Urgent issues and prospects in guilty plea research and practice
Open Access
- 26 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Legal and Criminological Psychology
- Vol. 30 (2) , 193-211
Abstract
Criminal legal systems around the world rely heavily on defendants foregoing their right to trial and pleading guilty. However, legal scholars, social scientists, and practitioners have identified and empirically examined numerous problems with pleas, such as the high potential for coercion, innocent defendants falsely pleading guilty, and undue incentives in exchange for accepting plea offer. In this article, leading guilty plea experts (practitioners and researchers) were asked to identify what they considered to be the most urgent questions surrounding pleas. Across nine commentaries, three primary themes emerged. First were calls for increased transparency in pleas, specific to rules of discovery and access to exculpatory information, and in uncovering the hidden nature of the plea negotiation process. Second were concepts of fairness and voluntariness, such as uncounseled pleas, particularly for misdemeanour defendants, and the dubious assumptions made by courts regarding the presumption of voluntariness. Third was the theme of fair and just outcomes, particularly false guilty pleas. Four of the commentaries focused on innocence, describing and encouraging more research on the factors that increase false guilty pleas, including excessive plea discounts, specialized sentencing offers for juvenile defendants, and ‘time‐served’ offers, either to induce initial guilty pleas (pre‐trial phase) or to avoid official exonerations of those wrongly convicted (post‐conviction phase). Across all commentaries, experts identified areas in need of future research, both in continuing to understand the problems known to plague systems of pleas and in developing improved methods to ensure the guilty plea process is transparent, voluntary, and just.Keywords
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- The decision to provide discovery: an examination of policies and guilty pleasJournal of Experimental Criminology, 2020
- State of the States: A survey of statutory law, regulations and court rules pertaining to guilty pleas across the United StatesBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2019
- Too young to plead? Risk, rationality, and plea bargaining’s innocence problem in adolescents.Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 2018
- The Bail Book2017
- The psychology of defendant plea decision making.American Psychologist, 2017
- Plea decision-making by attorneys and judgesJournal of Experimental Criminology, 2016
- Plea discounts, time pressures, and false-guilty pleas in youth and adults who pleaded guilty to felonies in New York City.Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 2016
- Self-reported false confessions and false guilty pleas among offenders with mental illness.Law and Human Behavior, 2010
- Charge reduction: An analysis of prosecutorial discretion in burglary and robbery casesJournal of Quantitative Criminology, 1992
- Streptococcal pharyngitis optimal site for throat cultureIndian Journal of Pediatrics, 1985