The coupled uncertainties in carbon dioxide removal and transient climate response to cumulative CO 2 emissions
Open Access
- 18 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (2)
Abstract
Meeting Paris Agreement targets increasingly points to a need for Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) from the atmosphere. While CDR seems promising, the associated uncertainties are not well known. One unexplored aspect is whether the uncertainties in CDR and transient climate response to cumulative CO 2 emissions (TCRE) are coupled to any degree, e.g. some CDR method could have lower carbon removal potential if TCRE is high. In this paper, we quantify the coupled uncertainties between TCRE and the CDR of ocean alkalinity enhancement and reforestation. To do so, we used a perturbed parameter ensemble with the University of Victoria Earth System Climate Model. These results were fed to train Kernel Flows-based model emulators, which in turn were used, together with observational data, to carry out Markov Chain Monte Carlo simulations to characterize Bayesian posterior distributions. It turns out that ocean alkalinity enhancement results in slow but steady CDR, with temperature reduction nearly linearly related to the amount of carbon removed. CDR with ocean alkalinity enhancement is also only weakly dependent on uncertain climate system parameters and TCRE, indicating ocean alkalinity enhancement is a reliable CDR method with respect to the coupled uncertainties between its removal potential and TCRE. CDR of reforestation slows down after 50 years, and its temperature reduction from biogeochemical effects is offset by the warming biogeophysical effects, as reforesting pastures lowers albedo. Moreover, CDR by reforestation shows a strong dependency on uncertain climate system parameters and negatively correlates with TCRE, implying that it is less reliable as a CDR method. We argue that CDR potential, timescale of CDR, and uncertainty coupling between TCRE and CDR should all be considered when designing robust climate change mitigation portfolios.Keywords
Funding Information
- Research Council of Finland (331764)
- Research Council of Finland (359342)
- European Union’s Horizon Research and Innovation Program 2020 (869357)
- National Aeronautics and Space Administration (80NM0018D0004)
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- The problem of permanence for carbon sequestration in forestsMitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change, 2023
- Broaden Research on Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement to Better Characterize Social ImpactsEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2023
- On economic modeling of carbon dioxide removal: values, bias, and norms for good policy-advising modelingGlobal Sustainability, 2022
- Carbon removals from nature restoration are no substitute for steep emission reductionsOne Earth, 2022
- Increasing River Alkalinity Slows Ocean Acidification in the Northern Gulf of MexicoGeophysical Research Letters, 2021
- A perturbed parameter ensemble of HadGEM3-GC3.05 coupled model projections: part 1: selecting the parameter combinationsClimate Dynamics, 2021
- Negative-emissions technology portfolios to meet the 1.5 °C targetGlobal Environmental Change, 2021
- An Updated Assessment of Near‐Surface Temperature Change From 1850: The HadCRUT5 Data SetJournal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 2021
- Land-based negative emissions: risks for climate mitigation and impacts on sustainable developmentInternational Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics, 2017
- Assessing ocean alkalinity for carbon sequestrationReviews of Geophysics, 2017