Repeatability of Pulse Oximetry Measurements in Children During Triage in Two Ugandan Hospitals
Authors:
- Ahmad AsdoAAAhmad Asdo
- Alishah MawjiAMAlishah Mawji
- Collins AgabaCACollins Agaba
- Clare KomugishaCKClare Komugisha
- Stefanie K NovakowskiSNStefanie K Novakowski
- Yashodani PillayYPYashodani Pillay
- Stephen KaumuSKStephen Kaumu
- Matthew O WiensMWMatthew O Wiens
- Abner TagoolaATAbner Tagoola
- Niranjan KissoonNKNiranjan Kissoon
- J Mark AnserminoJAJ Mark Ansermino
Preprint
Abstract
Background: In low- and middle-income countries, health workers use pulse oximeters for intermittent spot measurements of SpO 2 . However, the accuracy and reliability when used for spot measurements has not been determined. We evaluated the repeatability of spot measurements, and the ideal observation time of measurement to guide recommendations during spot check measurements. Methods: Two one-minute measurements were done for the 3,903 subjects enrolled in the study, collecting 1Hz SpO 2 and signal quality index (SQI) data. The repeatability between the two measurements was assessed using an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), calculated using a median of all seconds of non-zero SpO 2 values for each recording (any quality, Q1), and again with a quality filter only using seconds with SQI ≥ 90% (good quality, Q2). The ICC was also calculated for both these conditions using subsets of the minute, in increasing increments of 5 seconds, up to the whole minute. Lastly, the whole minute ICC was calculated with good quality (Q2), including only records where both measurements had a mean SQI > 70% (Q3). Findings: The repeatability ICC with condition Q1 was 0.591 (95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.570, 0.611). Using only the first 5 seconds of each measurement reduced the repeatability to 0.200 (95% CI = 0.169, 0.230). Filtering with Q2, the whole minute ICC was 0.855 (95% CI = 0.847, 0.864). The ICC did not improve beyond the first 35 seconds. For Q3, the repeatability rose to 0.908 (95% CI = 0.901, 0.914). Conclusions: Training guidelines must emphasize the importance of signal quality and duration of measurement, targeting a minimum of 35 seconds of adequate-quality, stable data. In addition, the design of new devices should incorporate user prompts and force quality checks to encourage more accurate pulse oximetry measurement. Trial Registration: Clinical Trials.gov Identifier: NCT04304235 , Registered 11 March 2020.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Digital technologies in the public-health response to COVID-19Nature Medicine, 2020
- Smart triage: triage and management of sepsis in children using the point-of-care Pediatric Rapid Sepsis Trigger (PRST) toolBMC Health Services Research, 2020
- Performance, Acceptability, and Usability of Respiratory Rate Timers and Pulse Oximeters When Used by Frontline Health Workers to Detect Symptoms of Pneumonia in Sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia: Protocol for a Two-Phase, Multisite, Mixed-Methods TrialJMIR Research Protocols, 2018
- Correction: Development and Internal Validation of a Predictive Model Including Pulse Oximetry for Hospitalization of Under-Five Children in BangladeshPLOS ONE, 2016
- Pulse oximetryCritical Care, 2015
- Variability in estimating shunt from single pulse oximetry measurementsPhysiological Measurement, 2015
- Pulse oximetry in low-resource settingsBreathe, 2012
- Development of the Respiratory Index of Severity in Children (RISC) Score among Young Children with Respiratory Infections in South AfricaPLOS ONE, 2012
- Pulse oximetry: technology to reduce child mortality in developing countriesPaediatrics and International Child Health, 2009
- Some comments on the repeatability of measurementsRinging & Migration, 1994