Oren Gazal-Ayal
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Oren Gazal-Ayal has a total of 30 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Oren Bar-Gill
2 shared publications- Ronen Perry
University of Haifa - Faculty of Law
2 shared publications Stephen M. Garcia
University of Michigan
2 shared publicationsAdir Solomon
Department of Information Systems, University of Haifa
1 shared publication- Allison D. Redlich
George Mason University
1 shared publication Annabelle Frazier
School of Criminal Justice, Forensic Science & Security University of Southern Mississippi Hattiesburg Mississippi USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Distinguishable but Undetected: True and False Confessions in Isolated Versus Comparative Evaluation Evidence From Authentic Police Confessions Judged by Prosecutors, Defense Attorneys, Civil Attorneys, and Laypeople
False confessions are a leading contributor to wrongful convictions. The criminal process is widely assumed to filter them out. Prosecutors, defense counsel, and courts are expected to recognize an unreliable confession when they see one. We test this diagnosticity assumption with authentic, full-length, video-recorded police confessions of known ground truth, drawn from a documented wrongful-arrest case, in two studies. In Study 1 (N = 344), laypeople, civil-practice attorneys, and three groups of criminal-justice specialists (defense attorneys, state prosecutors, and police prosecutors) each evaluated a single confession in isolation. No group could judge a confession's veracity above chance (overall accuracy = 50.6%, 95% CI [45.3, 55.8]; d′ near zero in every group; a pooled equivalence analysis capped the true-false difference at 8.2 percentage points, which corresponds to accuracy of at most ~54%, no better than ordinary unaided lie detection). About 64% would have convicted the demonstrably innocent suspect beyond a reasonable doubt, and those who convicted the innocent were no less confident than those who convicted the guilty. Willingness to convict varied with professional role-defense attorneys were the least willing and civil attorneys the most (OR = 3.40, p = .001)-but not with the confession's veracity. In Study 2 (N = 62), laypeople instead judged both confessions and identified which suspect was guilty. Here forced-choice discrimination was robust. Accuracy was 77.4% (p < .001), and on every measure, comparisons within the same evaluator favored the true confession on average (e.g., detail, M = 7.9 vs. 5.4, p < .001). The diagnostic cues were thus present in the confessions themselves, but became usable only under a direct comparison that the criminal process almost never affords. In practice, factfinders confront a single confession in isolation. True and false confessions were distinguishable in principle yet went undetected under the conditions in which confessions are actually judged. The failure of the diagnosticity assumption lies in the evaluative context, and it offers no reassurance about unaided human evaluation as a safeguard. We discuss implications for how confession evidence is assessed.
- 27 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessDistinguishable but Undetected: True and False Confessions in Isolated Versus Comparative Evaluation Evidence From Authentic Police Confessions Judged by Prosecutors, Defense Attorneys, Civil Attorneys, and Laypeople
False confessions are a leading contributor to wrongful convictions. The criminal process is widely assumed to filter them out. Prosecutors, defense counsel, and courts are expected to recognize an unreliable confession when they see one. We test this diagnosticity assumption with authentic, full-length, video-recorded police confessions of known ground truth, drawn from a documented wrongful-arrest case, in two studies. In Study 1 (N = 344), laypeople, civil-practice attorneys, and three groups of criminal-justice specialists (defense attorneys, state prosecutors, and police prosecutors) each evaluated a single confession in isolation. No group could judge a confession's veracity above chance (overall accuracy = 50.6%, 95% CI [45.3, 55.8]; d′ near zero in every group; a pooled equivalence analysis capped the true-false difference at 8.2 percentage points, which corresponds to accuracy of at most ~54%, no better than ordinary unaided lie detection). About 64% would have convicted the demonstrably innocent suspect beyond a reasonable doubt, and those who convicted the innocent were no less confident than those who convicted the guilty. Willingness to convict varied with professional role-defense attorneys were the least willing and civil attorneys the most (OR = 3.40, p = .001)-but not with the confession's veracity. In Study 2 (N = 62), laypeople instead judged both confessions and identified which suspect was guilty. Here forced-choice discrimination was robust. Accuracy was 77.4% (p < .001), and on every measure, comparisons within the same evaluator favored the true confession on average (e.g., detail, M = 7.9 vs. 5.4, p < .001). The diagnostic cues were thus present in the confessions themselves, but became usable only under a direct comparison that the criminal process almost never affords. In practice, factfinders confront a single confession in isolation. True and false confessions were distinguishable in principle yet went undetected under the conditions in which confessions are actually judged. The failure of the diagnosticity assumption lies in the evaluative context, and it offers no reassurance about unaided human evaluation as a safeguard. We discuss implications for how confession evidence is assessed.
- Open Access
- 21 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Justice Quarterly
- Vol. 43 (5) , 1-36
Evaluating Large Language Models as Judicial Decision-Makers
- 21 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Justice Quarterly
- Vol. 43 (5) , 1-36
Open AccessEvaluating Large Language Models as Judicial Decision-Makers
- Open Access
- 26 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Legal and Criminological Psychology
- Vol. 30 (2) , 193-211
Urgent issues and prospects in guilty plea research and practice
Criminal legal systems around the world rely heavily on defendants foregoing their right to trial and pleading guilty. However, legal scholars, social scientists, and practitioners have identified and empirically examined numerous problems with pleas, such as the high potential for coercion, innocent defendants falsely pleading guilty, and undue incentives in exchange for accepting plea offer. In this article, leading guilty plea experts (practitioners and researchers) were asked to identify what they considered to be the most urgent questions surrounding pleas. Across nine commentaries, three primary themes emerged. First were calls for increased transparency in pleas, specific to rules of discovery and access to exculpatory information, and in uncovering the hidden nature of the plea negotiation process. Second were concepts of fairness and voluntariness, such as uncounseled pleas, particularly for misdemeanour defendants, and the dubious assumptions made by courts regarding the presumption of voluntariness. Third was the theme of fair and just outcomes, particularly false guilty pleas. Four of the commentaries focused on innocence, describing and encouraging more research on the factors that increase false guilty pleas, including excessive plea discounts, specialized sentencing offers for juvenile defendants, and ‘time‐served’ offers, either to induce initial guilty pleas (pre‐trial phase) or to avoid official exonerations of those wrongly convicted (post‐conviction phase). Across all commentaries, experts identified areas in need of future research, both in continuing to understand the problems known to plague systems of pleas and in developing improved methods to ensure the guilty plea process is transparent, voluntary, and just.
- 26 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Legal and Criminological Psychology
- Vol. 30 (2) , 193-211
Open AccessUrgent issues and prospects in guilty plea research and practice
Criminal legal systems around the world rely heavily on defendants foregoing their right to trial and pleading guilty. However, legal scholars, social scientists, and practitioners have identified and empirically examined numerous problems with pleas, such as the high potential for coercion, innocent defendants falsely pleading guilty, and undue incentives in exchange for accepting plea offer. In this article, leading guilty plea experts (practitioners and researchers) were asked to identify what they considered to be the most urgent questions surrounding pleas. Across nine commentaries, three primary themes emerged. First were calls for increased transparency in pleas, specific to rules of discovery and access to exculpatory information, and in uncovering the hidden nature of the plea negotiation process. Second were concepts of fairness and voluntariness, such as uncounseled pleas, particularly for misdemeanour defendants, and the dubious assumptions made by courts regarding the presumption of voluntariness. Third was the theme of fair and just outcomes, particularly false guilty pleas. Four of the commentaries focused on innocence, describing and encouraging more research on the factors that increase false guilty pleas, including excessive plea discounts, specialized sentencing offers for juvenile defendants, and ‘time‐served’ offers, either to induce initial guilty pleas (pre‐trial phase) or to avoid official exonerations of those wrongly convicted (post‐conviction phase). Across all commentaries, experts identified areas in need of future research, both in continuing to understand the problems known to plague systems of pleas and in developing improved methods to ensure the guilty plea process is transparent, voluntary, and just.
- Open Access
- 7 October 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Social Inquiry
- Vol. 48 (3) , 847-880
How Minimum Sentences Benefit Offenders—The Case of Suspended Sentences
Legislatures often require a specific or minimal sentence be imposed if certain conditions are fulfilled. This study shows how such rules might benefit defendants. Israeli law requires that a suspended prison sentence be activated if the offender is reconvicted of a further offense during the term of suspension. Hence, the suspended sentence becomes a sort of minimum sentence for a breach offense. Yet judges are allowed to prolong the suspended term if, among other things, the breach offense is minor and hence does not result in a prison sentence. Using propensity score matching to analyze a rich database of magistrate court cases, we find that courts use the exception much more often than expected and, more importantly, that judges refrain from sentencing breaching defendants to prison, even if the breach offense justifies imprisonment, in order to circumvent the requirement to activate the suspended sentence. Moreover, for severe offenses, courts are less likely to sentence an offender to prison if the offender is in breach of a suspended sentence, compared to a similar offender who is not in such breach. For such offenses, being in breach of a suspended sentence reduces the likelihood of a prison sentence. For some offenders, the suspended sentence thus becomes a benefit rather than a punishment.
- 7 October 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Social Inquiry
- Vol. 48 (3) , 847-880
Open AccessHow Minimum Sentences Benefit Offenders—The Case of Suspended Sentences
Legislatures often require a specific or minimal sentence be imposed if certain conditions are fulfilled. This study shows how such rules might benefit defendants. Israeli law requires that a suspended prison sentence be activated if the offender is reconvicted of a further offense during the term of suspension. Hence, the suspended sentence becomes a sort of minimum sentence for a breach offense. Yet judges are allowed to prolong the suspended term if, among other things, the breach offense is minor and hence does not result in a prison sentence. Using propensity score matching to analyze a rich database of magistrate court cases, we find that courts use the exception much more often than expected and, more importantly, that judges refrain from sentencing breaching defendants to prison, even if the breach offense justifies imprisonment, in order to circumvent the requirement to activate the suspended sentence. Moreover, for severe offenses, courts are less likely to sentence an offender to prison if the offender is in breach of a suspended sentence, compared to a similar offender who is not in such breach. For such offenses, being in breach of a suspended sentence reduces the likelihood of a prison sentence. For some offenders, the suspended sentence thus becomes a benefit rather than a punishment.
- Open Access
- 23 July 2022
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
How Minimum Sentences Benefit Offenders – The Case of Suspended Sentences
Legislators often require that if certain conditions are fulfilled, a specific or minimal sentence is imposed. This study shows how such rules might benefit defendants. Israeli law requires that a suspended prison sentence be activated if the offender is reconvicted of a further offense during the term of suspension. Hence, the suspended sentence becomes a sort of minimum sentence for a breach offense. Yet judges are allowed to prolong the suspended term if, among other things, the breach offense is minor and hence does not result in a prison sentence. Using propensity score matching to analyze a rich database of magistrate court cases, we find that courts use the exception much more often than expected and, more importantly, that judges refrain from sentencing breaching defendants to prison, even if the breach offense justifies imprisonment, in order to circumvent the requirement to activate the suspended sentence. Moreover, for severe offenses, courts are less likely to sentence an offender to prison if the offender is in breach of a suspended sentence, compared to a similar offender who is not in such breach. For such offenses, being in breach of a suspended sentence reduces the likelihood of a prison sentence. For some offenders, the suspended sentence thus becomes a benefit rather than a punishment.
- 23 July 2022
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessHow Minimum Sentences Benefit Offenders – The Case of Suspended Sentences
Legislators often require that if certain conditions are fulfilled, a specific or minimal sentence is imposed. This study shows how such rules might benefit defendants. Israeli law requires that a suspended prison sentence be activated if the offender is reconvicted of a further offense during the term of suspension. Hence, the suspended sentence becomes a sort of minimum sentence for a breach offense. Yet judges are allowed to prolong the suspended term if, among other things, the breach offense is minor and hence does not result in a prison sentence. Using propensity score matching to analyze a rich database of magistrate court cases, we find that courts use the exception much more often than expected and, more importantly, that judges refrain from sentencing breaching defendants to prison, even if the breach offense justifies imprisonment, in order to circumvent the requirement to activate the suspended sentence. Moreover, for severe offenses, courts are less likely to sentence an offender to prison if the offender is in breach of a suspended sentence, compared to a similar offender who is not in such breach. For such offenses, being in breach of a suspended sentence reduces the likelihood of a prison sentence. For some offenders, the suspended sentence thus becomes a benefit rather than a punishment.
- 27 October 2017
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Plea-bargaining and prosecution
- 24 April 2015
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Political Science
- Vol. 60 (1) , 44-69
Descriptive Representation and Judicial Outcomes in Multiethnic Societies
The extent to which judicial outcomes depend on judges' identities is a central question in multiethnic societies. Past work on the impact of the racial composition of appellate courts has narrowly focused on civil rights cases in the United States. We expand this literature by testing for ethnicity‐based panel effects in criminal appeals in Israel. Using randomness in the assignment of cases to panels, we find that appeal outcomes for Jewish defendants are independent of panels' ethnic composition. By contrast, panel composition is highly consequential for Arab defendants, who receive more lenient punishments when their case is heard by a panel that includes at least one Arab judge, compared to all‐Jewish panels. The magnitude of these effects is sizable: a 14–20% reduction in incarceration and a 15–26% reduction in prison sentencing. These findings contribute to recent debates on the relationship between descriptive representation and substantive outcomes in judicial bodies.
- 24 April 2015
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Political Science
- Vol. 60 (1) , 44-69
Descriptive Representation and Judicial Outcomes in Multiethnic Societies
The extent to which judicial outcomes depend on judges' identities is a central question in multiethnic societies. Past work on the impact of the racial composition of appellate courts has narrowly focused on civil rights cases in the United States. We expand this literature by testing for ethnicity‐based panel effects in criminal appeals in Israel. Using randomness in the assignment of cases to panels, we find that appeal outcomes for Jewish defendants are independent of panels' ethnic composition. By contrast, panel composition is highly consequential for Arab defendants, who receive more lenient punishments when their case is heard by a panel that includes at least one Arab judge, compared to all‐Jewish panels. The magnitude of these effects is sizable: a 14–20% reduction in incarceration and a 15–26% reduction in prison sentencing. These findings contribute to recent debates on the relationship between descriptive representation and substantive outcomes in judicial bodies.
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Social Inquiry
- Vol. 39 (04) , 791-823
Imbalances of Power in ADR: The Impact of Representation and Dispute Resolution Method on Case Outcomes
In recent decades, alternative dispute resolution processes have gained worldwide recognition, a growing role in legal practice, and increasing academic attention. Despite their professed advantages, they have also faced fierce opposition. In a seminal article, Owen Fiss argued that ADR exacerbates imbalances of power between the parties. But while the theoretical argument has been widely developed, empirical evidence has remained scant. This article empirically examines the impact of representation patterns and dispute resolution methods on case outcomes. Arguably, professional representation of weaker parties may reduce the effects of inequality, whereas less formal, transparent, and adjudicatory processes may exacerbate them. The article focuses on small claims settlement conferences, using the Israeli labor courts system as a test case. The main findings are that representation increases the probability of a successful settlement conference, and that the more formal the process, the greater the ratio between the sum obtained by the plaintiff and the sum claimed.
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Social Inquiry
- Vol. 39 (04) , 791-823
Imbalances of Power in ADR: The Impact of Representation and Dispute Resolution Method on Case Outcomes
In recent decades, alternative dispute resolution processes have gained worldwide recognition, a growing role in legal practice, and increasing academic attention. Despite their professed advantages, they have also faced fierce opposition. In a seminal article, Owen Fiss argued that ADR exacerbates imbalances of power between the parties. But while the theoretical argument has been widely developed, empirical evidence has remained scant. This article empirically examines the impact of representation patterns and dispute resolution methods on case outcomes. Arguably, professional representation of weaker parties may reduce the effects of inequality, whereas less formal, transparent, and adjudicatory processes may exacerbate them. The article focuses on small claims settlement conferences, using the Israeli labor courts system as a test case. The main findings are that representation increases the probability of a successful settlement conference, and that the more formal the process, the greater the ratio between the sum obtained by the plaintiff and the sum claimed.
- 23 September 2013
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Israel Law Review
- Vol. 46 (3) , 455-479
Statutory Sentencing Reform in Israel: Exploring the Sentencing Law of 2012
In 2012 the Knesset approved a new sentencing law. Israel thus became the latest jurisdiction to introduce statutory directions for courts to follow in sentencing. The approach of the United States to structuring judicial discretion often entails the use of a sentencing grid with presumptive sentencing ranges. In contrast, the Sentencing Act of Israel reflects a less prescriptive method: it provides guidance by words rather than numbers. Retributivism is clearly identified as the penal philosophy underpinning the new law, which takes a novel approach to promoting more proportionate sentencing. Courts are directed to construct an individualised proportionate sentencing range appropriate to the case in hand. Once this is established, the court then follows additional directions regarding factors and principles related to sentencing. Although other jurisdictions have placed the purposes and principles of sentencing on a statutory footing, this is the first such legislative declaration in Israel. The statute also contains a methodology to implement a proportional approach to sentencing as well as detailed guidance on sentencing factors. This article describes and explores the new Sentencing Act, making limited comparisons to sentencing reforms in other jurisdictions – principally England and Wales, New Zealand and the United States. In concluding, we speculate on the likely consequences of the law: will it achieve the goals of promoting more consistent and principled sentencing?
- 23 September 2013
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Israel Law Review
- Vol. 46 (3) , 455-479
Statutory Sentencing Reform in Israel: Exploring the Sentencing Law of 2012
In 2012 the Knesset approved a new sentencing law. Israel thus became the latest jurisdiction to introduce statutory directions for courts to follow in sentencing. The approach of the United States to structuring judicial discretion often entails the use of a sentencing grid with presumptive sentencing ranges. In contrast, the Sentencing Act of Israel reflects a less prescriptive method: it provides guidance by words rather than numbers. Retributivism is clearly identified as the penal philosophy underpinning the new law, which takes a novel approach to promoting more proportionate sentencing. Courts are directed to construct an individualised proportionate sentencing range appropriate to the case in hand. Once this is established, the court then follows additional directions regarding factors and principles related to sentencing. Although other jurisdictions have placed the purposes and principles of sentencing on a statutory footing, this is the first such legislative declaration in Israel. The statute also contains a methodology to implement a proportional approach to sentencing as well as detailed guidance on sentencing factors. This article describes and explores the new Sentencing Act, making limited comparisons to sentencing reforms in other jurisdictions – principally England and Wales, New Zealand and the United States. In concluding, we speculate on the likely consequences of the law: will it achieve the goals of promoting more consistent and principled sentencing?
- Open Access
- 1 January 2011
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Non-Adjudicatory ADR, Representation, and Case Outcomes
In recent decades there has been increasing recognition of the importance of non-adjudicatory ADR, like mediation, conciliation, and settlement conferences. The
- 1 January 2011
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessNon-Adjudicatory ADR, Representation, and Case Outcomes
In recent decades there has been increasing recognition of the importance of non-adjudicatory ADR, like mediation, conciliation, and settlement conferences. The