Improving the consistency of usage labelling in dictionaries with TEI Lex?0
Open Access
- 20 November 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Lexicography
- Vol. 6 (2) , 133-156
Abstract
This paper analyzes the application of usage labels in three representative lexicographic works, namely the Portuguese, Spanish, and French Academy Dictionaries as a starting point for creating a consistent classifcation of usage labels and their encoding in accordance with TEI Lex-0. The use of labels is not always entirely consistent within individual dictionaries and even less so across diferent lexicographic projects. This makes the tasks of accurately classifying and encoding them quite diffcult. This difculty is compounded by the diferences and partial incompatibilities found in the lexicographic literature on the treatment of diasystemic information. We address the existing literature and the initial classifcation of TEI Lex-0, and argue for the need to introduce some changes to TEI Lex-0, most notably in terms of diatextual labels. Finally, we argue that the existing classifcations based on examples rather than on clear and explicit defnitions of classifcation categories will always lack in precision and lead to mutually incompatible encodings of diferent dictionaries. We propose a set of defnitions for usage label categories that can be adopted by TEI Lex-0 and used in other similar attempts to create interoperable lexical resources. An agreement on usage label categories is a frst and necessary step before proceeding in the direction of harmonizing and standardizing the actual values of usage labels across various dictionaries and across diferent languages.Keywords
Funding Information
- FCT (UID/LIN/03213/2019)
- H2020 ELEXIS (No 731015)
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Academy Dictionaries 1600–18002014
- Problems of Usage Labelling in English LexicographyLexikos, 2012
- The Oxford Guide to Practical Lexicography2008
- Bilingual Lexicography from a Communicative Perspective2007
- Manual of Specialised Lexicography1995
- DISCUSSION PAPER: RESTRICTIVE LABELS?DESCRIPTIVE OR PRESCRIPTIVE?Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1973