An Evaluation of Fracture Stabilization Comparing Kyphoplasty and Titanium Mesh Repair Techniques for Vertebral Compression Fractures
Authors:
- Thomas NunnTNThomas Nunn
- Claire RobertsonCRClaire Robertson
- Andrew MaharAMAndrew Mahar
- Yupo LeeYLYupo Lee
- Steven GarfinSGSteven Garfin
- 1 July 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Spine
- Vol. 35 (16) , E768-E773
Abstract
In vitro biomechanical investigation using human cadaveric vertebral bodies. To evaluate differences in biomechanical stability of vertebral compression fractures (VCFs) repaired using an expandable titanium mesh implant, with and without cement, as compared with standard balloon kyphoplasty. Vertebral augmentation, either in the form of vertebroplasty or kyphoplasty, is the treatment of choice for some VCFs. Polymethylmethacrylate, a common bone cement used in this procedure, has been shown to possibly cause injury to neural and vascular structures due to extravasation, embolization, and may be too rigid for an osteoporotic spine. Therefore, suitable alternatives for the treatment of VCFs have been sought. Individual vertebral bodies from 5 human cadaveric spines (from T4 to L5) were stripped of all soft tissues, and compressed at 25% of the intact height using methods previously described. Vertebral bodies were then randomly assigned to the following repair techniques: (1) conventional kyphoplasty, (2) titanium implant with cement, (3) titanium implant without cement. All vertebral bodies were then recompressed at 25% of the repaired height. Yield load, ultimate load, and stiffness were recorded and compared in these groups before and after treatment. There were no differences in biomechanical data between intact groups, and between repaired groups. In all 3 treatment groups, yield load and ultimate load of repaired vertebrae were similar to that of intact vertebrae. However, the stiffness following repair was found to be statistically less than the stiffness of the intact vertebral body (P < 0.05 for all comparisons). Based on the biomechanical data, the titanium mesh implant with or without cement was similar to polymethylmethacrylate fixation by kyphoplasty in the treatment of VCFs. Avoiding the adverse effects caused by using cement may be the main advantage of the titanium mesh implant and warrants further study.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Suitability of a Calcium Phosphate Cement in Osteoporotic Vertebral Body Fracture AugmentationSpine, 2009
- Biomechanical Evaluation of an Injectable Radiopaque Polypropylene Fumarate Cement for Kyphoplasty in a Cadaveric Osteoporotic Vertebral Compression Fracture ModelJournal of Spinal Disorders & Techniques, 2007
- Vertebral Augmentation With a Novel Vessel-X Bone Void Filling Container System and Bioactive Bone CementSpine, 2007
- Adjacent vertebral failure after vertebroplasty: a biomechanical study of low-modulus PMMA cementEuropean Spine Journal, 2007
- Biomechanical In Vitro Testing of Human Osteoporotic Lumbar Vertebrae Following Prophylactic Kyphoplasty With Different Candidate MaterialsSpine, 2007
- A biomechanical comparison of kyphoplasty using a balloon bone tamp versus an expandable polymer bone tamp in a deer spine modelThe Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volume, 2007
- Percutaneous vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty for the stand‐alone augmentation of osteoporosis‐induced vertebral compression fractures: Present status and future directionsJournal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials, 2006
- Kyphoplasty: Vertebral Augmentation for Compression FracturesClinics in Geriatric Medicine, 2006
- Vertebroplasty Versus Kyphoplasty: Biomechanical Behavior Under Repetitive Loading ConditionsSpine, 2006
- Vertebral fractures.BMJ, 1992