TETommi Ekholm

Tommi Ekholm

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Tommi Ekholm has a total of 93 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The Impact on Future Energy Cost From Biomass Availability: A Model-Based Assessment of European Policies on Energy and Biodiversity

    by Lina Reichenberg, Markus Millinger, Tommi Ekholm, Fredrik Hedenus

    Biomass is widely seen as essential for decarbonization, providing renewable energy, carbon-based fuels, and negative emissions, but rising land-use and biodiversity concerns are increasing pressure to restrict its use in Europe. Using a sector-coupled energy system model of Europe (PyPSA-Eur-Sec), we quantify the cost consequences of solid biomass scarcity under net-zero emissions targets across alternative technology futures. Restricting biomass availability from present-day levels to a severely constrained level increases total European system costs by 14–28%, with biomass used primarily for liquid fuels and industrial heat rather than electricity. The magnitude of this cost increase depends strongly on the maturity of substitute technologies: scarcity is most costly when hydrogen and electrofuel production remain expensive or inefficient, more so than when carbon storage or renewable electricity deployment is constrained. These results indicate that policies restricting biomass use should be paired with support for alternative carbon-neutral fuel pathways.

  • Open Access

    A new approach to determine national greenhouse gas budgets

    by Antti-Ilari Partanen, Tommi Ekholm, Jyri Seppälä, Sally Weaver, Taru Palosuo, Giacomo Grassi, Chris Smith, Kati Kulovesi, Hannele Laine, Markku Ollikainen

    We propose a new approach to determine national greenhouse gas (GHG) budgets that are collectively consistent with the 1.5° C goal of the Paris Agreement and compatible with the accounting method of national GHG inventories. Our approach is designed to bridge global mitigation assessments and national GHG inventory accounting, enabling fair and transparent Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) aligned with a given temperature goal. It is flexible, allowing the use of different equity principles and timeframes. GHG budgets are based on a fair share of the allowable warming contributions of GHG emissions. The approach translates the CO 2 -warming-equivalent GHG budget to be compatible with national GHG inventories by applying adjustment terms for non-CO 2 GHG emissions and anthropogenic emissions from land use, land-use change, and the forestry (LULUCF) sector. The adjustment term for non-CO 2 GHGs equals the bias introduced to estimate CO 2 -warming-equivalent emissions using Global Warming Potentials. The adjustment term for emissions in the LULUCF sector equals the projected indirect effects on managed lands due to climate change and CO 2 fertilization. These adjustments can be made either at the global or national level, leading to different national GHG budgets, depending on the country’s mix of non-CO 2 GHG emissions and projected indirect effects. We demonstrate this by showing that Finland’s GHG budget is much larger if the adjustments are made at the global level compared to the national level, resulting from high non-CO 2 GHG emissions and indirect effects. Nationally adjusted GHG budgets are consistent with countries’ fair share of warming contributions, but GHG budgets with global-level adjustments are less sensitive to modeling uncertainty in indirect effects and scenario uncertainty of national non-CO 2 GHG emissions. Our approach helps improve the Global Stocktake of NDCs and assess the long-term climate strategies of the signatory countries of the Paris Agreement.

  • Open Access

    Sensitivity of global land-based mitigation potential to land-use scenarios and interactions across sectors

    by Nadine-Cyra Freistetter, Tommi Ekholm, Ilkka Keppo, Antti-Ilari Partanen

    Land-based climate change mitigation can help limit global warming to well below 2 °C but requires balancing with food production, nature conservation, and biomaterial supply. Previous studies identified major trade-offs between these but limited the analysis to fairly few dimensions of uncertainty. Using the SuCCESs integrated assessment model, we quantified global total and land-based mitigation potentials, sensitivities, and interactions across six key dimensions. The 864 scenarios between 2020 and 2100 varied assumptions for drivers of land utilisation: emission pricing, diets, food distribution, conservation, biomaterial demand, and wildfire activity. Mitigation options included actions across land, energy, and material systems, spanning forestation, halting deforestation, adjusting forest rotation, residue management, shifting agricultural and forestry systems, and substituting fossil fuels with bioenergy or BECCS. Limiting warming to 1.5–2 °C required the agriculture, forestry, and land-use (AFOLU) sector to contribute 500–1,700 GtCO 2 e of mitigation and supply 100–140 EJ of bioenergy annually. Peak AFOLU mitigation occurred under globally vegan diets combined with emission pricing that incentivised afforestation of freed pastureland. Trade-offs between forestation and biomass production mostly remained, with SuCCESs favouring afforestation over bioenergy. Biodiversity conservation and emission pricing targeted overlapping mitigation areas, offering no combined benefit. High timber demand reduced mitigation potential and increased biodiversity loss, while reduced paper demand avoided the most deforestation but offered limited climate benefits. Slight variations in wildfire prevalence had little impact. Our findings highlight the need for integrated policies that manage land competition and account for policy interactions to fully unlock land-based mitigation potential.

  • Open Access

    Exploring global, economy-wide material trajectories and associated environmental pressures under shared socioeconomic pathways

    by Tommi Ekholm, Saana Springare, Hannu Savolainen, Jan Streeck, Dominik Wiedenhofer

    Material production is a major contributor to many environmental challenges, but has received limited attention in the global, long-term scenarios produced by integrated assessment models (IAMs) used to investigate humankind’s potential responses. Here, we quantify economy-wide material stocks and flows for the shared socio-economic pathways (SSPs) and a low material demand scenario (LMD) using a simplified but physically consistent approach developed to the SuCCESs IAM, based on empirically observed material stock intensities of the global economy and the detailed, economy-wide stock-flow modelling of MISO2. Demand for material stocks is then translated to the material production, recycling and final waste disposal flows, parametrized from the MISO2 model. Implications for energy use, CO 2 emissions, land use and human appropriation of net primary production are quantified via the SuCCESs IAM. We find that economy-wide material stocks grow substantially in all scenarios between 2020 and 2100—from +55% in LMD, to a nine-fold increase in SSP5. Stabilization or gradual reduction of material production and related environmental pressures only occur when low economic growth is combined with strong decoupling of GDP from material stocks. Material production volumes of major materials, e.g. steel and concrete, grow in all scenarios except LMD. Without active mitigation, the environmental impacts from material production continue to increase in all but the SSP3 and LMD scenarios, in which the impacts remain stable or decline even without deliberate action to reduce them. Conversely, with moderately or strongly growing GDP and only slightly declining material stock intensity, material production would grow immensely, requiring significant effort to mitigate the related environmental pressures. Waste accumulation will continue to grow for at least several decades due to the inherent lag in material flow dynamics.


  • Open Access

    Modelling the electricity system in Integrated Assessment Models - a time-series clustering approach for diverse futures

    by Tuukka Mattlar, Tommi Ekholm

    The growing role of variable renewable electricity calls for high time resolution when modeling the electricity sector. However, this can be computationally too expensive for models that combine different sectors and run over long timeframes, such as Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs). The computational burden can be reduced by e.g. timeslicing or time-series clustering. Clustering approaches have the benefit of maintaining chronology and thus enabling electricity storage modeling; but what hourly-level features clustering should capturefor the diverse long-term scenarios calculated with IAMs has remained unclear. This paper has a two-fold contribution to address these challenges. First, we propose an hourly-resolution electricity sub-model for IAMs that links with the annual level of the model, and uses time-series clustering to reduce the computational burden. Second, we propose a new clustering method – the multi-scenario clustering – that functions robustly across a range of future scenarios that might be calculated with an IAM. In this method, output from multiple model runs covering different future scenarios are used in clustering to define representative periods. Our results show that for a wide range of future scenarios, this approach produces a clustering that works nearly as accurately as a-posteriori clustering tailored for each scenario individually. Therefore, the multi-scenario clustering approach provides a robust way to save on computational burden while offering a relatively good level of accuracy in comparison to using the full, hourly time-horizon, which would be prohibitively costly to use in IAMs.

  • Open Access

    The coupled uncertainties in carbon dioxide removal and transient climate response to cumulative CO 2 emissions

    by Carla Maria Di Natale, Theresa Schaber, Giang Tran, Jouni Susiluoto, David Keller, Tommi Ekholm, Antti-Ilari Partanen

    Meeting Paris Agreement targets increasingly points to a need for Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) from the atmosphere. While CDR seems promising, the associated uncertainties are not well known. One unexplored aspect is whether the uncertainties in CDR and transient climate response to cumulative CO 2 emissions (TCRE) are coupled to any degree, e.g. some CDR method could have lower carbon removal potential if TCRE is high. In this paper, we quantify the coupled uncertainties between TCRE and the CDR of ocean alkalinity enhancement and reforestation. To do so, we used a perturbed parameter ensemble with the University of Victoria Earth System Climate Model. These results were fed to train Kernel Flows-based model emulators, which in turn were used, together with observational data, to carry out Markov Chain Monte Carlo simulations to characterize Bayesian posterior distributions. It turns out that ocean alkalinity enhancement results in slow but steady CDR, with temperature reduction nearly linearly related to the amount of carbon removed. CDR with ocean alkalinity enhancement is also only weakly dependent on uncertain climate system parameters and TCRE, indicating ocean alkalinity enhancement is a reliable CDR method with respect to the coupled uncertainties between its removal potential and TCRE. CDR of reforestation slows down after 50 years, and its temperature reduction from biogeochemical effects is offset by the warming biogeophysical effects, as reforesting pastures lowers albedo. Moreover, CDR by reforestation shows a strong dependency on uncertain climate system parameters and negatively correlates with TCRE, implying that it is less reliable as a CDR method. We argue that CDR potential, timescale of CDR, and uncertainty coupling between TCRE and CDR should all be considered when designing robust climate change mitigation portfolios.


  • Open Access

    Solving decision problems with endogenous uncertainty and conditional information revelation using influence diagrams

    by Olli Herrala, Tommi Ekholm, Fabricio Oliveira

    Mathematical programming formulations of influence diagrams can bridge the gap between representing and solving decision problems. However, they suffer from both modeling and computational limitations. Aiming to address modeling limitations, we show how to incorporate conditionally observed information within the mathematical programming representation of the influence diagram. Multi-stage stochastic programming models use conditional non-anticipativity constraints to represent such uncertainties, and we show how such constraints can be incorporated into the influence diagram formulations. This allows us to consider the two main types of endogenous uncertainty simultaneously, namely decision-dependent information structure and decision-dependent probability distribution. Additionally, we apply a subdiagram decomposition to improve both computational efficiency and modeling capabilities. Under suitable conditions, this decomposition allows for considering continuous decision variables arising from, e.g., investment sizing decisions, leading to better solutions than a discretization of the continuous decisions. Finally, our proposed framework is illustrated with a large-scale cost-benefit problem regarding climate change mitigation, simultaneously considering technological research and development, and optimal emission trajectories.

  • Open Access

    SuCCESs – a global IAM for exploring the interactions between energy, materials, land use, and climate systems in long-term scenarios (model version 2024-10-23)

    by Tommi Ekholm, Nadine-Cyra Freistetter, Tuukka Mattlar, Theresa Schaber, Aapo Rautiainen

    SuCCESs (Sustainable Climate Change mitigation strategies in Energy–land–material Systems) is a bottom-up integrated assessment model (IAM) that represents energy production and use, materials production, land use, and climate globally. The primary use case for SuCCESs is to calculate long-term scenarios until 2100 that consider the interactions between these systems, for example, the greenhouse gas emissions from energy, materials, and land use and their impact on climate change. The four systems are hard-linked in SuCCESs, and scenarios are solved through intertemporal optimization by minimizing discounted system costs to satisfy projected demand and other constraints, e.g. climate targets. This yields a long-term equilibrium solution between the modelled systems. This article introduces the model logic and structure, describes the overall representation of each system, and provides an evaluation by comparing the scenarios produced by SuCCESs with different end-of-century radiative forcing targets to those from other IAMs. Towards this end and to demonstrate the capability of SuCCESs for large-scale scenario exploration, we also conduct a sensitivity analysis employing Monte Carlo sampling with a 1000-member scenario ensemble for each radiative forcing target. Lastly, we discuss some practical aspects and different ways of using the model in long-term scenario analyses.