Young children evaluate and follow others’ arguments when forming and revising beliefs
Authors:
Open Access
- 23 July 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Social Development
- Vol. 31 (1) , 147-164
Abstract
What do young children understand about arguments? Do they evaluate arguments critically when deciding whom to learn from? To address this question, we investigated children at age 4–5, when robust selective social learning is in place. In Studies 1a/b, children made an initial perceptual judgment regarding the location of an object under varying perceptual circumstances; then received advice by another informant who had better/worse perceptual access than them; and then made their final judgment. The advice by the other informant was sometimes accompanied by utterances of the form “I am certain … because I've seen it”. These utterances thus constituted good arguments in some conditions (informant could see clearly), but not in others (informant had poor perceptual access). Results showed that children evaluated argument quality in context‐sensitive ways and used them differentially for belief‐revision. They engaged in more belief‐revision when the informant gave this argument only when her perceptual condition, and thus her argument, was good. In Study 2, children were asked to find out about different properties (color/texture) of an object, and received conflicting testimony from two informants who supported their claims by utterances of the form “because I've seen it” (good argument regarding color/poor regarding texture) or “because I've felt it” (vice versa). Again, children engaged in context‐relative evaluation of argument quality, selectively learning from the agent with the appropriate argument. Taken together, these finding reveal that children from age 4 understand argument quality in sophisticated, context‐relative ways, and use this understanding for selective learning and belief‐revision.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Knowledge matters: How children evaluate the reliability of testimony as a process of rational inference.Psychological Review, 2013
- The power of well-connected arguments: Early sensitivity to the connective becauseJournal of Experimental Child Psychology, 2012
- Accuracy, confidence, and calibration: How young children and adults assess credibility.Developmental Psychology, 2011
- Young Children Have a Specific, Highly Robust Bias to Trust TestimonyPsychological Science, 2010
- Evidentiality and trust: The effect of informational goalsNew Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 2009
- Trust in Testimony: Children's Use of True and False StatementsPsychological Science, 2004
- Taking Advice: Accepting Help, Improving Judgment, and Sharing ResponsibilityOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1997
- Cueing and Cognitive Conflict in Judge-Advisor Decision MakingOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1995
- Young Children's Understanding of the Role That Sensory Experiences Play in Knowledge AcquisitionChild Development, 1992
- Development of justification in disputes with mother and sibling.Developmental Psychology, 1987