Comprehensive Safety Analysis of Ultimate Bearing Capacity Considering Hydraulic Fracture for Guxian High RCC Gravity Dam
Open Access
Abstract
The widespread adoption of high concrete gravity dams in China and globally underscores the necessity for enhancing design processes to address potential risks, notably hydraulic fracture. This study delves into this urgency by scrutinizing common design regulations and investigating the impact of hydraulic fracture on high concrete gravity dams. A comparative analysis of design specifications from China, the USA, and Switzerland, employing the gravity method, elucidates distinctions, focusing on the Guxian dam. In addition, evaluation of standards with higher resistance to hydraulic fracture was conducted using the Finite Element Method (FEM) with XFEM (eXtended Finite Element Method), employing initial cracks with different depths at the dam heel ranging from 0.2 to 2 m. The vulnerability of the Guxian dam’s cross-section to safety risks prompts further inquiry into the dam’s resistance to hydraulic fracture. Therefore, high-pressure water splitting risks to the ultimate bearing capacity were examined through FEM simulation and theoretical calculations. FEM simulations assessed the dam’s ultimate bearing capacity with and without automatic crack propagation combining the XFEM and overloading methods, particularly considering weak layers in the RCC (Roller-Compacted Concrete) dams. Theoretical calculations utilized a fracture mechanical evaluation model. This model derived mechanism formulas to assess the dam’s resistance to hydraulic fracture. Additionally, the investigation explored the effect of the uplift pressure on the ultimate overload coefficient. Findings indicated that the Guxian dam’s current cross-sectional area was insufficiently safe against hydraulic fracture, necessitating an increase to its cross-sectional area to 18,888.1 m2. Notably, the USA’s and Switzerland’s criteria exhibited greater resistance to hydraulic fracture than the Chinese criteria, especially without considering uplift pressure. Also, the Chinese regulations tended to calculate a lower dam cross-sectional area compared with the other regulations. Numerical calculations revealed a substantial decrease in overall dam safety (up to 48%) when considering automatic crack propagation and the dam’s weak layers. The fracture mechanical evaluation model showed that the Guxian dam had the lowest resistance, with an overloading coefficient of 1.05 considering the uplift pressure. In the case of not considering the uplift pressure, the dam resistance to hydraulic fracture increased and the overloading coefficient rose to 1.27. The results highlighted the risk of hydraulic fracture in concrete dams. Hence, it is recommended that design specifications of high concrete gravity dams incorporate safety analyses of hydraulic fracture in the design process. Reducing uplift pressure plays a crucial role in enhancing the dam’s resistance to hydraulic fractures, emphasizing the need for this consideration in safety evaluations. The differences between the three design specifications were particularly pronounced for dams higher than 200 m. In contrast, dams of 50 m yielded similar results across these regulations.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Investigation on the influence of high-pressure water environment on fracture performance of concreteConstruction and Building Materials, 2022
- XFEM Method for Crack Propagation in Concrete Gravity DamsJournal of The Institution of Engineers (India): Series A, 2022
- Experimental investigation on hydraulic fracturing in cement mortar with tensile stressEngineering Fracture Mechanics, 2022
- Heightening of Very High Gravity Dams: The Case Study of the Grande Dixence2020
- Influence of the water pressure distribution along crack faces on seismic fracture modeling of a dam-reservoir-foundation systemEngineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, 2019
- Horizontal cracking and crack repair analysis of a super high arch dam based on fracture toughnessEngineering Failure Analysis, 2019
- Coupling analysis of hydraulic fracturing computation base on element-free methodCluster Computing, 2017
- Experimental study on the influence of hydraulic fracturing on high concrete gravity damsEngineering Structures, 2017
- Analysis of hydraulic fracturing in concrete dam considering fluid–structure interaction using XFEM-FVM modelEngineering Failure Analysis, 2015
- Seismic cracking analysis of concrete gravity dams with initial cracks using the extended finite element methodEngineering Structures, 2013