish application represents one of the first implementations of a spatial stock assessment using recently proposed good practices, serving as a valuable guide for future practitioners by underscoring critical decision points and analyses to address them when developing spatial stock assessments.
- 24 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
Open AccessPanmictic Panacea? Demonstrating Good Practices for Developing Spatial Stock Assessments Through Application to Alaska Sablefish (Anoplopoma fimbria)
Marine species and associated fisheries demonstrate complex spatial dynamics driven by biological, ecosystem and socioeconomic factors and integrating these spatial dynamics into stock assessment models can improve fishery management advice. While preliminary good practices for developing spatial stock assessment models have been proposed, comprehensive demonstrations applying these practices remain limited. Drawing on these good practices, we provide an end‐to‐end demonstration of developing a spatial stock assessment using Alaska sablefish (Anoplopoma fimbria). Our demonstration emphasises the utility of high‐resolution data analysis and conceptual models for informing key model structure decisions, the joint development of spatial and spatially‐aggregated models to enhance understanding of population dynamics, and the need for further guidance on integrating tagging data and diagnostic tools in spatial assessments. Spatial models highlighted regional differences in sablefish biomass, recruitment and age structure, but total population estimates generally aligned with outputs from spatially aggregated models. Moreover, the spatial model identified ontogenetic movement patterns for this highly mobile species. Overall, the spatially aggregated model for Alaska sablefish is likely adequate for management advice, but periodic spatial model updates could offer insights into spatial dynamics and regional depletion levels. Thus, we recommend concomitant use of both models: spatially aggregated models for informing population‐wide status, and spatial models for informing spatial fishery dynamics and local depletion. The sablefish application represents one of the first implementations of a spatial stock assessment using recently proposed good practices, serving as a valuable guide for future practitioners by underscoring critical decision points and analyses to address them when developing spatial stock assessments.
- Open Access
- 24 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 26 (5) , 809-824
The Pragmatic Sceptic: A Practical Approach for Integrating Environmental DNA Into Marine Stock Assessment and Fisheries Management
The ‘omics revolution’ has advanced scientific understanding of marine ecosystems and led to a rapid increase in data that can inform species' population structure, distribution, and abundance. Of the 'omics data types, environmental DNA (eDNA) may present the most cost‐effective opportunity for developing quantitative estimates of abundance trends, a key input for stock assessment models. However, eDNA has yet to be widely adopted for stock status determinations within regional fisheries management organisations. We review progress towards addressing key challenges that limited the application of eDNA in marine fisheries management, including advances in (1) the quantitative relationship between eDNA observations and species biomass, (2) reducing false‐negative and false‐positive detections, (3) defining the spatial scale of eDNA, (4) collecting biological data from eDNA surveys, (5) quantifying uncertainty in eDNA surveys, and (6) responding to scepticism of new survey methods. We use a case study with Pacific hake (Merluccius productus) to demonstrate the development of an eDNA index and its direct integration into an age‐structured stock assessment model. Given the many ways in which the field of eDNA has matured, we propose that eDNA can meaningfully inform a range of fisheries management needs, and outline a roadmap for using eDNA in stock assessment models in data‐limited to data‐rich species. A primary impediment to operationalising eDNA as stock assessment model inputs is the lack of interdisciplinary research teams, including geneticists, ecological modellers, and stock assessment scientists, which are necessary to interpret methods and results across scientific disciplines and ensure data are used appropriately.
- 24 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 26 (5) , 809-824
Open AccessThe Pragmatic Sceptic: A Practical Approach for Integrating Environmental DNA Into Marine Stock Assessment and Fisheries Management
The ‘omics revolution’ has advanced scientific understanding of marine ecosystems and led to a rapid increase in data that can inform species' population structure, distribution, and abundance. Of the 'omics data types, environmental DNA (eDNA) may present the most cost‐effective opportunity for developing quantitative estimates of abundance trends, a key input for stock assessment models. However, eDNA has yet to be widely adopted for stock status determinations within regional fisheries management organisations. We review progress towards addressing key challenges that limited the application of eDNA in marine fisheries management, including advances in (1) the quantitative relationship between eDNA observations and species biomass, (2) reducing false‐negative and false‐positive detections, (3) defining the spatial scale of eDNA, (4) collecting biological data from eDNA surveys, (5) quantifying uncertainty in eDNA surveys, and (6) responding to scepticism of new survey methods. We use a case study with Pacific hake (Merluccius productus) to demonstrate the development of an eDNA index and its direct integration into an age‐structured stock assessment model. Given the many ways in which the field of eDNA has matured, we propose that eDNA can meaningfully inform a range of fisheries management needs, and outline a roadmap for using eDNA in stock assessment models in data‐limited to data‐rich species. A primary impediment to operationalising eDNA as stock assessment model inputs is the lack of interdisciplinary research teams, including geneticists, ecological modellers, and stock assessment scientists, which are necessary to interpret methods and results across scientific disciplines and ensure data are used appropriately.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2024
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 25 (3) , 471-490
‘Drivin' with your eyes closed’: Results from an international, blinded simulation experiment to evaluate spatial stock assessments
Spatial models enable understanding potential redistribution of marine resources associated with ecosystem drivers and climate change. Stock assessment platforms can incorporate spatial processes, but have not been widely implemented or simulation tested. To address this research gap, an international simulation experiment was organized. The study design was blinded to replicate uncertainty similar to a real‐world stock assessment process, and a data‐conditioned, high‐resolution operating model (OM) was used to emulate the spatial dynamics and data for Indian Ocean yellowfin tuna (Thunnus albacares). Six analyst groups developed both single‐region and spatial stock assessment models using an assessment platform of their choice, and then applied each model to the simulated data. Results indicated that across all spatial structures and platforms, assessments were able to adequately recreate the population trends from the OM. Additionally, spatial models were able to estimate regional population trends that generally reflected the true dynamics from the OM, particularly for the regions with higher biomass and fishing pressure. However, a consistent population biomass scaling pattern emerged, where spatial models estimated higher population scale than single‐region models within a given assessment platform. Balancing parsimony and complexity trade‐offs were difficult, but adequate complexity in spatial parametrizations (e.g., allowing time‐ and age‐variation in movement and appropriate tag mixing periods) was critical to model performance. We recommend expanded use of high‐resolution OMs and blinded studies, given their ability to portray realistic performance of assessment models. Moreover, increased support for international simulation experiments is warranted to facilitate dissemination of methodology across organizations.
- 1 March 2024
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 25 (3) , 471-490
Open Access‘Drivin' with your eyes closed’: Results from an international, blinded simulation experiment to evaluate spatial stock assessments
Spatial models enable understanding potential redistribution of marine resources associated with ecosystem drivers and climate change. Stock assessment platforms can incorporate spatial processes, but have not been widely implemented or simulation tested. To address this research gap, an international simulation experiment was organized. The study design was blinded to replicate uncertainty similar to a real‐world stock assessment process, and a data‐conditioned, high‐resolution operating model (OM) was used to emulate the spatial dynamics and data for Indian Ocean yellowfin tuna (Thunnus albacares). Six analyst groups developed both single‐region and spatial stock assessment models using an assessment platform of their choice, and then applied each model to the simulated data. Results indicated that across all spatial structures and platforms, assessments were able to adequately recreate the population trends from the OM. Additionally, spatial models were able to estimate regional population trends that generally reflected the true dynamics from the OM, particularly for the regions with higher biomass and fishing pressure. However, a consistent population biomass scaling pattern emerged, where spatial models estimated higher population scale than single‐region models within a given assessment platform. Balancing parsimony and complexity trade‐offs were difficult, but adequate complexity in spatial parametrizations (e.g., allowing time‐ and age‐variation in movement and appropriate tag mixing periods) was critical to model performance. We recommend expanded use of high‐resolution OMs and blinded studies, given their ability to portray realistic performance of assessment models. Moreover, increased support for international simulation experiments is warranted to facilitate dissemination of methodology across organizations.