We study how observable characteristics of information sources shape individuals' evaluations of their content. In an online experiment, we vary source characteristics while holding content constant. We find that disclosing these characteristics leaves both the content's perceived accuracy and the willingness to share it largely unaffected but substantially shapes trust in the source. Highly educated sources are trusted more; disclosing low education, popularity, and Republican affiliation each reduces trust. Participants sort across sources based on observable characteristics even before seeing any content, suggesting that source cues serve as credibility signals that influence who is trusted and heard.